The entire newcastle defence had pushed out which Suarez was ahead of, but Tiote was running back very slowly from the box which meant Suarez was onside. I'm not sure if he'd gone down injured or something though, don't quite remember the moment.
Premier League 19-21 Oct
- Thread starter NotoriousISSY
- Start date
How is that not a handball? My hate for Liverpool has nothing to do with this, but how can lineo be one meter from the incident and can't see clear handball.
Would it matter if he had gone down injured? If he was on the pitch and covering the player, then he wasn't offside, no?
Gerrard lucky
Great defending by Skrtel there.
If he's gone down injured he's not involved in play therefore he should've been offside as I understand it. The rule has a lot more technicalities now.
Strange that you don't mention a dislike for Liverpool or City, being "a Manchester United fan first".Born and bred in Wythenshawe, which is probably 200 miles north of where you are at the moment...I like Barcelona of course and I have a dislike for Real Madrid. So, in all, I am a Manchester United fan first, Lyon fan second and Barcelona third.
Oh ok didn't know that. Thanks.
How is that not a FK to Newcastle for that Skrtl back pass?
As long as he is in between his goalkeeper and Suarez, there is no way Suarez is offside, since injured or not, he is still on the field of play.
It was a tackle so it wouldn't of been interpreted as deliberate
Well Issynazar is suggesting otherwise, are you sure?
Gerrard should be off, soft penalty and red, clear backpass ignored.
Anything else to add to the list?
Anything else to add to the list?
Cheers. It's not that straightforward then. Who makes the choice of the player being 'seriously injured'? The linesman or the main ref?
It's subjective between different refs. I've seen it happen in the Dutch league but in fairness I doubt our Premier League refs would go along with it.
According to the whole article, it is the referee, since he can either blow up or let play continue. Sorry Izzy.
Can anybody see Newcastle getting a draw out of this?
Get in!!!!
G'wan Newcastle!
cnuts, when you need them to win against 10 men they can't, bastards
I just tuned in and Newcastle score. 
Absolutely!! This is what messes up our chances in Europe since referees have a different interpretation as far as a foul or dive is concerned.
I think this was offside.
How's New Utd played in the 2nd half?
Good movement, calm finish.
Whoop whoop has never been more appropriate.
Amazing. Hope is restored that this Liverpool team is still not as good as they think they are.
Cissokho's glance of disbelief behind him to see where Dummett came from after the ball was in the net was priceless!
Check it out on the replay if you already haven't!
Check it out on the replay if you already haven't!
Just defended with Liverpool creating nothing. They also got Remy away but Skrtel made a last ditch challenge.
Really nice finish by Dummett.
I doubt he'd have rolled the ball towards his own goal if he didn't see Mignolet there.
Touré's glance of disbelief behind him to see where Dummett came from after the ball was in the net was priceless!
Check it out on the replay if you already haven't!
Need a gif of this, missed it!
Touré's glance of disbelief behind him to see where Dummett came from after the ball was in the net was priceless!
Check it out on the replay if you already haven't!
Gif worthy stuff.