United's biggest problem - Our spoiled and overly entitled fan base

Shark

@NotShark
Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
20,793
Location
Ireland
In fairness I said sensible not positive

No one I know is saying we’ll win the league - far from it in fact.

What I mean is that they’re willing to give Ole a chance, are happy we are focussing on youth and are glad to see us rid of divas like Pogba.

Yes but this is what I mean, positivity cannot always be tied to sensibility. Pogba is probably our best player, so selling him probably isn’t in our best interest if we actually want to build a team that’s capable of competing with the best. Focusing on youth? I’m all for youth but imo this isn’t the summer to do that, you focus on youth when you already have a functioning team with leaders that are winning major trophies. What we needed is two or three world class talents or at least on the cusp, with the right personality and attitude. Liverpool signed Salah and Mane to enhance their attack, we’ve so far signed one championship winger and Lingard, Mata and Martial still hanging around without a worry in the world when they simply haven’t delivered for years. Ole is still to win me over tbh, I’m not going to blindly pretend that everything is going to be ok when our final game last season had us losing 0-2 to a relegated side, at home. Trust needs to be earned, being a legend of the club on the pitch has little to do with his ability as a manager.
 

desirere

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 26, 2013
Messages
154
Location
Rijeka
I’m a little surprised we’re bottom on that. I thought it would have been much worse.
I think you missed a trick there or white text missing xD There is literally not a worse situation at any club in the footballing World in that regard. Maybe some NBA or NFL teams... but just maybe...
 

Saffron

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
628
:drool:

I like to imagine someone reading the threads on the front page, getting to mine and just sighing a big sigh of relief.
Yeah, Woodward and the Glazers. They probably can’t believe their luck having stumbled in to such a subservient and obedient fan base. They’ve overseen one of the most dramatic declines of a top team in sports history and we just continue to make excuses for them.

The likes of Leeds seem worse on the surface but they were always a glass giant stretching their resources too thin. We were genuinely the biggest club in the world with the world’s highest revenue when they took over.
 
Last edited:

passing-wind

Full Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
1,639
:lol: Solskjaer had better hope he's still in his job this time next year because if he fails top 4, the "disillusionment" will quantify his reality.
 

AllezLesDiables

Full Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
1,762
The distortion campaign that is carrying on is hilarious.

Yeah, it’s the fans fault that United is in a state of shite despite selling out every game at OT. What a load of bollocks.

It’s not Woodward’s fault is the other hilarious distortion campaign being promoted on the boards as if the CEO title is a figurehead title and a DoF with autonomy is in place.

How this club being run reminds of one my former employers, a Fortune 500 company, who ran their company like absolute shit with numerous scandals, which led the company to go from public to private.

They were even spinning that going from a publicly traded company to a privately owned company was a good thing.

The fans should be more outraged than they are at this moment. The owners are using this team as their own personal slush fund.
 
Last edited:

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
1,415
I wouldn't say its exclusively the fans fault no, but they are certainly playing a massive part in the unrest and down fall of the side I think.

From chants of "attack, attack, attack" at most games still on going, our supporters booing and abusing players like Fellaini and Pogba during matches and the latter receiving horrific abuse towards the end of the season last. Supporters chanting for Jose with LVG sat in the bench. Fellaini being booed coming on in a CL Qualifying match only to silence them with a goal.

Supporters seem to think if they pay for a match ticket that gives them entitlement to be abusive, guess what folks...it doesn't.

When Ole came in, we needed to draw a line in the sand and move on but unfortunately too many continued to use Mourinho's "blame anyone but me" philosophy and continued to constantly attack the players which has lead to some of the players becoming disenfranchised with the club. Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.

I want players committed to the club like any supporter but a part of me as well doesn't blame him for wanting out if supporters spend years giving him abuse every game.

No doubt I'll get a flurry of replies now saying Real wouldn't stand for this, but the same people who'd say this will also run to a thread about Reals supporters and say they are scum for how they treat their players :rolleyes:
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
3,731
I wouldn't say its exclusively the fans fault no, but they are certainly playing a massive part in the unrest and down fall of the side I think.

From chants of "attack, attack, attack" at most games still on going, our supporters booing and abusing players like Fellaini and Pogba during matches and the latter receiving horrific abuse towards the end of the season last. Supporters chanting for Jose with LVG sat in the bench. Fellaini being booed coming on in a CL Qualifying match only to silence them with a goal.

Supporters seem to think if they pay for a match ticket that gives them entitlement to be abusive, guess what folks...it doesn't.

When Ole came in, we needed to draw a line in the sand and move on but unfortunately too many continued to use Mourinho's "blame anyone but me" philosophy and continued to constantly attack the players which has lead to some of the players becoming disenfranchised with the club. Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.

