Confirmed: Moyes sacked.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
Can't decide which historical reference is the best analog for Moyes's tenure: Kerensky, The Weimar Republic or Andropov. All tumultuous and brief periods that ended in failure.
Let's not go for that one! We all know what followed - and now that video of Van Gaal speaking to the masses from a balcony in Bavaria takes on a whole new meaning...
 

#07

makes new threads with tweets in the OP
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
23,328
Paddy Power have taken it too far with this. What's worse is that, as the picture shows, the Liverpool fans are revelling in it and taking photos with the statue. Genuinely don't understand what Paddy Power get out of this either? The grim reaper stunt was done while Moyes was in post. Now Moyes has been axed what's the point? I hope Chelsea win today.
 

SteveJ

all-round nice guy, aka Uncle Joe Kardashian
Scout
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
62,851
They're The Sun of betting shops. Twats.
 

Crackers

greasy ginfers
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
29,321
Location
Glazers Out
They're The Sun of betting shops. Twats.
People think they're twats, and then the try to make money from them by betting. Lots of people bet more, and they make their money. Publicity stunts seem to work for betting shops.
 

Andy_Cole

Full Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2009
Messages
7,975
Location
Manchester
Paddy Power have taken it too far with this. What's worse is that, as the picture shows, the Liverpool fans are revelling in it and taking photos with the statue. Genuinely don't understand what Paddy Power get out of this either? The grim reaper stunt was done while Moyes was in post. Now Moyes has been axed what's the point? I hope Chelsea win today.
Publicity.
 

SteveJ

all-round nice guy, aka Uncle Joe Kardashian
Scout
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
62,851
People think they're twats, and then the try to make money from them by betting. Lots of people bet more, and they make their money. Publicity stunts seem to work for betting shops.
Then people are bigger twats than Paddy Power, chief.
 

SteveJ

all-round nice guy, aka Uncle Joe Kardashian
Scout
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
62,851
Unfortunately, yes. "The greater fool is someone with the perfect blend of self delusion and ego to think that he can succeed where others have failed."
Yet more Moyes digs! ;) :D
 

bobbyf

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2014
Messages
1,054
Well, yes, I'd be inclined to trust in a football man like Moyes over a corporate guy who somehow thinks that he's fit to decide who signs for United. However, the impression I get is that Moyes as manager was floundering: he might've had long-terms plans in place but his present management was a mixed bag of over-strong authoritarianism and weak concessions; blunt-speaking and keeping people (the press, favoured players) sweet; stale, traditional thinking and supposedly innovative touches. While this mixed message could be viewed as merely the kind of on-the-fly compromising that able politicians routinely do, it also speaks of a lack of overall vision, organisation and cool-headedness; it speaks of a drowning man out of his depth entirely.
What's also being widely overlooked is Moyes' total inflexibility and stubborness in the job. Sir Alex was big enough to step back and delegate, let others more qualified do what they did best, cos he couldn't. That's what makes a top manager. And he players saw through Moyes and his lack of vision straight away, carried on playing but are now being lambasted which is over the top.

Moyes apparently found the magnitude and pressure of the job daunting, including all the tasks behind the scenes, but he still chose to coach the players even though he was not up to scratch tactically or otherwise. While he ignored verbal agreements about keeping the continuity of the coaching staff too. He only has himself to blame, but the ABUs in the media and beyond need to whinge about something.
 

crossy1686

career ending
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
31,710
Location
Manchester/Stockholm
All these Moyes defenders seem to blame Woodward. The soccer Saturday clowns were the same.

It was Moyes who turned down Thiago because he wasn't so sure. Strootman was there for him, but he turned him down.
If it ever comes out that Moyes turned those players down/let them get away because he wasn't sure if they'd fit then he never deserves to manage another top team ever again as far as I'm concerned. You'd be insane to hire him if you were a chairman.

Surely chairmen call old teams to get a managers reference?
 

Fergie's Man

Suffers Snails fetish
Joined
Dec 18, 2006
Messages
3,230
Well, yes, I'd be inclined to trust in a football man like Moyes over a corporate guy who somehow thinks that he's fit to decide who signs for United. However, the impression I get is that Moyes as manager was floundering: he might've had long-terms plans in place but his present management was a mixed bag of over-strong authoritarianism and weak concessions; blunt-speaking and keeping people (the press, favoured players) sweet; stale, traditional thinking and supposedly innovative touches. While this mixed message could be viewed as merely the kind of on-the-fly compromising that able politicians routinely do, it also speaks of a lack of overall vision, organisation and cool-headedness; it speaks of a drowning man out of his depth entirely.
I don't disagree when anything you have said Steve. Without doubt, he was out his depth and as a result grew a set of deaf ears and stuck his head in the transfer market sand. He actions smack of panic and fear. The players pretty much stuck their head in the sand too and left his weaknesses exposed.

I think we need some real strength as well as Giggs' motivational bandwagon. The club needs a strong manager, no question.
 

