Would you sell Pogba to finance a deal for Sancho?

jesperjaap

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
2,281
What I dont understand is all over the internet so much "pogba and fernandes will be unstoppable" type comments.....people seem to forget. Pogba has been here three seasons now isnt it? Exclude the 3months Ole took over and he has probably warranted his world star tag less than 10games.

He may have all the attributes and ability in the world to be labelled our most talented player, but he has never consistently proved it. Take away the name and hype and losing Pogba really isnt as big a deal as it has been made up to be based on his performances. Add to that we already have his replacement in Fernandes.

If it wasnt for this virus I think we would have been happily selling him to the highest bidder this summer. Now I am not so sure, but he isnt committed to the club and he isnt anywhere near world class for us either.

Personally I would sell him for what we paid for him. As Fernandes has already shown in literally a couple of months, there are so many other central midfielders out there that may not have the same talent but can give us much more consistant quality and heart
 

fps

Full Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2018
Messages
2,928
TBF most of the drama is driven by the media that wants attention (money) and by his haters online. He hasn't put a foot wrong since the "maybe it's time for a new challenge" comment. Some people seem to just be obsessed with this player for some bizarre reason.
Rubbish. His agent does nothing but push the messages the client wants. Pogba has been deliberately briefing to try and get out of Manchester for years, and the irony is he feels like he’s only half arrived in the first place.
 

fps

Full Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2018
Messages
2,928
What I dont understand is all over the internet so much "pogba and fernandes will be unstoppable" type comments.....people seem to forget. Pogba has been here three seasons now isnt it? Exclude the 3months Ole took over and he has probably warranted his world star tag less than 10games.

He may have all the attributes and ability in the world to be labelled our most talented player, but he has never consistently proved it. Take away the name and hype and losing Pogba really isnt as big a deal as it has been made up to be based on his performances. Add to that we already have his replacement in Fernandes.

If it wasnt for this virus I think we would have been happily selling him to the highest bidder this summer. Now I am not so sure, but he isnt committed to the club and he isnt anywhere near world class for us either.

Personally I would sell him for what we paid for him. As Fernandes has already shown in literally a couple of months, there are so many other central midfielders out there that may not have the same talent but can give us much more consistant quality and heart
Absolutely, Fernandes hasn’t waited for better quality players or underperformed because the system isn’t right. He’s just gone in and played. Pogba’s a primadonna and he’s not worth it because at the heart of the matter he’s not as good as people think he is.
 

RedRonaldo

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2003
Messages
10,783
What I dont understand is all over the internet so much "pogba and fernandes will be unstoppable" type comments.....people seem to forget. Pogba has been here three seasons now isnt it? Exclude the 3months Ole took over and he has probably warranted his world star tag less than 10games.

He may have all the attributes and ability in the world to be labelled our most talented player, but he has never consistently proved it. Take away the name and hype and losing Pogba really isnt as big a deal as it has been made up to be based on his performances. Add to that we already have his replacement in Fernandes.

If it wasnt for this virus I think we would have been happily selling him to the highest bidder this summer. Now I am not so sure, but he isnt committed to the club and he isnt anywhere near world class for us either.

Personally I would sell him for what we paid for him. As Fernandes has already shown in literally a couple of months, there are so many other central midfielders out there that may not have the same talent but can give us much more consistant quality and heart
Well if you look at him objectively:

16-17
- UEFA Europa league Player of the year (7.74 avg rating in whoscored too, highest in our team)
- avg 7.72 rating in the league by whoscored (highest in our team, 2nd is Ibra with 7.41)
- 9 goals, 5 assists
17-18
- avg 7.48 rating in the league by whoscored (highest in our team)
- 15th place in Ballon D'or, highest from our squad.
- 6 goals, 11 assists (most assists in our team)
18-19
- Premierleague team of the year
- avg 7.31 rating in the league by whoscored (highest in our team, 2nd is Herrera with 6.96)
- 16 goals, 10 assists (most goals+assists in our team)
19-20
- 1st half:Injured.
- 2nd half:season suspended due to pandemic

Even you don't like him, and he didn't show up in every matches and was rather inconsistent, he is still easily our best outfield player over past 3 years (apart from this season where he is injured). I think everyone would at least agree he is by far our most creative player too. Of course people will be looking forward to his midfield partnership with Bruno.
 
Last edited:

Jeppers7

Full Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2014
Messages
1,689
Absolutely, Fernandes hasn’t waited for better quality players or underperformed because the system isn’t right. He’s just gone in and played. Pogba’s a primadonna and he’s not worth it because at the heart of the matter he’s not as good as people think he is.
Fernandes has immediately played with better players than Pogba did when he first arrived, we’ve got a settled back four and the additions of Maguire and AWB have been great. We are now a side only a couple of players short of competing...in fact if we got Sancho and kept Pogba, I could see us being a real force. Pogba has played in a mishmash of teams with terrible defences and static target men forwards.
You’re comparing apples with oranges, even ignoring the fact that Pogba has been our best outfield player in his time back.
 

Striker10

"Ronaldo and trophies > Manchester United football
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
18,448
No I wouldn't. I think we just need to focus on keeping our talent and bringing in the likes of Sancho. We know Pogbas agents talks a lot. But I think we were such an unstable club. Now, the promise is there. We need to look to push on. A great incentive is their to win trophies. We need to get him signed up and raring to go. I think we need to define his role better. Give him more responsibility. I remember his first game back for us. So much talent. We just need to define what we need from him. Personally, I want him drifting forwards and a final third type player. He can ping it long on the counter but I think we need to set him a target and say - let's meet targets. I think all of us look at our midfield now and it's pleasing.

Now having said that. I would never sell Pogba. If we want that Norwegian lad, we're going to have to make it work anyway but if I were manager, I would only consider part exchange of two quality players to bolster the squad. That said, if Juve offered us Ronaldo as a direct swap, i'd take it because those he's pushing on I think he could play on for many years but it wouldn't happen. For me Ronaldo is the exception because not only does he still produce but he could have a good impact on the younger lads. It's a shame we weren't in for him when he left the mob.
 

MadDogg

Full Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2002
Messages
10,376
Location
Manchester Utd never lose, just run out of time
Now having said that. I would never sell Pogba. If we want that Norwegian lad, we're going to have to make it work anyway but if I were manager, I would only consider part exchange of two quality players to bolster the squad. That said, if Juve offered us Ronaldo as a direct swap, i'd take it because those he's pushing on I think he could play on for many years but it wouldn't happen. For me Ronaldo is the exception because not only does he still produce but he could have a good impact on the younger lads. It's a shame we weren't in for him when he left the mob.
Ronaldo will only go somewhere where he can have a realistic chance of winning the CL. We're not at that stage. Hopefully in the not-too-distant future, but it'll probably be too late for Ronaldo to be an option.
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
1,820
If he doesnt want to he here then sure. If he is happy to stay then no. I feel like a midfield with Pogba and Bruno both fit and in form would be amazing.