I want players committed to the club like any supporter but a part of me as well doesn't blame him for wanting out if supporters spend years giving him abuse every game.

No doubt I'll get a flurry of replies now saying Real wouldn't stand for this, but the same people who'd say this will also run to a thread about Reals supporters and say they are scum for how they treat their players :rolleyes:

The fans chant attack attack attack when the team is 0-0 at home to Cardiff with 2 shots on goal. It is like paying a top end builder top dollar only to do a cowboy's job? I am sure you wont be happy with that?

So you think the only reason Pogba is asking for a move is because of a handful of supporters abusing him on the final day of the season? you truly are deluded.

Pogba is a huge talent with a money hungry agent who only cares about his bonus. We paid our record fee for Pogba, with great wages, you expect him to lead the team against the Huddersfield and Cardiff's, drag the team, not moan and throw his hands in the air mid game.
 

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
1,415
The fans chant attack attack attack when the team is 0-0 at home to Cardiff with 2 shots on goal. It is like paying a top end builder top dollar only to do a cowboy's job? I am sure you wont be happy with that?

So you think the only reason Pogba is asking for a move is because of a handful of supporters abusing him on the final day of the season? you truly are deluded.

Pogba is a huge talent with a money hungry agent who only cares about his bonus. We paid our record fee for Pogba, with great wages, you expect him to lead the team against the Huddersfield and Cardiff's, drag the team, not moan and throw his hands in the air mid game.
It's a self entitled attitude, we support through good and bad. No one was happy with losing to Cardiff, it was a new low. Don't we praise our away supporters for constantly singing even during loss?

Where did I say "only reason", just that if it was part of the reason for him possibly wanting out. Hardly entices him to stay with supporters spitting venom at him.
 

MUFC OK

Full Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2014
Messages
2,269
Its certainly not our biggest problem when you consider that we are one of the most profitable and biggest clubs in the world with revenue in the top 3 but we have owners who have leeched over £1bn from our club and regularly pay themselves dividends whilst shifting their debt onto the club.

We were essentially the Bayern, Real Madrid, Juventus (top team in their respective country) and have been allowed to fall due to this neglect. When these team have a bli or a bad season, which they all do, they ruthlessly reinvigorate their squads, we do not. could you imagine these teams failing to qualify for the CL, even once? Milan are the only comparable case and they have never had the financial clout that we do.

So yes, we do have spoilt and entitled fans in the scheme of things but no more so than any of the worlds biggest clubs, yet weve had it much worse in recent times so have the right to feel aggrieved I would say.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
3,731
It's a self entitled attitude, we support through good and bad. No one was happy with losing to Cardiff, it was a new low. Don't we praise our away supporters for constantly singing even during loss?

Where did I say "only reason", just that if it was part of the reason for him possibly wanting out. Hardly entices him to stay with supporters spitting venom at him.
It's a self entitled attitude, we support through good and bad. No one was happy with losing to Cardiff, it was a new low. Don't we praise our away supporters for constantly singing even during loss?

Where did I say "only reason", just that if it was part of the reason for him possibly wanting out. Hardly entices him to stay with supporters spitting venom at him.
Most teams have great away support, don't get carried away as if we have the greatest away support.. teams at the bottom of the league come to OT with away support and sing even when losing 4/5- 0.

Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.
That statement says oh he has changed his mind because of abuse? Seriously? If you cannot take criticism with the wages, support when he gets when he is on form?

So i guess you are happy for us to finish 6th year in year out and shout out about it and support the players and the team and congratulate them for finishing 6th.. This is Manutd, you are paid the best wages, have the best facilities to win.
 

VanGaalyTime

Full Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2015
Messages
2,000
I wouldn't say its exclusively the fans fault no, but they are certainly playing a massive part in the unrest and down fall of the side I think.

From chants of "attack, attack, attack" at most games still on going, our supporters booing and abusing players like Fellaini and Pogba during matches and the latter receiving horrific abuse towards the end of the season last. Supporters chanting for Jose with LVG sat in the bench. Fellaini being booed coming on in a CL Qualifying match only to silence them with a goal.

Supporters seem to think if they pay for a match ticket that gives them entitlement to be abusive, guess what folks...it doesn't.

When Ole came in, we needed to draw a line in the sand and move on but unfortunately too many continued to use Mourinho's "blame anyone but me" philosophy and continued to constantly attack the players which has lead to some of the players becoming disenfranchised with the club. Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.

I want players committed to the club like any supporter but a part of me as well doesn't blame him for wanting out if supporters spend years giving him abuse every game.

