Sunderland bid £12m for O'Shea, Gibson & Brown

prateik

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
42,189
Watching SSN now.. they just showed Brown and Oshea training with the sunderland squad.

:(
 

prateik

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
42,189
The SSN bit I saw (see post above) said they werent going to decide on the captaincy issue till after the preseason tour
 

Eyepopper

Lowering the tone since 2006
Joined
Sep 1, 2006
Messages
66,941
I can't believe Gibson is looking for 40k a week out of them.....
 

Mainoldo

New Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
22,965
Thats about right to be perfectly honest.

Forget about your opinion of how good he is and look and what hes achieved as a part of the squad and the fact that hes a full international. Is 40k that far off the mark considering?
Considering Henderson was on about 20k i'm sure 30k wouldn't have got a miss... I doubt Gyan is on anything more than 50k
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Thats about right to be perfectly honest.

Forget about your opinion of how good he is and look and what hes achieved as a part of the squad and the fact that hes a full international. Is 40k that far off the mark considering?
Yes.
 

Brophs

The One and Only
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
50,471
It wouldn't have been a tough conversation to have with Cattermole..

-Boss, what the feck, you've made Sheasy captain? Why? What have I done wrong?
-You missed all but three games last season through suspension, Lee.
-Yeah, fair play, pal. Lolz!!11
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Why should gibson give a shit about what henderson was on?

And i repeat, look at what gibson has achieved, and look at what henderson has achieved. Tell me who should be paid more?
What HAS Gibson achieved?
 

Mickey

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13,041
Location
Stop paying attention to this a while ago
What HAS Gibson achieved?
16 full international caps (which include qualifiers), 2 league cups and a premier league title to his name, and is only 23.

Id say a player with that under his belt would be deserving of 40k, much more than a player whos never touched any sort of silverware and only has 1 full international cap, in a friendly if im not mistaken.
 

moses

Can't We Just Be Nice?
Staff
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
43,434
Location
I have no idea either, yet.
16 full international caps (which include qualifiers), 2 league cups and a premier league title to his name, and is only 23.

Id say a player with that under his belt would be deserving of 40k, much more than a player whos never touched any sort of silverware and only has 1 full international cap, in a friendly if im not mistaken.
I like Gibson, and I'm a Paddy, but an Ireland cap is not comparable to an England cap at the mo', no way Gibbo would have an England call up if he was eligible.
 

Mickey

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13,041
Location
Stop paying attention to this a while ago
I like Gibson, and I'm a Paddy, but an Ireland cap is not comparable to an England cap at the mo', no way Gibbo would have an England call up if he was eligible.
Not the point though. However difficult it may be to get in one national team and not the other, hes played competitive, international football. Surely has to be taken into consideration.
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Well relative to Henderson, quite a lot?

Playing for United is an achievement, especially in a title winning side?
Not an argument you wish to pursue, for obvious reasons.

He has played sporadically for us, been deemed not good enough, is surplus to requirements, and is obviously up for sale. For not a lot, if the fee agreed with Sunderland is any indicator.

How is he worth £40 grand a week?
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Not the point though. However difficult it may be to get in one national team and not the other, hes played competitive, international football. Surely has to be taken into consideration.
No, it doesn't.
 

Mickey

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13,041
Location
Stop paying attention to this a while ago
Played for Manchester United 58 times. Surely thats an achievement in itself. Scored & played an important role in the side that won the League Cup 08/09 & 09/10 too. Has Champions league & International football experience.
THats another thing, he has champions league experience and has performed beyond expectation in the champions league at times.


Hes worth 40k a week.
 

Mickey

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13,041
Location
Stop paying attention to this a while ago
Let's buy Fróði Benjaminsen of the Faroe Isles and pay him EIGHTY Grand a week. He has, after all, made 66 appearances playing competitive, international football.
Nice hyperbole.

Gibson isnt worth 40k a week solely because hes played competitive international football.It a factor that has to be taken into account. Nice use of google btw.

But go on, carry on focusing on just that.
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Nice hyperbole.
You don't know what hyperbole means.

Gibson isnt worth 40k a week solely because hes played competitive international football.
Correct. He isn't worth £40 Grand a week despite playing international football.

It a factor that has to be taken into account. Nice use of google btw.
You too.

But go on, carry on focusing on just that.
:lol:

Yes, because I am the one focusing on that.

Explain to me why you wouldnt take the fact that hes played in euro and world cup qualifiers into account?
. However difficult it may be to get in one national team and not the other, hes played competitive, international football. Surely has to be taken into consideration.
16 full international caps (which include qualifiers),
 

Mickey

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
13,041
Location
Stop paying attention to this a while ago
You don't know what hyperbole means.



Correct. He isn't worth £40 Grand a week despite playing international football.



You too.



:lol:

Yes, because I am the one focusing on that.
Well done, youve separated my quote into little parts out of context. Youve sure shown me.

Not worth debating if youre only interested in making yourself look like some intelligent being.


Infact theres not much point debating over gibson in general because people only see a shit player worth nothing and thats not going to change.
 

Lance Uppercut

Guest
Well done, youve separated my quote into little parts out of context. Youve sure shown me.

Not worth debating if youre only interested in making yourself look like some intelligent being.


Infact theres not much point debating over gibson in general because people only see a shit player worth nothing and thats not going to change.
I am only interested in educating you.

It is unfortunate that the rest of us don't see the player you do. The club, fans, manager, etc.