unSporting Club de Portugeezers

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
I can explain the sporting management from a point of view of a portuguese that is not a fan of sporting and not even a fan of the one of the top 3 clubs in portugal.

You will find it harsh my comparision but this is the truth, the real truth.

Bruno de Carvalho = Hitler
Saraiva = Goebbels.



He is also so fair and professional that he left is wife to start banging a sporting worker and even re activated a marketing section to put her has boss of that section.
Amazing, we even have "cartilheiros" in United's forum now :lol: I'm not going to contradict the post you wrote, it's full of crap but i'll give you a warning, this forum is not what you are used to in Portugal, where the tone and the level is extremely low. This type of things you wrote isn't accepted here. So moderate your tone and stop making stuff up or you won't get far. Think wisely before posting again.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Why did he actually get sacked?
He got sacked because he sided with his agent (sometimes against the interests of the club) and adopted a confrontational tone against our Board. Our President isn't a saint but when chosing between our President and Marco Silva in terms of defending our club's interests, it's Bruno de Carvalho all the way.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Amazing, we even have "cartilheiros" in United's forum now :lol: I'm not going to contradict the post you wrote, it's full of crap but i'll give you a warning, this forum is not what you are used to in Portugal, where the tone and the level is extremely low. This type of things you wrote isn't accepted here. So moderate your tone and stop making stuff up or you won't get far. Think wisely before posting again.
Don't worry mate I think I made my presence felt here today, but if he believes he will get away with this when he comes here, well... :lol:
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
I also wonder if the situation Leicester find themselves in with Adrien is anything to do with the way Sporting have handled the transfer.
Nope. It was Leicester responsability not Sporting's. But tbf to our President, who often behaves in a very erratic manner, he sided with Leicester and praised their behaviour in the transfer saga. He called for FIFA to be more flexible. Since Sporting and Leicester have a very good relation and are in friendly terms, i think they will negotiate some kind of solution for this problem. At least that's what most media is reporting.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Don't worry mate I think I made my presence felt here today, but if he believes he will get away with this when he comes here, well... :lol:
Incredible, we have a Setúbal "fan" who copy pastes stuff from Benfica sites. What an incredible coincidence.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Incredible, we have a Setúbal "fan" who copy pastes stuff from Benfica sites. What an incredible coincidence.
AhAh, and he spouts the same propaganda as Guerra or Rui Pedro Braz, who by the way was from the same school as me in Margem Sul, and believe me he is so fanatical about Benfica that everytime they lost a match he would go to the school totally freaked out.

And this is what they call "objective and unbiased media" in Portugal, these muppets never learn. :lol::lol::lol:
 

AR87

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2013
Messages
3,217
Location
believer that Sancho will turn it around
He got sacked because he sided with his agent (sometimes against the interests of the club) and adopted a confrontational tone against our Board. Our President isn't a saint but when chosing between our President and Marco Silva in terms of defending our club's interests, it's Bruno de Carvalho all the way.
Thanks mate.

Also what are your thoughts about Adrien Silva as a player? You think he'll be able to make the step up to the Prem? I believe Leicester made a push for him last summer as well, right?
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Thanks mate.

Also what are your thoughts about Adrien Silva as a player? You think he'll be able to make the step up to the Prem? I believe Leicester made a push for him last summer as well, right?
No problem mate.

Adrien is a very good player and should be useful for Leicester. He isn't the typical technical with flair portuguese player. He is more like a hardworking midfielder with good engine, tactical awareness and positional sense. His best performance, where you can see the type of player he is, was his duel against Modric in the Euro 2016. He has been at the club for a while and it was a good time for him to move on. And yes Leicester did bid for him last year. It was a fair bid but we had sold João Mário and Slimani for record deals, so we couldn't afford to lose another influencial player so we rejected the deal.
 

Crimson King

Full Member
Joined
May 11, 2013
Messages
3,085
Our resident Portuguese fans paint a very bleak picture of Portuguese football that i wasn't aware about.

It still appears to be a bit of a talent factory from the outside looking in, but I wonder how long that can last...
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Our resident Portuguese fans paint a very bleak picture of Portuguese football that i wasn't aware about.