No doubt I'll get a flurry of replies now saying Real wouldn't stand for this, but the same people who'd say this will also run to a thread about Reals supporters and say they are scum for how they treat their players :rolleyes:
Horrific abuse? Ha! Yes there were some boos for Fellaini. And Pogba had an argument with 3 fans at the end of a game but the vast majority of our fans somehow put up with what these guys did on the field. We're talking about footballers being made millions per year to kick a ball. While Fellaini tried he wasn't good enough. And he made the same mistakes often. Many felt he simply wasn't trying to improve. Pogba gets abuse because he rarely plays to his potential. I think fans have a right to express their opinions. Most will give their full support to players that try even a little bit during games. If players can't take the feedback they should try not accepting hundreds of thousands of dollars per week playing professional sports.
 

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
1,415
Horrific abuse? Ha! Yes there were some boos for Fellaini. And Pogba had an argument with 3 fans at the end of a game but the vast majority of our fans somehow put up with what these guys did on the field. We're talking about footballers being made millions per year to kick a ball. While Fellaini tried he wasn't good enough. And he made the same mistakes often. Many felt he simply wasn't trying to improve. Pogba gets abuse because he rarely plays to his potential. I think fans have a right to express their opinions. Most will give their full support to players that try even a little bit during games. If players can't take the feedback they should try not accepting hundreds of thousands of dollars per week playing professional sports.
Weather it's 3 or 1, what does it matter? Your justifying abusive conduct towards players.

Buying a match ticket doesn't give you that entitlement
 

hobbers

Full Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
8,838
From chants of "attack, attack, attack" at most games still on going, our supporters booing and abusing players like Fellaini and Pogba during matches and the latter receiving horrific abuse towards the end of the season last. Supporters chanting for Jose with LVG sat in the bench. Fellaini being booed coming on in a CL Qualifying match only to silence them with a goal.

Supporters seem to think if they pay for a match ticket that gives them entitlement to be abusive, guess what folks...it doesn't.

When Ole came in, we needed to draw a line in the sand and move on but unfortunately too many continued to use Mourinho's "blame anyone but me" philosophy and continued to constantly attack the players which has lead to some of the players becoming disenfranchised with the club. Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.

I want players committed to the club like any supporter but a part of me as well doesn't blame him for wanting out if supporters spend years giving him abuse every game.

No doubt I'll get a flurry of replies now saying Real wouldn't stand for this, but the same people who'd say this will also run to a thread about Reals supporters and say they are scum for how they treat their players
The bolded do not constitute abuse in the sense you're presenting. And if you really think 'attack attack attack' or a bit of generalised booing after a defeat is monstrously abusive you seriously need to grow a spine. Booing a player who's only just getting subbed on is a shit thing to do, granted, and a couple of fans shouting targeted abuse at Pogba at the end of one match was wrong, but that was still an isolated incident.

More generally, buying a ticket to a football match absolutely gives you an entitlement to boo. If the players aren't even fecking trying a la the Everton or Cardiff defeats what right do they have to walk off to applause from the people paying their wages?

Secondly the fans have played absolutely zero part in Pogba's desire to leave, that's totally fecking obvious. Maybe the media and pundits have played a part given their almost relentless (but often justified) criticism, but still the overwhelming reasons he wants to leave are for more chances at titles, more money and more of a platform for him to grow his brand.

Don't compare United's treatment of players with Real's. Real fans target individual players, in the middle of games, who have won them trophies. In Bale and Casillas and Ronaldo's cases players who have sacrificed it all to at times carry the team to titles. Some of the fans turn up at the training ground and physically threaten violence. There is no comparison with United fans.
 
Last edited:

VanGaalyTime

Full Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2015
Messages
2,000
Weather it's 3 or 1, what does it matter? Your justifying abusive conduct towards players.

Buying a match ticket doesn't give you that entitlement
Weather it's 3 or 1, what does it matter? Your justifying abusive conduct towards players.

Buying a match ticket doesn't give you that entitlement
The players wouldn't even be playing for the club if it wasn't for the fans. United fans pay a high price for tickets and should be able to express their opinions as long as they aren't offensive or violent. Booing is fine. As is yelling at players.
 

RedNed77

Full Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
2,285
Location
Land of the Berties
I wouldn't say its exclusively the fans fault no, but they are certainly playing a massive part in the unrest and down fall of the side I think.

From chants of "attack, attack, attack" at most games still on going, our supporters booing and abusing players like Fellaini and Pogba during matches and the latter receiving horrific abuse towards the end of the season last. Supporters chanting for Jose with LVG sat in the bench. Fellaini being booed coming on in a CL Qualifying match only to silence them with a goal.

Supporters seem to think if they pay for a match ticket that gives them entitlement to be abusive, guess what folks...it doesn't.

When Ole came in, we needed to draw a line in the sand and move on but unfortunately too many continued to use Mourinho's "blame anyone but me" philosophy and continued to constantly attack the players which has lead to some of the players becoming disenfranchised with the club. Pogba wasn't asking for moves prior to the abuse from fans but he sure as hell is now.

