Like, respect, it doesn’t matter. It shouldn’t enter into it. They are supposed to be professionals after all.
Appointing Solskjaer was a mistake
- Thread starter R.N7
- Start date
- Status
It mightn't be a conscious decision, they are not going out thinking I'm playing bad today. Maybe he just can't get the best out of them now the initial new manager novelty has wore off.
The terrible culture that seems to have developed at the club is the biggest issue. 3 managers in a row that were a terrible fit combined with Woodward and the Glazers is the most likely root cause (and we don't really know this as we are only looking at symptoms from the ouside).
If we can get a decent modern management structure in place, get rid of some deadwood, recruit well (to an actual plan) and promote well from within, then then Ole has a chance. Again, how good he is is an unknown as we are only peering in from the outside.
I'm still really curious as to why the team performed so well but now seem to have fallen well off the pace. Is something else going on that caused this change?
If we can get a decent modern management structure in place, get rid of some deadwood, recruit well (to an actual plan) and promote well from within, then then Ole has a chance. Again, how good he is is an unknown as we are only peering in from the outside.
I'm still really curious as to why the team performed so well but now seem to have fallen well off the pace. Is something else going on that caused this change?
Yep, although it's been useful to help top up my ignore list.
As much as I like him, I do think it’s pathetic how he still refused to park in Sir Alex’s parking spot, or how he continually refers to how Sir Alex did things as a reference point. It was okay when he was interim, but mate you’re the manager of Manchester United now. Be your own man.
Sad times indeed. This club is a mess
Im not sure what you mean, because it seems Fergie is in his ear constantly. Fergie's been invited to Carrington a few times, united are seemingly going back to the transfer policy we had in the Fergie era and Solsjaer is even dressed like a Fergie clone, red tie and all.
This!! When people say he says all the right things and is the man for the job, I cant help but think Fergie is actually telling him what to say, and Phelan is overseeing all the attacking drills like he did under Fergie
wtf are you even talking about? you started talking about Pogba in a thread that's about how appointing an unqualified manager was a mistake. at no point did i say that you said Pogba was shit, are you feeling ok?
this was your first reply to me:
see how you randomly started talking about pogba?
and below is my reply to you:
see how i never said that you or anyone else said pogba is shit?Yeah, man we have a 7 losses in 9 record because Pogba doesn’t give a feck despite him being instrumental in the run that gave an unqualified Ole the permanent job in the first place.
The fact that you even singled out and/or attempted to attribute this shit to Pogba
I’m convinced you guys scream “curse you Pogba!!!!” when you spill your coffee in the morning or some shit
You're so discombobulated you can't even keep track of your conversations. Go do some spinning yoga classes or something man, i promise that when you come back Ole will still be an inept, out of his depth, unqualified manager, but hopefully Pogba won't be living rent free on your mind any longer.
13-8-8. That was Klopp's first season record after he joined Liverpool in October, including a 6-1 hammering by Stoke City.
What happened towards the end of the season? The players were knackered. He didn't have his own squad. Liverpool were not better by any stretch of results and they finished 8th.
But...gradually, Klopp instilled fitness in the squad. Gradually, he bought players that he wanted. Gradually, he whitened his teeth. Gradually, he got rid of deadwood. Gradually, Liverpool improved.
Ole needs time. He needs to instill fitness. He needs to bring in his own players. He needs to adapt to the new Premier League. He needs to influence transfer strategy and work with the coaching staff. Improvements don't happen overnight, despite his impressive 14 first games (the players were bound to burn out after that, as we're seeing). Improvements take time.
Patience is a virtue, and sorely lacking on this forum. And to those insulting and denigrating Ole, shame on you.
What happened towards the end of the season? The players were knackered. He didn't have his own squad. Liverpool were not better by any stretch of results and they finished 8th.
But...gradually, Klopp instilled fitness in the squad. Gradually, he bought players that he wanted. Gradually, he whitened his teeth. Gradually, he got rid of deadwood. Gradually, Liverpool improved.