It still appears to be a bit of a talent factory from the outside looking in, but I wonder how long that can last...
Because that's the truth mate. Our football has no credibility and like the country itself it's full of corruption scandals. Here it isn't like England where when you lose it's because of your shortcomings. In Portugal there are bribes to refs, clubs trying to control FA's and games being bought by Mafias. Our league is a mess but the talents will keep coming up. The reasoning is simple. Clubs have top notch facilities, scouts and coaches and at the youth level there isn't as much corruption. So if you are a really good player you will eventually move out of the swamp. So even with all the problems, that's why we keep producing top players and our NT keeps getting good results.
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,375
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Our resident Portuguese fans paint a very bleak picture of Portuguese football that i wasn't aware about.

It still appears to be a bit of a talent factory from the outside looking in, but I wonder how long that can last...
It will continue to last simply because portuguese clubs usually overachieve in UEFA competitions with the budgets at their disposal. It is an interesting league, and the small clubs are decently organized and have good conditions at their disposal. And like it or not, there's actually some criteria at the transfer market (except in Mendes transfers :D )

We had our dark ages in the 90's, where the only team who actually did something in Europe was Porto. All the other teams were quite terrible having results.

But things improved since than, happily. We are no longer a top tier league like in the 80's, but we still have a decent level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sly

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,375
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Because that's the truth mate. Our football has no credibility and like the country itself it's full of corruption scandals. Here it isn't like England where when you lose it's because of your shortcomings. In Portugal there are bribes to refs, clubs trying to control FA's and games being bought by Mafias. Our league is a mess but the talents will keep coming up. The reasoning is simple. Clubs have top notch facilities, scouts and coaches and at the youth level there isn't as much corruption. So if you are a really good player you will eventually move out of the swamp. So even with all the problems, that's why we keep producing top players and our NT keeps getting good results.
Football is mainly an entretainment industry nowadays. It's a romantic thought to think that only in our league those things happen. It's installed everywhere.
From the day this started to be a bilions business, other interests imeddiatly try to install themselves at key positions to ensure that the business never stops growing. Everyone has a tag price, unfortunatelly.

The major difference is in the scale, imho.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Football is mainly an entretainment industry nowadays. It's a romantic thought to think that only in our league those things happen in our league. It's installed everywhere.
From the day this started to be a bilions business, other interests imeddiatly try to install themselves at key positions to ensure that the business never stops growing. Everyone has a tag price, unfortunatelly.

The major difference is in the scale, imho.
Perhaps you are right in some extent. I think that in Spain, the same happens. We have boundaries but it's the same mentality. It happened in Italy with Juventus and in France with Marseille. But in England (or Germany) i don't believe in that one bit. That's why i used it like an example. I wish i wasn't so sentimentally attached to Sporting. It would be easier for me to stop following football. Damm you Father and Grandpa :mad:
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,375
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Perhaps you are right in some extent. I think that in Spain, the same happens. We have boundaries but it's the same mentality. It happened in Italy with Juventus and in France with Marseille. But in England (or Germany) i don't believe in that one bit. That's why i used it like an example. I wish i wasn't so sentimentally attached to Sporting. It would be easier for me to stop following football. Damm you Father and Grandpa :mad:
The stupid thing is that Calcio Caos was not mainly about Juventus winning the title. It was all about betting industry and betting mafias making influence over the game results.

Marseille at least was a "classic" corruption, where they paid to win the games.

Nowadays you have a system that will favour the team with the hotest prospects so they can be sold at high prices to the market. This is not about Sporting, Benfica or Porto. It's all about selling products (players). The preripherical leagues are all a showcase for the big leagues. They need to to show products (players) and make them look god.

Coming back to Juve, how much of the 100M€ really got to the club? Or how much of the 54M€ for Magala reached Porto's bank account?
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
The stupid thing is that Calcio Caos was not mainly about Juventus winning the title. It was all about betting industry and betting mafias making influence over the game results.

Marseille at least was a "classic" corruption, where they paid to win the games.