I want players committed to the club like any supporter but a part of me as well doesn't blame him for wanting out if supporters spend years giving him abuse every game.

No doubt I'll get a flurry of replies now saying Real wouldn't stand for this, but the same people who'd say this will also run to a thread about Reals supporters and say they are scum for how they treat their players :rolleyes:
I agree that our fanbase can be overly entitled but you have gone completely overboard and picked entirely the wrong targets. The original OP is implying we are struggling to get back to where we were because of our fan base, either that or he thinks us being currently shit is less important than having some moaners (which is wow if that is the case). Assuming its the former being true rather than the latter would imply our fan base is moanier and more entitled than any other clubs fans. If you can name a club in the top 10 in europe who's fans would not have reacted the same as ours I'll give you the internet. Top end teams, mid table teams and relegation fodder will cry for "attack attack attack" if their club are playing stultifying football (you only need to look at Leicester and Saints fans when their teams were being managed by Puel) and will not give warm welcomes to players who they feel are stealing a living or not giving their all (Ozil as a prime example). As for some of the rest of the things you have said, some of them are just out righ fabrications. I have absolutely no recollection of Old Trafford singing Jose Mourinho's name whilst LvG was still in charge.

Re your other point about the fans continuing to blame the players after the manager change? If we have had 4 different managers and we're still doing shit, you want us to keep firing managers without ever looking at the players?
 

blue blue

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2016
Messages
940
Supports
chelsea
The fans are going through a period of adjustment as is the club. There will always be detractors but in a period where expectations are being challenged after a period of sustained success it is to be expected.

From a footballing point of view the club hasn't quite worked out how to rebuild after SAF and are now trying a new approach. They have tried the big name managers and are now adopting a new approach much the same as my club.

There is a changing of the guard as far as big name managers in the PL goes and SAF, Jose's, LVG, and Wengers departure opens the door for a new breed of manager to show their worth. How long Pep and Klopp will remain in place is debatable but I find it refreshing that young managers are being given a chance at a high level. The Chelsea fans at the moment are fully backing Lampard and Ole should be given more of a chance next season. It may be a slow learning curve and Utd can afford this more than Chelsea but there is a lot to be said for nurturing and growing a new team from scratch. The fans can feel a part of the growth and if youth can also be part of that development the more connected the fans will be with the team on the pitch.

I can't help but feel most of the detractors ply their trade on forums such as this and that the real fans who go to the games see things in completely different way. A new team built from home grown talent, and dare I say British players, will get a much better relationship with the crowd. Yes there will always be a place for quality foreign players but I can't help but feel there needs to be a strong homegrown element. For me the English game is on the up and we are entering a new era when homegrown talent will become more influential and the fans won't be able to get enough.

I would though wouldn't I.
 

sunama

Baghdad Bob
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
14,902
:lol: Solskjaer had better hope he's still in his job this time next year because if he fails top 4, the "disillusionment" will quantify his reality.
It's actually quite shocking that managers are surprised when they get fired. When they failed to make top 4, they genuinely were surprised that they got fired. Moyes, LVG, Jose - all were surprised.
Jose was the only one who kept his job when he failed to make top 4, but that was because he won 2 trophies and he had a huge reputation.
Now, once again, Ole is falling into that false sense of security. If he fails to do a decent job, he will be fired. Absolutely no question about this. Woodward uses sackings as a way to protect his own arse.

I'm actually looking forward to this season, because it will be interesting to see how Ole does and how patient Woodward will be with him. And if he does get fired during the coming season, who will be the next permanent manager. The other unknown is our transfers - when the window closes, how much money will we have spent.
The next few months could be a roller coaster ride for all of us.
 

He'sRaldo

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2019
Messages
1,235
The players wouldn't even be playing for the club if it wasn't for the fans. United fans pay a high price for tickets and should be able to express their opinions as long as they aren't offensive or violent. Booing is fine. As is yelling at players.
That doesn't make sense. The players have worked very hard to get to where they are, why should their success be attributed to random fans?
 

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
1,415
The bolded do not constitute abuse in the sense you're presenting. And if you really think 'attack attack attack' or a bit of generalised booing after a defeat is monstrously abusive you seriously need to grow a spine. Booing a player who's only just getting subbed on is a shit thing to do, granted, and a couple of fans shouting targeted abuse at Pogba at the end of one match was wrong, but that was still an isolated incident.

More generally, buying a ticket to a football match absolutely gives you an entitlement to boo. If the players aren't even fecking trying a la the Everton or Cardiff defeats what right do they have to walk off to applause from the people paying their wages?