Ole needs time. He needs to instill fitness. He needs to bring in his own players. He needs to adapt to the new Premier League. He needs to influence transfer strategy and work with the coaching staff. Improvements don't happen overnight, despite his impressive 14 first games (the players were bound to burn out after that, as we're seeing). Improvements take time.
Patience is a virtue, and sorely lacking on this forum. And to those insulting and denigrating Ole, shame on you.
I'd be more optimistic if I know the club had a plan in place in order to bring United back to the top but giving Ole the job after 15 games was teenage girl's emotional reaction at its finest. I'm not saying Ole shouldn't have been United manager but the trial should've always been the end of the season not 2.5 months.
Ideally United should have a Sporting director by now to address the problems before season start, instead we have Eddy Willy Wonky who thinks United is Disneyland for adults and keeps rewarding mediocrities with new mega contracts and extensions. Is that look like a plan to anyone?
The rebuilding job is not one man's task. Even if it is, given our record in the last 5 years, the stars must align for us to get everything absolutely right next season.
Ole's being setup to fail and it's not his fault. The soon everyone realizes it the better.
Ideally United should have a Sporting director by now to address the problems before season start, instead we have Eddy Willy Wonky who thinks United is Disneyland for adults and keeps rewarding mediocrities with new mega contracts and extensions. Is that look like a plan to anyone?
The rebuilding job is not one man's task. Even if it is, given our record in the last 5 years, the stars must align for us to get everything absolutely right next season.
Ole's being setup to fail and it's not his fault. The soon everyone realizes it the better.
Unlike Klopp, Ole doesn't have a winning record as a manager, and he's never managed a big club. Its ok to have/express concerns without being disrespectful to him
comparing Ole to Klopp is madness. Klopp was a bonafide top manager when he took over at Liverpool, he had german titles and cups under his belt, and a CL final too
Correct, but despite his successes in Germany, he started slowly and had some embarrassing defeats and hilarious (from our perspective) moments for 2.5 years to get to this season. But he had the backing in market and by the board with a supporting staff to make it work (with a patient fanbase, presumably).
Klopp wasn't there for that 6-1 game. That was Rodgers.
Christ. Its just all so tedious.
So it was. They got hammered by City and Spurs the next season, which is more respectable.
Or the fact they played like this under two managers now says its them, and not the managers? Unless ole is sitting with joses playbook, theres no real reason they would be playing that same identical shitty way they were playing when jose was here.
The players and manager aren't up to scratch. That's the reality.
And yet most said he wasnt good enough for us
Everyone's favourite Pochettino, after a full preseason, took Spurs from 6th to 5th, but they amassed a lower points total (64 compared to 69 the previous year).
This isn't a slight on Pochettino. He's fantastic. But the point is, it takes time to build things, especially when the CEOs are tedious bellends (like Levy and Woodie).
No one knows if Solskjaer will be a success or a failure. But the one thing we can be sure of, is that Manchester United will not achieve success overnight.
This isn't a slight on Pochettino. He's fantastic. But the point is, it takes time to build things, especially when the CEOs are tedious bellends (like Levy and Woodie).
No one knows if Solskjaer will be a success or a failure. But the one thing we can be sure of, is that Manchester United will not achieve success overnight.
I cant say anything about ole, hes not been here long enough or brought in players to play his system. I can say hes failed in the past, quite badly, but who hasnt? If hes grown as a manger he deserves time to show it. If not, well we tried. I cant support the knee jerk reaction to the guy. He deserves a chance, and our support during that chance. But thats just me. I cant throw ole under the bus, when I know the players are a big issue currently. Id only be comfortable judging him after we get rid of a few problem players.
That's humiliating. Even if our 1 shot on goal had gone in, we'd still lose.
Those are the kind of stats I'd expect if a top club plays a club in the relegation zone.
I do feel that Ole is getting a free ride.
We have had relegation form for some time now.
Had Jose or LVG got results like this, most would want them sacked....including me.