Nowadays you have a system that will favour the team with the hotest prospects so they can be sold at high prices to the market. This is not about Sporting, Benfica or Porto. It's all about selling products (players). The preripherical leagues are all a showcase for the big leagues. They need to to show products (players) and make them look god.

Coming back to Juve, how much of the 100M€ really got to the club? Or how much of the 54M€ for Magala reached Porto's bank account?
Nope mate. Moggi also picked and asked for refs in certain games. It's in wiretappings. Same type of behaviour we have seen in certain clubs here in Portugal.

Rest i agree. As for your transfer examples you could have mentioned your own club or mine under Godinho Lopes.
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,375
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Nope mate. Moggi also picked and asked for refs in certain games. It's in wiretappings. Same type of behaviour we have seen in certain clubs here in Portugal.

Rest i agree. As for your transfer examples you could have mentioned your own club or mine under Godinho Lopes.
Truth about Moggi, but also truth that he was getinng overpaid by betting mafias by doing it. He was probably doing, as we say in portuguese, "Juntar o útil ao agradável".

But the incredible thing is: with all this messy stuff, disorganization, super-agents and super agent enterprises influences over the clubs, we manage to get competitive clubs at UEFA competitons. The law of "desenrasca" always finds a way in Portugal :D
 

Inter Yer Nan

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
6,380
Location
Los Angeles, CA (from UK)
Didn't realize Portuguese Football was in such a state. Been trying to make an effort to watch more of it this season if I can. Is it worth it or no? Was just going to stick to the big 3 as I've usually enjoyed them in the past.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Truth about Moggi, but also truth that he was getinng overpaid by betting mafias by doing it. He was probably doing, as we say in portuguese, "Juntar o útil ao agradável".

But the incredible thing is: with all this messy stuff, disorganization, super-agents and super agent enterprises influences over the clubs, we manage to get competitive clubs at UEFA competitons. The law of "desenrasca" always finds a way in Portugal :D
True on both counts.

Excluding some "dirigentes" who are worthless, we have alot of competent coaches, scouts and our academies are well run. Among the best in Europe in terms of competence.
 

Sly

Hang Ten
Scout
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
12,256
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Didn't realize Portuguese Football was in such a state. Been trying to make an effort to watch more of it this season if I can. Is it worth it or no? Was just going to stick to the big 3 as I've usually enjoyed them in the past.
You should stick to the three big clubs, the games between them and the occasional Braga and Guimarães match. The rest is usually boring. The problem with portuguese football isn't the quality of the players, it's quality of the boards and the directors.
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,375
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
Didn't realize Portuguese Football was in such a state. Been trying to make an effort to watch more of it this season if I can. Is it worth it or no? Was just going to stick to the big 3 as I've usually enjoyed them in the past.
All peripherical leagues are "damaged" by the money injection from the tycoons who bought clubs all over Europe, not only a problem from the portuguese league. As I said, we are mainly used as a showcase so the tycoon owned clubs come and get the players for overpriced values, where probably 40-50% of that transfer is divided by agent fees, lawyer fees, etc, etc

It doesn't mean the leagues can't still have quality. The problem is that most of those players that come from some sources will play, no mather what :D

In my opinion, the portuguese league has some nice games to watch. Braga, Rio Ave and Guimarães usually display good football to watch, even though Guimarães are in a bad form at the moment.

Sporting will probably be a good club to watch for the neutrals, since Jorge Jesus likes to implement a high pace + high pressure system, who eventually breaks the players stamina at long term in the season.
 

Inter Yer Nan

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
6,380
Location
Los Angeles, CA (from UK)
All peripherical leagues are "damaged" by the money injection from the tycoons who bought clubs all over Europe, not only a problem from the portuguese league. As I said, we are mainly used as a showcase so the tycoon owned clubs come and get the players for overpriced values, where probably 40-50% of that transfer is divided by agent fees, lawyer fees, etc, etc

It doesn't mean the leagues can't still have quality. The problem is that most of those players that come from some sources will play, no mather what :D

In my opinion, the portuguese league has some nice games to watch. Braga, Rio Ave and Guimarães usually display good football to watch, even though Guimarães are in a bad form at the moment.