Secondly the fans have played absolutely zero part in Pogba's desire to leave, that's totally fecking obvious. Maybe the media and pundits have played a part given their almost relentless (but often justified) criticism, but still the overwhelming reasons he wants to leave are for more chances at titles, more money and more of a platform for him to grow his brand.

Don't compare United's treatment of players with Real's. Real fans target individual players, in the middle of games, who have won them trophies. In Bale and Casillas and Ronaldo's cases players who have sacrificed it all to at times carry the team to titles. Some of the fans turn up at the training ground and physically threaten violence. There is no comparison with United fans.
The players wouldn't even be playing for the club if it wasn't for the fans. United fans pay a high price for tickets and should be able to express their opinions as long as they aren't offensive or violent. Booing is fine. As is yelling at players.
With "support" like this who needs rivals to go against the club! ;)

The attack chants come across as self entitled, its sport and there are no guarantees. Win, lose or draw we choose to part with funds to support the club and our role is to encourage and be that extra man for our team.

Booing and undermining our own players is not what were supposed to do. It's counter productive to boo, jeer or give our own players a hard time.

It's not really isolated incidents either when you factor in the levels of abuse they receive online through their social media profiles. This thread highlights this exact problem.

The club tweeted happy birthday to Ashley Young and you've anything from "feck off and leave to club" to "sign Fernandes". There's probably worse than that but after the 100th or so tweet of this nature you give up all hope and stop reading them.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
52,352
It's actually quite shocking that managers are surprised when they get fired. When they failed to make top 4, they genuinely were surprised that they got fired. Moyes, LVG, Jose - all were surprised.
Jose was the only one who kept his job when he failed to make top 4, but that was because he won 2 trophies and he had a huge reputation.
Now, once again, Ole is falling into that false sense of security. If he fails to do a decent job, he will be fired. Absolutely no question about this. Woodward uses sackings as a way to protect his own arse.

I'm actually looking forward to this season, because it will be interesting to see how Ole does and how patient Woodward will be with him. And if he does get fired during the coming season, who will be the next permanent manager. The other unknown is our transfers - when the window closes, how much money will we have spent.
The next few months could be a roller coaster ride for all of us.
If Ole get fired after failing to make top 4 then I am fully expecting him to say nothing and not try to defend his reputation at all. That's because the loudest fans are not the greatest or the best fans
 

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
1,415
I can’t see him getting the sack if we won’t make the top 4.
I think he’ll be given time, unless something really catastrophic happens.
Barring an absolute disaster I agree with this. I can see Ole getting the next season as well.

But I'm also confident we can get top 4 anyway looking at the absolute state that our rivals are in.
 

Class of 63

Full Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2017
Messages
7,451
Location
Still living next door to Alice ... in Wonderland!
Sheesh, this is what you wrote:

And then, in the same fecking post where you denied saying it you doubled down on by saying the following:

If that's not absolving Ed of any blame and putting it all on the 'spoilt little rich kids' (WTF?!) on social media' I don't know what is.

Even if we take your imaginary scenario where the board are totally 50/50 on a decision as gospel - what are you saying, that nobody should ever put forward an opinion just in case the CEO of a multi-billion pound business is undecided and needs to take to social media to get a clue as to which direction to go in?! And then, if said CEO should do that and the decision turn out to be unsuccessful then the fans are at fault? Do you realise how ridiculous that sounds? If that's truly your view then I would suggest that hanging out on discussion forums might not be for you cos like it or not you are going to encounter quite a few pesky fan opinions there.
Sorry, but what in the actual name of feck are you prattling on about? There's a bloody good reason why numerous senior figures at Old Trafford, SAF, Sir Bobby Charlton, David Gill et al didn't want Jose fecking Mourinho anywhere near the club, and if you'd been in the wide awake club for the last 15 years or so you'd have known why that was, the very same reason that Liverpool(a club I hate with a fecking passion and then some, but I can still respect what they have achieved and how they did it)even when they were desperate to get back to winning ways, christ even Man. City, a club desperate to become a household name outside of friggin Moss Side and Stockport and the money to do it never once entertained the idea of appointing Jose Mourinho, and for good reason.

Nothing personal, but you are a fecking idiot if you don't think Jose Mourinho being appointed Manchester United Manager was driven by spoilt little rich kids on social media.

And on Ed Woodward, unlike most on here which is disturbing in itself, I don't feel the need to blame EW for everything that is going wrong at the club at the moment, but allowing himself to be swayed and going against the advice of folk(listed above)who only wanted what was best for the club was definitely on him. But saying that most of us, put in that situation would have gone against our better judgement and done the same, so I can't even hold that against him. In Ed we trust.
 