I don't think it's Ole who does the contract extensions. That decision is taken by Woodward (who takes input from the manager, but makes his own decision) and the negotiations are carried out by Matt Judge.
I refuse to believe that Ole (or any manager), would be happy to have Young and Jones on our books, while shunning new player purchases in the Summer. Woodward on the other hand loves contract renewals as it saves money.
Maybe Fergie stopped managing remotely and said he you go son
If Ole thinks they are not good enough then there's no point in keeping them.
After his start he has to be given time. The results and performances have been terrible I dont think anyone can get away from that. However the reactions of some of our fans is borderline ridiculous.
I'm sure early next season if we are still playing awful and results are not improving a decision will be made by October.
Give the man a chance to turn it round I say.
Who are all these 'stars' that are 'cnuts' and rotting the rest of the team anyway? Did they have the same problem before they joined us, or do they just decide to turn up for training and rot the rest of the team?
I agree with that
I'm with you mate.
Fergie out! Remember that?
This place is a disgrace sometimes!
Some people are only in it for the short term. They haven’t got the patience to see how something pans out. Everything is automatically put into black/white divisions in their head.
What a stupid thread. Ole has just got the job, and any man with half a brain can see that his team is knackered.
You look at the injuries and the drop in work rate from the whole team, and it shows why things have changed. He would be pulling off a miracle if he got us into the top 4 - and with 3 games left, we still have an outside chance.
We can only hope he gets better support behind the scenes from the club. Ed Woodwood has already failed to deliver a contract renewal for Ander (who was Ole's go to guy) - and it appears we will need to find a replacement for him as well.
The squad needs building - and anyone who that Ole could paper over that crack was kidding himself.
You look at the injuries and the drop in work rate from the whole team, and it shows why things have changed. He would be pulling off a miracle if he got us into the top 4 - and with 3 games left, we still have an outside chance.
We can only hope he gets better support behind the scenes from the club. Ed Woodwood has already failed to deliver a contract renewal for Ander (who was Ole's go to guy) - and it appears we will need to find a replacement for him as well.
The squad needs building - and anyone who that Ole could paper over that crack was kidding himself.
We had the best manager available in the world but we didn't gave him enough power to build his own team so what's the point of doing it now for this guy ?
A 77 year old man who has had serious health problems is running the worlds biggest club through another person?
The players that really performed well(herrera, lingard, rashford, pogba etc.) switched off for one reason or another. If this reason is the manager I would be concerned. But Ole did seem to create some unity that hadnt been there since SAF left after his appointment, and if he can strengthen the squad (the weaknesses really shows when key players are injured/out of form) I think we should give him a chance next season. I really dont think anyone else in world football could have taken us on the run we had this year before the bad spell. If it was a one off thing, time will show.
Also, we need to recruit players with a stronger mentality, most of our players seem far too inconsistent and fragile. We need more winner/fighting spirit types and I think Ole will be looking for that more than anything else.
Too many people here only remember the trophies. They don't remember the struggles it took to get there.
This tenure hasn't even gotten started yet.
At least there's a few level heads
No one is a cnut, until they are.
What would you do then? Give up? Sack him?
We have to start somewhere. Something has to change. Personally I'd take a few seasons of good football with average results as long as a clear path and identity of the managers style is being formed.
We have had a lack of direction since SAF retired. Just a scatter gun approach to transfers and managers alike.
Hopefully giving ole time and appointing a DOF will set us on a clear path to modernising and finding a new identity of how we want to play moving forward so the next manager after ole fits the new style we want as a club.
It is all good though painting a whole squad of players as 'cnuts' just to defend a man that couldn't do his job properly anymore. Solskjaer being up to the task remains to be seen, though I'm not exactly convinced by what I've seen so far.
Im not saying Fergie is running the club, but its clear to me Ole is attempting to emulate him, and must be heavily relying on the old man for advice. Its pretty evident. Nothing wrong with being a student of Fergie and trying to lead like he did, but eventually Ole is going to have step into his own shoes here.
- Status