Sporting will probably be a good club to watch for the neutrals, since Jorge Jesus likes to implement a high pace + high pressure system, who eventually breaks the players stamina at long term in the season.
Yeah, I always tended to have a preference for Sporting I guess because of Figo, Ronaldo, Nani coming through the ranks and that. I'll have a look tomorrow if I can.
 

FC Ronaldo

Posts stuff that's been said before in tweet form
Joined
Aug 22, 2014
Messages
12,043
They gave West Ham's owners shit and for that, I appreciate all that they do. We need more of that action, not less.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Didn't realize Portuguese Football was in such a state.
It always was, nothing new.
Is it worth it or no?
It depends on what you like, if you want to see better games, in theory should be between the 3 main clubs, more Braga and Guimarâes, but this year they look crap, maybe better Rio Ave instead.

The problem is the lack of money, so instead of developing more players from the academies, clubs are way too cautious on that, and sometimes when someone more talented arrives there comes the Mendes bus hype train and then they leave, it is all part of the "process".

But I guess we will always have some new players arriving, there are very good coaches in this country, not only at professional level, also on the youth sector, as there are also good scouts, if not it wouldn't be possible for example clubs like Benfica in 2009/2010 having this eleven:

Quim (weak link), Ruben Amorim (normal player), Fabio Coentrão, Luisão, David Luis, Javi Garcia, Aimar, Ramires, Di Maria, Saviola, Cardoso.

Or Porto in 2010/2011

Helton, Sapunaru, Alvaro Pereira, Rolando, Otamendi, Fernando (ex City), Guarin, Moutinho, Hulk, Varela, Falcão.

I could go on and on, but now it is more and more dificult to keep these type of players here, with the huge flows of money, not only coming from England, but also the flux of capital coming from Asia and all that.
 
Last edited:

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Our resident Portuguese fans paint a very bleak picture of Portuguese football that i wasn't aware about.

It still appears to be a bit of a talent factory from the outside looking in, but I wonder how long that can last...
No problem, ignore the crap we write here, we are not perfect, but I guess we will always have our "ups" and "downs", imo the picture in 2014 was more "dark" than today regarding new players, even if we have a likeable guy as NT head coach but with way outdated football concepts for my taste. :lol:
 

Inter Yer Nan

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
6,380
Location
Los Angeles, CA (from UK)
Is it common to show the bigger teams/better games on the Friday? Usually the Spanish games are a bit weaker on Friday's and I'll give the Sporting game a watch tomorrow but my sports schedule is jam packed Saturday's and Sunday's. GOL TV has the games and they show a little beyond the big three but I'd like to see if they have a highlights/roundup show also.
 

Bojan11

Full Member
Joined
May 16, 2010
Messages
33,113
I don't even know why you guys take someone seriously who compares the management of a football club to Hitler and Göbbels.

Football executives talking a bit of shit isn't something specific to Portugal. In Germany people like Watzke, Hoeneß and Tönnies do it quite often as well. They wouldn't necessarily call people Dildos (which I think goes too far), but since they rely on votes they have to be politicians to a certian degree and as such you have to sometimes make populist statements.
It's not too far, it's banter.

You probably don't know this. But the West Ham owners made their money off selling pornography hence the digs.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Is it common to show the bigger teams/better games on the Friday? Usually the Spanish games are a bit weaker on Friday's and I'll give the Sporting game a watch tomorrow but my sports schedule is jam packed Saturday's and Sunday's. GOL TV has the games and they show a little beyond the big three but I'd like to see if they have a highlights/roundup show also.
Common common, I wouldn't say, but it is quite normal to have games between Friday to Monday, so tomorrow you can "watch" Feirense vs Sporting in Portugal starts at 7 p.m dunno where you are, or Benfica vs Portimonense at 9 p.m.

Probably because the Champions League will start, but if you like to watch games at Saturday or Sunday cause you are watching Premier League, it is the same stuff as Spain regarding the hour of the matches, also if you want to ask when Sporting plays, you always can ask on the portuguese football thread, where you will find always a great portuguese poster even if he has a lot of crap to say about his country.