Cloud7

Full Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
5,358
It's actually quite shocking that managers are surprised when they get fired. When they failed to make top 4, they genuinely were surprised that they got fired. Moyes, LVG, Jose - all were surprised.
Jose was the only one who kept his job when he failed to make top 4, but that was because he won 2 trophies and he had a huge reputation.
Now, once again, Ole is falling into that false sense of security. If he fails to do a decent job, he will be fired. Absolutely no question about this. Woodward uses sackings as a way to protect his own arse.

I'm actually looking forward to this season, because it will be interesting to see how Ole does and how patient Woodward will be with him. And if he does get fired during the coming season, who will be the next permanent manager. The other unknown is our transfers - when the window closes, how much money will we have spent.
The next few months could be a roller coaster ride for all of us.
Do you think they’re actually surprised when it happens or is it just keeping up appearances in public? I would assume the club make it clear that CL qualification is the bare minimum to keep your job.

Even in the case of mid season sackings like Jose, I’m sure they have meetings with the manager before the actual act is done. Not necessarily the “crisis talks!!1!” that the media reports, but discussions about what’s going wrong, how they’re trying to fix it etc., to the point where by the time they are sacked, they probably know it’s coming.
 

Cloud7

Full Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
5,358
I can’t see him getting the sack if we won’t make the top 4.
I think he’ll be given time, unless something really catastrophic happens.
What matters most is the direction we’re going I think. If we seem like there’s a clear plan, a style of football we’re working towards and signs of development as a team, even if the results aren’t there, I think he’ll get the next season as well, unless we finish tenth or something.

On the other hand, if we continue looking as bad as we did near the end of the season, I’m not sure he’ll even get the entire season.
 

DoomSlayer

Full Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Messages
2,978
Location
Bulgaria
Do you think they’re actually surprised when it happens or is it just keeping up appearances in public? I would assume the club make it clear that CL qualification is the bare minimum to keep your job.

Even in the case of mid season sackings like Jose, I’m sure they have meetings with the manager before the actual act is done. Not necessarily the “crisis talks!!1!” that the media reports, but discussions about what’s going wrong, how they’re trying to fix it etc., to the point where by the time they are sacked, they probably know it’s coming.
I remember reading multiple reports that Mourinho was totally blindsided by the sack and he actually thought Woodward was calling him in to discuss the January transfer targets.

Also, LVG found out he was being removed from the media and has been very sour towards our board because of that, highlighted in many of his interviews post-United.
 

Class of 63

Full Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2017
Messages
7,451
Location
Still living next door to Alice ... in Wonderland!
0
:lol: :lol: :lol:

The club should have listened to you instead and give Moyes more time, right?

Fans being blamed for the Mourinho appointment. This is the most ridiculous post I've seen on here in a long time.

The funny, or not so funny thing is, pretty much everyone will be happy if Ole achieves as much as Mourinho did. Including those who think he is the right man for the job.
Yep, the club should have given David Moyes, and LvG more time but they never listened to me and like minded folk, but eventually they will and will be better for it.

It might be ridiculous in your world, BUT IT'S ALSO TRUE.

Well yeah obviously, in his first year, not so much what he achieved(is that the right word?)in his 2nd or 3rd year.
 

Cloud7

Full Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
5,358
I remember reading multiple reports that Mourinho was totally blindsided by the sack and he actually thought Woodward was calling him in to discuss the January transfer targets.

Also, LVG found out he was being removed from the media and has been very sour towards our board because of that, highlighted in many of his interviews post-United.
Vangle found out because Mendes and Mourinho’s camp leaked the stories to the media. Wasn’t that the way it went down? Again though, he would have known he failed to meet his minimum requirements, so his surprised could he really have been? It was just handled poorly.

As for Jose, I don’t recall reading that, but if so that’s genuinely very surprising, and speaks volumes of his lack of self awareness. There were stories of him being sacked months prior, before Pogba and Martial bought him a stay of execution. The results and performances were awful and showed no signs of improvement.
 

DoomSlayer

Full Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Messages
2,978
Location
Bulgaria
Vangle found out because Mendes and Mourinho’s camp leaked the stories to the media. Wasn’t that the way it went down? Again though, he would have known he failed to meet his minimum requirements, so his surprised could he really have been? It was just handled poorly.

As for Jose, I don’t recall reading that, but if so that’s genuinely very surprising, and speaks volumes of his lack of self awareness. There were stories of him being sacked months prior, before Pogba and Martial bought him a stay of execution. The results and performances were awful and showed no signs of improvement.
My theory about Jose is that he thought the worst period had passed and no way could he be sacked at that point. But the embarrassing defeat to Liverpool could have been the last straw for Woodward and the board. I mean, we got totally demolished in that game.
 