Will Absolute

New Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
7,982
Location
Southern Ireland
Well, yes, I'd be inclined to trust in a football man like Moyes over a corporate guy who somehow thinks that he's fit to decide who signs for United. However, the impression I get is that Moyes as manager was floundering: he might've had long-terms plans in place but his present management was a mixed bag of over-strong authoritarianism and weak concessions; blunt-speaking and keeping people (the press, favoured players) sweet; stale, traditional thinking and supposedly innovative touches. While this mixed message could be viewed as merely the kind of on-the-fly compromising that able politicians routinely do, it also speaks of a lack of overall vision, organisation and cool-headedness; it speaks of a drowning man out of his depth entirely.
Yep. Good post.
 

PlayerOne

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
9,668
Location
London
This thread should just be renamed the Moyes haters thread.
Where's the hate? A few of us have never been through a managerial sacking and there's a lot to discuss, don't see what's wrong with that.
 

TheGame

Full Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2002
Messages
19,291
Location
In the Land of Saints and Sinners
Where's the hate? A few of us have never been through a managerial sacking and there's a lot to discuss, don't see what's wrong with that.
Alot to discuss and no hate :houllier:are you kidding me, it's one pathetic insult after another, there is no discussion. Childish pathetic insults, that's all this thread has become. Ppl having some strange belief their insult is better than the one before. The man has been sacked, the jokes weren't funny before and they are not funny now.
 

PlayerOne

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
9,668
Location
London
Alot to discuss and no hate :houllier:are you kidding me, it's one pathetic insult after another, there is no discussion. Childish pathetic insults, that's all this thread has become. Ppl having some strange belief their insult is better than the one before. The man has been sacked, the jokes weren't funny before and they are not funny now.
Can you point out the hate and insults? There's only a few.
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
20,454
Jonathan Northcroft has just written a long article about the truth behind Moyes' sacking. Clearly telling Moyes' side of the story but an interesting read nonetheless.

http://www.thesundaytimes.co.uk/sto/sport/football/Premiership/article1404236.ece

Football's ugliest sacking: the truth
The Manchester United board continued to re-assure their embattled manager right up until the day the axe fell

What an absolute clusterfeck of an article, it should have been titled : Excuses, excuses, excuses: by David Moyes.

The continued suggestion that he had no idea his job was in any kind of danger is laughable, i don't think Moyes is a stupid man he can't be to have gotten as far as he has in management as such he will have known there was a real danger he was going to get the boot at the end of the season, or once he failed to qualify for the CL he did after all willingly sign a contract with this clause inserted, no one forced him to do that.

Again the club getting criticized for waiting until it was mathematically impossible for qualify for the CL so he got a lesser pay out, well that was the whole purpose of the clause why are people having problems understanding that. Also why should the club have sacked him earlier and as a result give him a bigger financial reward for his failure when the team was not going to get into the CL anyway, makes no sense what so ever.

Woodward said the board had started having “a few doubts” after the 2-0 away defeat by Olympiakos. Moyes pointed out he had actually turned that tie around with a 3-0 win in the home leg and said he would have turned United round generally, given time. Woodward said the team had not been showing enough “spirit and fight” to suggest a revival was going to happen. Moyes noted that if there was one thing he had been associated with as a manager at Everton, it was producing sides with “spirit and fight”. Was, therefore, the lack of it in United down to the manager? It is a question he left Woodward to ponder. Some, of course, have a simple theory on such matters: if players do not give their best, it is really not the poor souls’ fault. It is all down to their gaffer.
This bit if he really said it is absurd, yeah because the group of players he took over were not known as a team who possessed fight and spirit. What a load of horseshit he was just as culpable for every limp performance as the players. He sounds like a man totally unwilling to accept responsibility for the disaster of a season he presided over.

The first issue he had to address was his backroom staff. Mike Phelan and Eric Steele, two of Ferguson’s trusted assistants, were coming out of contract and Moyes felt he had to make a decision on them, out of fairness, before meeting the pair. He wanted Rene Meulensteen, Ferguson’s chief coach, to stay but because Moyes was still an Everton employee he was unable to go to Carrington, spend proper time getting to know the Dutchman to establish a basis to work together.

Meulensteen — with his own management ambitions — decided to go. Even now, Moyes’ detractors portray him as having “sacked” Meulensteen but he finally admitted this week it had been his decision to quit. “It became evident to me after a few meetings with David Moyes about the upcoming season that he wanted to bring in his own people and do things in his own way, and I felt very strongly that things would change dramatically for myself, so I couldn’t carry on,” Meulensteen said.
If he was unable to go to carrington how was it then that he was pictured being driven to the place last may by Ferguson, which was plastered over every newspaper and sports station. So that part is complete bullshit. What it seems actually happened was Moyes decided to piss off on holiday for 6 weeks once the season ended probably thinking that now he has lots of money to spend signing players will be a piece of piss once he gets back in july. There were rumours the Glazers & Woodward first had doubts about Moyes as early as last summer due to his seemingly lackadaisical attitude in identifying targets.

The article he quotes Rene from also has Mulensteen stating he met and spoke with Moyes, he even said he offered Moyes advice. Which would seem to contradict the articles assertion that Moyes never had a chance to speak to Rene before he decided to leave.