Regarding Sporting, atm the youngest players we have on our 11 is Gelson Martins and Bruno Fernandes, Jorge Jesus our head coach likes more experienced players, so it is more dificult if we want to compete with Benfica or Porto to put so many players as we used to do in the past.

By the way if you are going to watch the game tomorrow, it will not be a easy match for us, only because they are a small club, our opponent even having a low budget has a old school style of management, where they do not live on loans from bigger clubs, and their head coach for me is one of the biggest revelations from last season.
 

Tomuś

Nani is crap, I tell you!
Joined
Oct 17, 2011
Messages
6,177
Location
Świdnik
I can explain the sporting management from a point of view of a portuguese that is not a fan of sporting and not even a fan of the one of the top 3 clubs in portugal.

You will find it harsh my comparision but this is the truth, the real truth.

Bruno de Carvalho = Hitler
Saraiva = Goebbels.

The strategy is exactly the same has the nazis. Sporting it's a club that's beeing attacked from all the fronts and even from inside. This is the perspective of the managment. Even yesterday or two days ago, Bruno de Carvalho, the chairman said something like "the sporting fans that criticize me they are stupid or benfica fans"

On a 3 hour interview to sporting tv he was even capable of saying/blackmail William with a phrase in the likes of "He should be thankfull for his career because it was all because of me, not the coach ( Leonardo Jardim) but me.

He is also so fair and professional that he left is wife to start banging a sporting worker and even re activated a marketing section to put her has boss of that section.

Propaganda is really high on the sporting side. Fans dont talk against the chairman. He even got 90% of the votes on the last run.

Just a quick edit. football in portugal is rotten and decaying. It will die. don't try to know more about this corpse called Liga Nos
Jeez, sounds like Schulzes, Merkels and Timmermans of this world ('My right is the rightest!!!!') rather than Hitler/Goebbels. I'd also be careful with the use of 'Nazis' and 'Hitler' everywhere, as a Pole whose family experienced their methods too well (find me a Pole whose didn't) I'm appalled by the liberal use and nicknaming everyone like that. Smacks of extreme leftist approach to discredit anyone who doesn't jump on a bandwagon.
 

antohan

gets aroused by tagline boobs
Joined
Apr 24, 2002
Messages
42,177
Location
Montevideo
I don't even know why you guys take someone seriously who compares the management of a football club to Hitler and Göbbels.
I see where you are coming from, but as someone with a more detached perspective on Nazism I understood straight away he referred to the use of communication and propaganda and reactions they try to elicit, not content.
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
I see where you are coming from, but as someone with a more detached perspective on Nazism I understood straight away he referred to the use of communication and propaganda and reactions they try to elicit, not content.
He's right that our president is a populist that says a lot of shit, no need to make that comparison though.

He's wrong about everything else and that was a terrible post.

He is also so fair and professional that he left is wife to start banging a sporting worker and even re activated a marketing section to put her has boss of that section.
People that take their time to know things like this are the normal portuguese fan by the way. Imagine a Bournemouth fan complaining about Ed Woodward leaving his wife for a Manchester United employee... it would be nuts. Not here. Football shows in England are about the goals and some analysis. In Portugal shit like this is subject to a 1 hour discussion on national TV.

Fans dont talk against the chairman. He even got 90% of the votes on the last run.
He's wrong about this too. Plenty of sporting fans talk against the president especially the way he speaks out to the press and creates unnecessary drama, he got 90% of the votes because he's done a very good job and put our club into a much healthier position not because he's brainwashed Sporting fans with propaganda speeches.
 

antohan

gets aroused by tagline boobs
Joined
Apr 24, 2002
Messages
42,177
Location
Montevideo
He's right that our president is a populist that says a lot of shit, no need to make that comparison though.

He's wrong about everything else and that was a terrible post.
No idea on right or wrong, just popped in for a read because I have a (minor) soft spot for Sporting Lisbon.

It's a style thing ultimately. I suppose he could describe it the way you just did, but it's a bit bland and gets lost in guff.

To describe such a personality with a comms lackey I can't think of any other world-reknowned combo that drives the point home. It's obvious that there's several orders of magnitude separating their actions, that shouldn't (and doesn't IMO) require clarification.