Jose Mourinho v Ryan Giggs... who do you want? [POLL]

[Raees]

Can we have a poll on this as the media seem to think Giggs would be a popular choice. .

Even if you think neither. . this is for if it came down to it, who would you prefer.

@Damien

 

[RedChip]

Can we have a poll on this as the media seem to think Giggs would be a popular choice. .

Even if you think neither. . this is for if it came down to it, who would you prefer.

@Damien

This will be close

 

[Raees]

This will be close

That's the point.. the media won't be able to state that he's popular when a fan poll on the biggest United forum proves otherwise (you'd hope...)

 

[devilish]

Please put Gary Neville in too

 

[All 3 United]

Yep good idea, if nothing else just to (hopefully) prove a point.

 

[Jazz]

That's the point.. the media won't be able to state that he's popular when a fan poll on the biggest United forum proves otherwise (you'd hope...)

Do the media even pay attention to what's on the Caf?

I've seen some newspaper polls - and Jose is leading all the way - even though ABUs are there no doubt voting for Giggs. You would hope the United hierarchy are paying attention....

 

[Jazz]

Please put Gary Neville in too

 

[ivaldo]

Oh yeah, that going to grind the media to a halt.

 

[devilish]

He won more matches with Valencia then Giggs did with United

 

[MrSingh2002]

Poll poll poll poll poll.

My votes going to be Mourinho by a mile.

 

[AltiUn]

Oh yeah, that going to grind the media to a halt.

Probably a better idea than an organised walk out in fairness

 

[Jazz]

He won more matches with Valencia then Giggs did with United

That's true....

 

[Donut]

Do the media even pay attention to what's on the Caf?

I've seen some newspaper polls - and Jose is leading all the way - even though ABUs are there no doubt voting for Giggs. You would hope the United hierarchy are paying attention....

They lurk here all the time. Remember the Kaka prank

 

[Jazz]

Send the results to United's official twitter account

Seriously, curious to see what the voting looks like once the poll is up.

 

[Fer]

What about Pochettino? Do you think that we cannot sign him?

 

[devilish]

That's true....

Also he comes in pairs. You pay for Gary and you have Phil for free

 

[Sunny Jim]

Please put Gary Neville in too

And Rafa Benitez

 

[Jazz]

They lurk here all the time. Remember the Kaka prank

Really? Sports journalists eh?

Re: Kaka - wasn't on the Caf then so don't know about that.

 

[Jazz]

Also he comes in pairs. You pay for Gary and you have Phil for free

 

[devilish]

yeah its called the ain't heavy he's my brother special offer

 

[Pexbo]

That's the point.. the media won't be able to state that he's popular when a fan poll on the biggest United forum proves otherwise (you'd hope...)

On Man United's biggest fan forum Red Cafe;

United fan @B20 said "it's got to be Giggs! Give him a 10 year contract!"

@Tommy said "He's a United legend, he's got to be given the chance.

@Gol123 said "If Pep is at City, Simeone at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool, Pochettino st Spurs and Wenger at Arsenal, I would LOVE to see Giggs at United.

 

[Donut]

Really? Sports journalists eh?

Re: Kaka - wasn't on the Caf then so don't know about that.

Basically someone (Spoony I think) made up a fake article about Kaka coming to United, and it was reported by several newspapers.

 

[Jazz]

What about Pochettino? Do you think that we cannot sign him?

Think we should stick to Giggs and Mo as there's no suggestion Poch is gettable right now. Plus why would he leave stability at Spurs to come and feck around with us?

 

[Jazz]

Basically someone (Spoony I think) made up a fake article about Kaka coming to United, and it was reported by several newspapers.

 

[Von Mistelroum]

For me, it's Mourinho by a huge margin. I suspect we'll be ensuring our fall to mid table for the foreseeable future if Giggs is appointed. He doesn't come across as having the nous or personality to inspire a team in any way and a manager at Manchester United should have already proven himself as a top manager.

If we're really considering hiring a former player as manager with little to no experience then Neville would be my choice. He has shown good insight and intelligence and I do feel that, in time, he could make a good manager.

It'll be Giggs though, I can feel it coming in my darkest nightmares....

Edit: please keep the poll to Mourinho vs Giggs. Would like to see the real split here.

 

[Mrs Smoker]

I'd prefer Giggs between the two.

 

[Raees]

What about Pochettino? Do you think that we cannot sign him?

We can but this is the best poll to get an indication of just how highly rated Giggs is in united fan circles. Adding guys like Poch would dilute it.. I think the media take what we say seriously. Cina's wum was being talked about by plenty of people I know at work and they are not members or even United fans.

 

[devilish]

On Man United's biggest fan forum Red Cafe;

United fan @B20 said "it's got to be Giggs! Give him a 10 year contract!"

@Tommy said "He's a United legend, he's got to be given the chance.

@Gol123 said "If Pep is at City, Simeone at Chelsea, Klopp at Liverpool, Pochettino st Spurs and Wenger at Arsenal, I would LOVE to see Giggs at United.

Gol must hate United very much

 

[Spoony]

Tough decision, give me time to decide.

 

[devilish]

I'd prefer Giggs between the two.

What are you smoking Mrs?

 

[Raees]

Tough decision, give me time to decide.

Is that you Ed..

 

[Mrs Smoker]

What are you smoking Mrs?

I don't know what it's called.

 

[sullydnl]

Mourinho and it isn't even remotely close. I couldn't construct an argument for choosing Giggs over Mou that didn't rely on me being willfully stupid.

 

[Jazz]

Well can't wait for this poll. Mo gets my vote.

 

[Mrs Smoker]

Most anticipated poll in the history of Cafe! Like Deadpool the film.

 

[Hemil]

Surely Giggs. This is not even a close arguement. One is a life-long club legend while one is a shit player who has managed rival clubs and disrespected United all the way.

 

[All 3 United]

Think we should stick to Jose v Giggs as I think the idea is to show anybody from the media or club that might actually review the caf, how anti most United fans are to Giggs taking over, as there seems to be some suggestion that the club believe it will be a popular choice.

I suppose the other option would be simply, would you be happy with Giggs being appointed as manager on a permanent basis (yes or no)?

Come on Mods don't tell me you don't work Sunday's!?

 

[Jazz]

Surely Giggs. This is not even a close arguement. One is a life-long club legend while one is a shit player who has managed rival clubs and disrespected United all the way.

Other supporters are not allowed to vote in this poll.

Please Mods make it so

 

[AltiUn]

Surely Giggs. This is not even a close arguement. One is a life-long club legend while one is a shit player who has managed rival clubs and disrespected United all the way.

No, go away, bad Hemil!

 

[ZupZup]

Probably Giggs by a slender margin...