Of the players we've sold how many have become significantly better? It doesn't feel like it's very many. Carragher I'd just relishing his moment at the top which isn't even his moment.
I find it lazy by Redknapp, yes we bought good players, but none of them has been a fit for united. Let's get back to the signings shall we?:
Marouane Fellaini, £27.5m
Good player, scored some important goals for us, had the right mentality but not a good fit for us. Thought he reached his match potential with us.
Juan Mata, £37.1m
Great player in his prime, but coming to United, he still caught by the dilemma of not playing him in 10. Over the years he has given us goals and assists, while slowly regressing due to his age. Thought we got what we paid for.
Ander Herrera, £29m
We got what we paid for, was quality for us, and then got his move to PSG.
Luke Shaw, £31m
Was good pre-injury, but after that suffered from the lack of fitness and now Brandon Williams. Still an okay-ish investment.
Marcos Rojo, £16m
Van Gaal signed him on the back of a World Cup was ominous. Rojo has played in 113 out of a possible 274 games. Had a good five-month spell in Mourinho's first season that was halted by an anterior cruciate ligament injury, other than that he has almost always been poor. Impressively never been sent off. United have tried to sell him in three out of four summers.
Angel di Maria, £59.7m
Got the ability but not the right fit for United. We didn't make him shit, he failed to perform for us.
Daley Blind, £13.8m
Was technically very good for us, but seems like PL is not his level. He can play at European level apparently at Ajax, but he was never signed to be world class. We got what we paid for.
Radamel Falcao, £6m loan fee
Already shit after injury.
Victor Valdes, free
Already shit, retirement years.
Memphis Depay, £26.3m
Still shit/mediocre/decent at Lyon, found his level. We didn't turn him to shit, he can't handle the pressure and hopes here.
Matteo Darmian, £12.7m
Basic football player, did we made him into shit? Can't say so.
Morgan Schneiderlin, £25m
The moment he came for us, he seems shot of confidence, can't believe he was the same player at Soton. He can't cope with our hopes and expectations, is that for us to blame?
Then he went to Everton and still shit.
Bastian Schweinsteiger, £6.8m
Retirement age, injury prone, already shit.
Sergio Romero, free
Turns out to be solid.
Anthony Martial, £44m rising to £58m
Is he shit now? Don't think so. Decent.
Eric Bailly, £30m
He gets injured a lot, is that down to us too?
Zlatan Ibrahimovic, free
Light up the league, then got injured, United didn't turn him to shit either.
Henrikh Mkhitaryan, £26.3m
Arsenal and us failed to turn this player into the player he was at Dortmund. Us to blame?
Paul Pogba, £89m
Seriously can you blame Pogba when our team is filled with undeserving players to wear the jersey? The expectations towards him is Messi/Ronaldo like, but people forgets he is a fecking midfielder first.
Victor Lindelof, £30.9m rising to £39m
Improving steadily.
Romelu Lukaku, £75m rising to £90m
Brought in to carry an elite team. Found out that he can't do that, he is a shit player. His level is supporting cast, and leading striker at Everton/Inter Milan/Serie A.
Nemanja Matic, £35m rising to £40m
Already regressing at Chelsea, we got what we paid for.
Alexis Sanchez, swap
Already a shit player according to Arsenal fans. Swapped with another shit player. Club to blame?
Diogo Dalot, £19m
Youngster, improving over time. No verdict yet.
Fred, £52m
Raised his level into a power house. Turned to shit? I guess not.
Lee Grant, £1.5m
3rd choice keeper.