End of Season. Moyes to Stay or Go Poll

End of season, Moyes to stay or go?


  • Total voters
    438

golden_blunder

Site admin. Manchester United fan
Staff
Joined
Jun 1, 2000
Messages
120,940
Location
Dublin, Ireland
Just wondering what fergies threshold is?

I mean he backed him and told us all to back him. But for how much longer? Results in 2014 are relegation form, not even mid-table
 

Pexbo

Winner of the 'I'm not reading that' medal.
Joined
Jun 2, 2009
Messages
68,921
Location
Brizzle
Supports
Big Days
Just wondering what fergies threshold is?

I mean he backed him and told us all to back him. But for how much longer? Results in 2014 are relegation form, not even mid-table
I would bet any money he is regretting saying that. He'll be proud of the fans for their support but he'll realise the seriousness of the situation and the mistake he made in choosing Moyes and realise that by saying that we can't be fickle and have to support him he has made the removal of Moyes virtually impossible to do and save face.


I think that when he said that he envisaged a couple of years without a trophy while we have a couple of cup runs and come 2nd 3rd or 4th. Not this cataclysmic disaster.
 

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,536
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬
I would bet any money he is regretting saying that. He'll be proud of the fans for their support but he'll realise the seriousness of the situation and the mistake he made in choosing Moyes and realise that by saying that we can't be fickle and have to support him he has made the removal of Moyes virtually impossible to do and save face.
I don't think it is in Fergie's character to suck it up and accept his 'mistake'. He is has hard headed and adamant as they come, which was a major factor for his success. I can easily see him let this run for a year more, before things get virtually out of his hand. No easy way out.
 

Bloxy

Why does it always rain on me?
Joined
Jul 12, 2004
Messages
3,658
Location
All the wrong places
I don't think it is in Fergie's character to suck it up and accept his 'mistake'. He is has hard headed and adamant as they come, which was a major factor for his success. I can easily see him let this run for a year more, before things get virtually out of his hand. No easy way out.
that's what I'm afraid of too. SAF is as stubborn as they come and trusts his own judgement, so SAF might be the one in the boardroom still refusing to sack Moyes.
 

MDFC Manager

Full Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
24,576
that's what I'm afraid of too. SAF is as stubborn as they come and trusts his own judgement, so SAF might be the one in the boardroom still refusing to sack Moyes.
Yea but Fergie doesn't have executive powers. The moment Glazers want Moyes gone, he will be.
 

Cina

full member
Joined
Aug 10, 2007
Messages
50,912
Yea but Fergie doesn't have executive powers. The moment Glazers want Moyes gone, he will be.
Hard to know, they obviously have a lot of respect for Fergie. They never tried to interfere with him during his reign, they just let him do what he wanted (well, to an extent, I'm sure there were financial restrictions in place), they flat out let him pick Moyes and it looks like they're trusting his idea of sticking with him despite the fact that 99% of owners would've sacked him months ago.

Fergie is a stubborn old git and he won't admit his mistakes easily, which is why I think we're stuck with this club destroyer for a while yet.
 

Dracula

caf plane air-master
Joined
Jan 23, 2012
Messages
3,991
When the glazers and test of the board see the declining ST sales they'll soon make a move and wont care what SAF thinks
 

MDFC Manager

Full Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
24,576
Hard to know, they obviously have a lot of respect for Fergie. They never tried to interfere with him during his reign, they just let him do what he wanted (well, to an extent, I'm sure there were financial restrictions in place), they flat out let him pick Moyes and it looks like they're trusting his idea of sticking with him despite the fact that 99% of owners would've sacked him months ago.

Fergie is a stubborn old git and he won't admit his mistakes easily, which is why I think we're stuck with this club destroyer for a while yet.
I agree with what you're saying but in the first case, they had literally no choice than to trust Fergie with the decisions as they know feck all football themselves. I actually think that they'd have still bowed to Fergie if he suggested they stick with Moyes, in the event we limped to a 4th place finish. The current situation is very different and catastrophic though. If a suitable manager is available at the end of the season, Glazers will pull the trigger imo. But we shall see.
 

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,536
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬
I agree with what you're saying but in the first case, they had literally no choice than to trust Fergie with the decisions as they know feck all football themselves. I actually think that they'd have still bowed to Fergie if he suggested they stick with Moyes, in the event we limped to a 4th place finish. The current situation is very different and catastrophic though. If a suitable manager is available at the end of the season, Glazers will pull the trigger imo. But we shall see.
Probably incorrect. They are astute businessmen who are wise (and successful) enough not that trustable and be led around blind, even by Fergie. The are aware of popularity of Fergie, backed by his success and so are willing to take a backseat as any good owner should. I'm sure they will seek assurances from Fergie on why he thinks Moyes should not be sacked. If they are satisfied, Moyes may well continue. Them bowing to Fergie due to ignorance of football is just absurd, imho.
 