Josep Dowling

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
4,692
Hang on, so you think that there is something intrinsically different about our fans that makes them react in a way that is different to how any other group of fans would act if they were in a similar scenario? Don't be ridiculous - people are just people, whatever team they support. It's the circumstances that dictate how they react.

Also, this a discussion forum, of course there are going to be people having a moan - this is exactly where they should be doing it. What about our matchgoing fans (of which I am one - not that it matters a jot) who are as loyal as can be when in the ground?

As a club we are being left behind by our closest rivals, and certain things about the club are a shambles. Should everyone just swallow that down for fear of being seen as disloyal on a bloody discussion forum?!



We finished 30 points off the leaders last season - you think that a right-back and an unproven youngster from the Championship represents a 'decent summer so far'? Especially given that our 2 genuinely world class players both want out. It's clearly too soon to write the summer off, but I think you are viewing this through a ridiculously over-optimistic prism. And as for the last sentence - did you miss the last quarter of the season? Worst form for 60 odd years?

The thing that frustrates people is that we could be the best again. We make shitloads of money. With a proper footballing structure put in place, a top class manager, and owners that were committed to making us the best in Europe there's no reason why we couldn't be. To want that is not being spoiled. If we aim for that and fall short then that's fine. It's the not even aiming for it that understandably disappoints people.
Best post I’ve seen in a long term. Exactly my sentiment on the club right now.
 

Denis79

Full Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2014
Messages
4,156
Hang on, so you think that there is something intrinsically different about our fans that makes them react in a way that is different to how any other group of fans would act if they were in a similar scenario? Don't be ridiculous - people are just people, whatever team they support. It's the circumstances that dictate how they react.

Also, this a discussion forum, of course there are going to be people having a moan - this is exactly where they should be doing it. What about our matchgoing fans (of which I am one - not that it matters a jot) who are as loyal as can be when in the ground?

As a club we are being left behind by our closest rivals, and certain things about the club are a shambles. Should everyone just swallow that down for fear of being seen as disloyal on a bloody discussion forum?!



We finished 30 points off the leaders last season - you think that a right-back and an unproven youngster from the Championship represents a 'decent summer so far'? Especially given that our 2 genuinely world class players both want out. It's clearly too soon to write the summer off, but I think you are viewing this through a ridiculously over-optimistic prism. And as for the last sentence - did you miss the last quarter of the season? Worst form for 60 odd years?

The thing that frustrates people is that we could be the best again. We make shitloads of money. With a proper footballing structure put in place, a top class manager, and owners that were committed to making us the best in Europe there's no reason why we couldn't be. To want that is not being spoiled. If we aim for that and fall short then that's fine. It's the not even aiming for it that understandably disappoints people.
Spot on about how I feel right now. Excellent post that I believe embodies the sentiment of many fans at the moment.
 

Josep Dowling

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
4,692
Thanks, glad it's not just me who has noticed the trend.

I also completely agree about the top-redism. The ultimate sign is 'I don't care if we compete or not' as long as its entertaining, which I get for fans that are going week in week out, and it looks impossible that we will challenge this time.

Top red views/signs:
Pogba is garbage and has been since he arrived - should carry the team etc
Martial - lazy, no good
Bring Roy Keane back in some capacity
Play the youth no matter the circumstances or if they're any good
Mention about the 70's and how it was somehow enjoyable
Winning things doesn't matter
That list :lol:, the play the youth one I particular enjoyed. Every season it’s the same thing. I’m sure it will be Garner next as he scored against some Australian minnows in a friendly. Greenwood is the only one I have seen genuine quality from and he’s only 17. The others I will be amazed if they have a career at United.
 

ThinkTank@Cafe

Full Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2019
Messages
531
Location
Kazakhstan
English is not my first language, so I can’t fully express my thoughts.

I’ve been reading the Caf for 15 years. I could find (and still find) a lot of unique content and have a good laugh.
I decided to join the forum because United supporters who enjoy supporting the club have become outnumbered by “fans” who hate supporting the club.

They feel obliged to do so. Obliged to suffer. Statistics, historical analogies, all sorts of metaphors, and comparisons dumped here to finally express well rationalized contempt to United. They hate everything about the club bar it’s past glory. But they “care” about the club, “blow whistles” or express their concern. We, who enjoy United, must respect their loyalty, a precious gift forged in the fire of genuine human’s suffering.

How do I recognize them? They start by mentioning some “facht” and move on to expressing their emotions. “Loath”, “sick”, “fed up”, etc.

They don’t hesitate to use pejorative adjectives towards the club consistently. They consistently belittle United and praise City and Liverpool. They are arrogant to other posters although don’t contribute anything technical. They like pretentious wording and emotional expressions. They attack you once found out immediately.

Psychoanalysts don’t really follow what is reasoning one’s ego is using to justify his/her behavior, but concentrate on what what is literally said.