Moyes was given an opportunity of a life time that a lot of people felt he never deserved, for multiple reasons and i am sure despite his best efforts he blew it big time. There is no way he seriously thought Manchester United would stand still and wait while he spent 2-3 years discarding and replacing players he didn't have the talent to win over and get the best out of.

It's over now and he should accept the fact that it was largely down to the mistakes he made and his decisions that didn't work out. This article sounds like it was spoon fed from Moyes himself, its as if he really thinks the world and his dog conspired to sabotage and derail his big chance, instead of the much more likely reason that he simply didn't have the right mentality and wasn't good enough for this level.
 

TheGame

Full Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2002
Messages
19,291
Location
In the Land of Saints and Sinners
Can you point out the hate and insults? There's only a few.
This is just a few, god knows how many are in the thread, you call this discussion?

Looks like some are suggesting Moyes was the moral victor, now he's just like Shitty!
I regret one thing. We should have sacked him on a day Liverpool wins the league. Sacking Moyes would be a bigger news.
I am actually shocked he didn't mention his Community Shield trophy in his statement!
This.

Moyes keeps brainwashing people even after being sacked. The guy has a gift. He is in the wrong profession.
The more people speak about it, the more I wanna say - Good effin riddance.
My Dad knows a few people involved with club and apparently Carrington has miraculously transformed into a happy, joyous and positive place. Not much of a shock.

My sister knows a keeper involved with the academy (nay idea who) but even he said that it was a depressing place.
I cant belive this but every time i realize he no longer the manager of this club brings a smile on my face.
By the time Dithering Dave decides what's going on the plate it'll be fecking stone cold
Someday surely someone will be writing a book on his whole time at United.

It will be a riveting read.

"The Damn United 2".
Ding Dong the witch is dead


wtf! I found this image today! Look at him! Never has he looked so happy! :lol:
Moyes got millions for coming in and kicking out our coaching staff, turning us into a bunch of fannys, and pissing Giggs off. So in my opinion goodbye and do not let the door hit you on the ass on the way out.
40 mile sprints up a mountain twice a day, most certainly takes its toll on the human body...
No. Whenever its bumped i giggle. I hated when he was in charge.
Im developing irrational hate towards Moyes. So happy hes gone.
Love the picture of him draining a vase of beer whilst his wife just sits there and listens to him. Bet he made her sit through six or seven. And why shouldn't he? HE'S PAYING!
 

Jimy_Hills_Chin

Desperately wants to be ITK
Joined
Jun 26, 2010
Messages
10,892
Location
ITK
Another thing that irks me about that article is Moyes babbling on about no one from the board telling him that results need to improve. It implies that he was coasting, did he not know himself that results needed to improve?! If the Glazer's had expressed dissatisfaction with the results what difference would it have made to his management?
 

CantonaGiggs1

New Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
5,681
Alot to discuss and no hate :houllier:are you kidding me, it's one pathetic insult after another, there is no discussion. Childish pathetic insults, that's all this thread has become. Ppl having some strange belief their insult is better than the one before. The man has been sacked, the jokes weren't funny before and they are not funny now.
Any criticism of Moyes is hate in your book.

Everything the "haters" said about Moyes was proven to be correct.
 

Erebus

Full Member
Joined
May 14, 2013
Messages
966
None of them were around when SAF was appointed and did worse than Moyes in his first season.
I was - and it was a totally different situation then. Ferguson inherited a drinking den and not the ruling Champions. Very, very different. And what's being around then got to do with it anyway? Can you only discuss things that happened when you were around? In that case most of us can't discuss the Second World War and I bet I'm one of the only people on this board entitled to talk about England winning the world cup. Never understood this argument.
 

bobbyf

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2014
Messages
1,054
None of them were around when SAF was appointed and did worse than Moyes in his first season.
Actually they were. Long before SAF was appointed. Such a pathetic assumption just cos they rightly criticise a totally inept manager.

And what's wrong with hating Moyes? He completely ruined our club this season. He brought in his own coaches after telling SAF he would keep the original staff who had been responsible for so much success and replaced them with his muppets and their half-arsed ideas. He wrongly changed tactics and then questioned whether SAF could do better with the same players when he couldn't. And still he refuses to take the rap for that.

And it's been said a million times but cos you missed it, here it is again...SAF didn't take over a top side in his first season. Far from it. That's why comparing the two managers is just plain ridiculous.
 

CantonaGiggs1

New Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
5,681
Not this stupid argument again.

-Ferguson's CV was of a winner when he arrived at Old Traffford.

- Ferguson did not inherit the champions nor the global beast that is Man United now.

- Ferguson had a plan and it started with the youth system. He was building something, which allowed management to ignore the complaints and stick with him.


Moyes didn't have any of these things going for him. All he was doing was dismantling a winning formula. He was ripping the soul out of United.


PLEASE STOP WITH THE STUPID COMPARISONS.
 

Rednails

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2005
Messages
1,734
Location
Lancashire
Moyes has always been stubborn, set in his ways and unwilling to listen to anyone else's opinion but his own. That's why he brought in his gophers Round and Lumsden. He has been hoisted by his own petard and it serves him right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.