Rednails

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2005
Messages
1,734
Location
Lancashire
Hard to know, they obviously have a lot of respect for Fergie. They never tried to interfere with him during his reign, they just let him do what he wanted (well, to an extent, I'm sure there were financial restrictions in place), they flat out let him pick Moyes and it looks like they're trusting his idea of sticking with him despite the fact that 99% of owners would've sacked him months ago.

Fergie is a stubborn old git and he won't admit his mistakes easily, which is why I think we're stuck with this club destroyer for a while yet.
I'm not so sure. SAF was ruthless in all the important decisions and look at how he dropped Rooney for the Real match. He is a very intelligent man and he will do the right thing for the club.
 

MDFC Manager

Full Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
24,576
Probably incorrect. They are astute businessmen who are wise (and successful) enough not that trustable and be led around blind, even by Fergie. The are aware of popularity of Fergie, backed by his success and so are willing to take a backseat as any good owner should. I'm sure they will seek assurances from Fergie on why he thinks Moyes should not be sacked. If they are satisfied, Moyes may well continue. Them bowing to Fergie due to ignorance of football is just absurd, imho.
Umm that's more or less what I said. I said they'd agree with Fergie about not sacking Moyes if we had a reasonable season. We aren't though and he will be sacked.
 

Rednails

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2005
Messages
1,734
Location
Lancashire
Probably incorrect. They are astute businessmen who are wise (and successful) enough not that trustable and be led around blind, even by Fergie. The are aware of popularity of Fergie, backed by his success and so are willing to take a backseat as any good owner should. I'm sure they will seek assurances from Fergie on why he thinks Moyes should not be sacked. If they are satisfied, Moyes may well continue. Them bowing to Fergie due to ignorance of football is just absurd, imho.
I can't help but compare the Glazers to the Liverpool owners. When they decided that Kenny had to go they recruited their next manager in a professional way. They invited the short-listed candidates to the US for interview and at first Martinez was the favorite for the job. But then they decided that Rodgers was a better choice and how right they were. If John Henry can get it right why can't the Glazers?
 

Lu Tze

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2012
Messages
3,268
I'm not so sure. SAF was ruthless in all the important decisions and look at how he dropped Rooney for the Real match. He is a very intelligent man and he will do the right thing for the club.
SAF has lost his ruthlessness completely. He's all about misplaced loyalty now.
 

Pogue Mahone

Swiftie Fan Club President
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
134,482
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
I'm not so sure. SAF was ruthless in all the important decisions and look at how he dropped Rooney for the Real match. He is a very intelligent man and he will do the right thing for the club.
Same with Veron. From "yous know nothing about football" to shipping his most expensive signing ever out the door (to a rival team, no less) all in the space of a few weeks.

One of Fergie'ss strengths as a manager was a willingness to be ruthless when he needs to be, even if this meant letting the world know he'd made a bad decision in the first place.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,874
Same with Veron. From "yous know nothing about football" to shipping his most expensive signing ever out the door (to a rival team, no less) all in the space of a few weeks.

One of Fergie'ss strengths as a manager was a willingness to be ruthless when he needs to be, even if this meant letting the world know he'd made a bad decision in the first place.
Have you read SAF's latest book Pogue?
 

Rednails

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2005
Messages
1,734
Location
Lancashire
SAF has lost his ruthlessness completely. He's all about misplaced loyalty now.
Where do you think his loyalty lies, United or Moyes? Fergie looked crushed on Sunday and he was sat next to one of the Glazers. He must have felt very uncomfortable. He will want to restore his good reputation.
 

Cal?

CR7 fan
Joined
Mar 18, 2002
Messages
34,976
Where do you think his loyalty lies, United or Moyes? Fergie looked crushed on Sunday and he was sat next to one of the Glazers. He must have felt very uncomfortable. He will want to restore his good reputation.
Sir Alex to give us 2 years and the time for Jose to fall out with Abramovich again?
 

Timdbro

Full Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2012
Messages
1,969
It would be nice if he gave something to cling to, some kind of positive evolution or progress so that we can balance these things in our heads and produce measured assessments. But, two days later, the Liverpool defeat feels even worse than on the day; 7 months into the season, we're playing worse and getting worse results than at the start of the season. Bad times.
 