Textual analysis of great chunk of posts here will show that a lot of “fans” here just hate to support United. Noble masochists. Doing what you don’t enjoy is a sign of a miserable life. Just stop.
 

He'sRaldo

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2019
Messages
1,235
English is not my first language, so I can’t fully express my thoughts.

I’ve been reading the Caf for 15 years. I could find (and still find) a lot of unique content and have a good laugh.
I decided to join the forum because United supporters who enjoy supporting the club have become outnumbered by “fans” who hate supporting the club.

They feel obliged to do so. Obliged to suffer. Statistics, historical analogies, all sorts of metaphors, and comparisons dumped here to finally express well rationalized contempt to United. They hate everything about the club bar it’s past glory. But they “care” about the club, “blow whistles” or express their concern. We, who enjoy United, must respect their loyalty, a precious gift forged in the fire of genuine human’s suffering.

How do I recognize them? They start by mentioning some “facht” and move on to expressing their emotions. “Loath”, “sick”, “fed up”, etc.

They don’t hesitate to use pejorative adjectives towards the club consistently. They consistently belittle United and praise City and Liverpool. They are arrogant to other posters although don’t contribute anything technical. They like pretentious wording and emotional expressions. They attack you once found out immediately.

Psychoanalysts don’t really follow what is reasoning one’s ego is using to justify his/her behavior, but concentrate on what what is literally said.

Textual analysis of great chunk of posts here will show that a lot of “fans” here just hate to support United. Noble masochists. Doing what you don’t enjoy is a sign of a miserable life. Just stop.
Always enjoy your posts man. Another good one.
 
Last edited:

Nytram Shakes

Full Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
3,890
Location
Normally dark rooms
Sorry but our biggest problem is the way the football side of the business is being ran.

We have 7 centre backs in a 25 man squad, that should tell you everything you need to know about how badly this squad is been managed.
 

HackeyC

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 31, 2018
Messages
141
Sorry but our biggest problem is the way the football side of the business is being ran.

We have 7 centre backs in a 25 man squad, that should tell you everything you need to know about how badly this squad is been managed.
Jones, Bailly and Rojo are permanently crocked so cover is needed.
 

Amarsdd

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
751
English is not my first language, so I can’t fully express my thoughts.

I’ve been reading the Caf for 15 years. I could find (and still find) a lot of unique content and have a good laugh.
I decided to join the forum because United supporters who enjoy supporting the club have become outnumbered by “fans” who hate supporting the club.

They feel obliged to do so. Obliged to suffer. Statistics, historical analogies, all sorts of metaphors, and comparisons dumped here to finally express well rationalized contempt to United. They hate everything about the club bar it’s past glory. But they “care” about the club, “blow whistles” or express their concern. We, who enjoy United, must respect their loyalty, a precious gift forged in the fire of genuine human’s suffering.

How do I recognize them? They start by mentioning some “facht” and move on to expressing their emotions. “Loath”, “sick”, “fed up”, etc.

They don’t hesitate to use pejorative adjectives towards the club consistently. They consistently belittle United and praise City and Liverpool. They are arrogant to other posters although don’t contribute anything technical. They like pretentious wording and emotional expressions. They attack you once found out immediately.

Psychoanalysts don’t really follow what is reasoning one’s ego is using to justify his/her behavior, but concentrate on what what is literally said.

Textual analysis of great chunk of posts here will show that a lot of “fans” here just hate to support United. Noble masochists. Doing what you don’t enjoy is a sign of a miserable life. Just stop.
Exactly! I thought RAWK was bad, but the last few years has made caf equally bad.
 

ThinkTank@Cafe

Full Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2019
Messages
531
Location
Kazakhstan
I don’t hate Glazers. Everything they do is completely legal. They don’t care about football and just want to earn money. I accept that.

I have a deep respect for Ole, he’s a smart person. He has to deal with the situation he is in. I’m enjoying preseason, I like his tactical approach, and team rebuild.

Woodward is not dumb. But he is serving owners best interest, not United fans. Ole’s appointment serves to the interests of owners. Will it be in our best interests? Nobody knows. I am inclined to “search of identity” interpretation. Now the window is closed, the outcome depends on Ole and the team. We will see.

Time for trials and errors is running out. If Ole fails, and Owners will stay as inept as they were, we have to act. Not moan. Moaning is not working. We had 6 years to prove that.
 

Nytram Shakes

Full Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
3,890
Location
Normally dark rooms
Jones, Bailly and Rojo are permanently crocked so cover is needed.
Then they shouldn't of been given new contracts. Jones signed in January, Rojo signed when he was not even close to recovering from an injury that has ended lots of career who few return from and match the same standard.

Again it just adds to the complete mess that has been the management of the football side of the business.