Cal?

CR7 fan
Joined
Mar 18, 2002
Messages
34,976
It would be nice if he gave something to cling to, some kind of positive evolution or progress so that we can balance these things in our heads and produce measured assessments. But, two days later, the Liverpool defeat feels even worse than on the day; 7 months into the season, we're playing worse and getting worse results than at the start of the season. Bad times.
Our best performance in the league this season was the Swansea away game.
 

Timdbro

Full Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2012
Messages
1,969
Our best performance in the league this season was the Swansea away game.
Basically all our good ones were earlier on; Swansea away (such hope we had) and a few in the CL. More recently, we've had a couple of decent results against relegation contenders, but the final scoreline was better than the performances I feel. More importantly, we've had two of our very worse performances in our last three matches — I think only the Man City match comes close to these two, and that's amongst a large set of pretty horrible ones this season.
 

Cal?

CR7 fan
Joined
Mar 18, 2002
Messages
34,976
Basically all our good ones were earlier on; Swansea away (such hope we had) and a few in the CL. More recently, we've had a couple of decent results against relegation contenders, but the final scoreline was better than the performances I feel. More importantly, we've had two of our very worse performances in our last three matches — I think only the Man City match comes close to these two, and that's amongst a large set of pretty horrible ones this season.
It's quite incredible how right that guy on RAWK was. :(
 

MikeUpNorth

Wobbles like a massive pair of tits
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
19,948
Yeah, that's the first that springs to mind.

Swansea away was just a really good last 20 minutes. Similar to the recent game against WBA, although with much less control overall. The early goals were completely against the run of play.
Exactly. I think the Villa game is the only league match where we've been up to scratch. Even the Arsenal win we were hanging on.
 

Mockney

Not the only poster to be named Poster of the Year
Joined
Jan 27, 2009
Messages
40,992
Location
Editing my own posts.
I actively disliked the Arsenal performance. I had more problems with it than some of our loses, as irrational as that sounds. It was the stereotypical home win of a limited underdog team.
 
Last edited:

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,874
Excerpts only.
I started reading it and its pretty interesting to be honest.

Regarding Veron, SAF complained about JSV inability to stick to a position. If he played him CM he moves to RW, if he plays him RW he ended up to DM. While not clearly stating it, SAF lamented that he had no use for such player and considering the fact that Chelsea played a rigid system, I think that selling them Veron (a fantasista whose used to a free role) was SAF's bid in weakening them.
 

Pexbo

Winner of the 'I'm not reading that' medal.
Joined
Jun 2, 2009
Messages
68,921
Location
Brizzle
Supports
Big Days
I started reading it and its pretty interesting to be honest.

Regarding Veron, SAF complained about JSV inability to stick to a position. If he played him CM he moves to RW, if he plays him RW he ended up to DM. While not clearly stating it, SAF lamented that he had no use for such player and considering the fact that Chelsea played a rigid system, I think that selling them Veron (a fantasista whose used to a free role) was SAF's bid in weakening them.
Bloody hell devilish that's an excellent post. I had to double check you posted it then.


To add to it, I think Mourinho might have returned the trick.
 

Rednails

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2005
Messages
1,734
Location
Lancashire
I know this is ESPN but it's cheered me up a bit!

Sources: Board turning against Moyes

March 18, 2014
By Miguel Delaney | ESPNFC


ESPN FC: United are shell shocked

Key Manchester United boardroom figures have now turned against David Moyes, as the prospect of the manager getting sacked has been properly raised for the first time, club sources have told ESPN FC.





David Moyes' job hangs in the balance after revelations that United's owners, the Glazers, are now open to the idea of a change of manager.
The Glazer family owners are now more open to the idea of a change of manager, although they presently remain behind Moyes, but the next week could prove decisive, sources said. Over that time, United must overturn a 2-0 deficit in the Champions League against Olympiakos, before facing an awkward trip to West Ham United and then a potentially daunting second derby of the season against Manchester City.

While qualification for the quarterfinals of the Champions League would be seen as a huge positive and possibly change the entire dynamic of his job, an elimination followed by poor performances in the two games after that could well bring the pressure to breaking point. The Glazers are said to have become very "nervous" about the nature of recent performances, let alone the results, with a nadir coming in the 3-0 home defeat to Liverpool. Some United officials now openly maintain that a managerial change is needed.

Old Trafford sources also state it has been noted that Sir Alex Ferguson is no longer so vocally backing Moyes at boardroom level, although the former manager is not said to have turned against his replacement. It is also believed Moyes retains the backing of Sir Bobby Charlton.

Doubt, however, has increased at virtually every level of the club. Despite the poverty of recent performances, sources state that one of the most influential factors now has been financial concerns. A number of recently signed-up sponsors and commercial partners have reportedly let it be known to the club that they are less than enthused with now being linked to failure, especially since they specifically came on board because of the reputation for extreme success.

This is said to have most unnerved the hierarchy, and long-term damage to United as a "brand" could be the clinching point in any decision. While the club have long planned for a season out of the Champions League -- and that was known to be one initial reason behind the previously unwavering support for Moyes -- any extra negative effect on commercial revenue would be viewed with utmost seriousness.

Sources also state Louis van Gaal would be interested in a potential summer move to Old Trafford, and that the Dutch coach is a little less intent on the Tottenham Hotspur job than he was a few weeks ago. Spurs had felt that Van Gaal's appointment after the World Cup was virtually certain, but it is now more open-ended.

http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1...idering-replacing-david-moyes-manager?cc=5739
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,874
I know this is ESPN but it's cheered me up a bit!
Sources: Board turning against Moyes
March 18, 2014
By Miguel Delaney | ESPNFC


ESPN FC: United are shell shocked

Key Manchester United boardroom figures have now turned against David Moyes, as the prospect of the manager getting sacked has been properly raised for the first time, club sources have told ESPN FC.





David Moyes' job hangs in the balance after revelations that United's owners, the Glazers, are now open to the idea of a change of manager.
The Glazer family owners are now more open to the idea of a change of manager, although they presently remain behind Moyes, but the next week could prove decisive, sources said. Over that time, United must overturn a 2-0 deficit in the Champions League against Olympiakos, before facing an awkward trip to West Ham United and then a potentially daunting second derby of the season against Manchester City.

While qualification for the quarterfinals of the Champions League would be seen as a huge positive and possibly change the entire dynamic of his job, an elimination followed by poor performances in the two games after that could well bring the pressure to breaking point. The Glazers are said to have become very "nervous" about the nature of recent performances, let alone the results, with a nadir coming in the 3-0 home defeat to Liverpool. Some United officials now openly maintain that a managerial change is needed.

Old Trafford sources also state it has been noted that Sir Alex Ferguson is no longer so vocally backing Moyes at boardroom level, although the former manager is not said to have turned against his replacement. It is also believed Moyes retains the backing of Sir Bobby Charlton.

Doubt, however, has increased at virtually every level of the club. Despite the poverty of recent performances, sources state that one of the most influential factors now has been financial concerns. A number of recently signed-up sponsors and commercial partners have reportedly let it be known to the club that they are less than enthused with now being linked to failure, especially since they specifically came on board because of the reputation for extreme success.

This is said to have most unnerved the hierarchy, and long-term damage to United as a "brand" could be the clinching point in any decision. While the club have long planned for a season out of the Champions League -- and that was known to be one initial reason behind the previously unwavering support for Moyes -- any extra negative effect on commercial revenue would be viewed with utmost seriousness.

Sources also state Louis van Gaal would be interested in a potential summer move to Old Trafford, and that the Dutch coach is a little less intent on the Tottenham Hotspur job than he was a few weeks ago. Spurs had felt that Van Gaal's appointment after the World Cup was virtually certain, but it is now more open-ended.

http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1...idering-replacing-david-moyes-manager?cc=5739

If Van Gaal wants the job then he either take it now or else he can remain where he is. The last thing we need is another new manager starting his job in late summer.
 

Crashoutcassius

Full Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2013
Messages
10,336
Location
playa del carmen
Why don't we just have this poll at the end of the season when we have all the info. There's not much danger in spreading negativity in the summer. Negative and pointless threads like this before the most important game of the season make this place horrible though.
 

Revan

Assumptionman
Joined
Dec 19, 2011
Messages
49,992
Location
London
If Van Gaal wants the job then he either take it now or else he can remain where he is. The last thing we need is another new manager starting his job in late summer.
He is currently the Dutch national manager, won't leave Holland until after the World Cup. Anyway, the season is gone, as long as he would have some targets to sign, July would be alright to start the job.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,874
He is currently the Dutch national manager, won't leave Holland until after the World Cup. Anyway, the season is gone, as long as he would have some targets to sign, July would be alright to start the job.
We will end up in the same situation as last summer, with the manager having no time to assess the squad and with no time left to really strengthen the side. I wonder if that's the idea in the first place.

Van Gaal is good but there are other managers one can pick and who would do a great job.