Would you sack or keep Ole? (Poll reopened)

Sack or Keep OLE?

  • Sack Ole & appoint new coach ASAP

  • Keep Ole & back him to finish rebuild


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Delano

Full Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
1,513
Let's see where we are by 11pm Monday... But he has to look at this squad and see that 4-2-3-1 isn't getting the best out of the players we have at our disposal.

He needs to adapt, he needs to implement a blueprint that doesn't just rely on individual quality... Problem is, I can't see much changing.
 

dogwithabone

Full Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2014
Messages
2,260
Whether you want him out or not, does anyone debate that he's been completely let down in this window? Same thing happened to Mourinho, not backed when it matters the most.
Sorry but I just don’t by that nonsense. Man for man we are light years ahead of Palace and Brighton and arguably stronger than Tottenham but we’ve been utterly outclassed in all but one game. Ole has either signed - or decided to keep (de Gea, Pogba, etc) - the majority of that side. He’s had three windows yet how much further forward are we ? I’d say a bit, some might say a fair bit, but either way I think as fans we have a right to expect way way better than the rubbish churned out so far the season. A 2-9 aggregate at home this season against sides we’d beat with one eye shut for the past 30 years. Yes the board have questions to answer re recruitment but any deficiency in that area should show up in the CL against Real or Barcelona, not Palace, Brighton or Spurs in the PL.
 

soapythecat

Full Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2006
Messages
3,802
Location
Glasgow resident these days.
You would trust Ole with getting another CB after he sanctioned 80 mil for Maguire?
He insisted on Maguire and we paid a huge fee for him. He has regressed under Ole. Ditto for AWB. He was best RB in the league for us at one stage, and now he’s garbage.
Giving Ole more money is like tackling CV19 with a plastic face shield.
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
We came third last season? We've had a terrible window and we started this season later as a result of a late finish to the season. We are still not where we need to be as a team yet this season compared to how we finished last season for a variety of reasons. Get Ole a quality CB to go with Telles and give the team to the 10 games mark before we start making sack Ole statements.
er

We should have got Ranieri then. He won the PL with Leicester an unfancied side.
 

FreakyJim

90% of teams play better football than us
Joined
Jan 16, 2006
Messages
9,082
Location
Glazers Out
Ole is the youngest "dinosaur" manager around. Wouldn't look out of place in the 90s.
 

Anustart89

Full Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
15,955
Part in bold is pathetic.

Your entire reasoning is so off base. So because a few other teams are also shipping goals left and right, it doesn't matter if we are too. You are the perfect fan for the Glazers.

Get your own head up from your ***. I won't stop supporting the club. And I hope Ole does well for us, but I've lost hope in him managing anything with us going forward.
People were having a go at me this week because I didn't think 66 points was that impressive, even if we got third. They'd probably class it as progress if we somehow managed to get 2nd with 44 points this season.

It's like our own performances don't matter in terms of how we are doing as a club as everything is judged in relation to other teams.
 

Eddy_JukeZ

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
17,130
People were having a go at me this week because I didn't think 66 points was that impressive, even if we got third. They'd probably class it as progress if we somehow managed to get 2nd with 44 points this season.

It's like our own performances don't matter in terms of how we are doing as a club as everything is judged in relation to other teams.
It wasn't impressive. It's been debated on here plenty of times. We didn't improve much from Jose to Ole. Ole got backed with plenty of signings to improve the team for that season.

It was the bare minimum for that season.
 

FreakyJim

90% of teams play better football than us
Joined
Jan 16, 2006
Messages
9,082
Location
Glazers Out
Feck it, let's give him 7 years so there won't be any excuses and moaning. SAF got six years to turn it around, it's only fair.
 

Anustart89

Full Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
15,955
It wasn't impressive. It's been debated on here plenty of times. We didn't improve much from Jose to Ole. Ole got backed with plenty of signings to improve the team for that season.

It was the bare minimum for that season.
Completely agree. Our point tallies haven't really changed much. We've clearly picked up more points against the top sides, but since we've obviously not improved in total points one can assume that we've regressed against the poorer sides.
 

UnofficialDevil

Anti Scottish and Preoccupied with Donkeys.
Joined
Aug 5, 2006
Messages
19,019
Location
I'm not anti Scottish, I just wanted Moyes out.
Haha...the cultists are running on fumes now
  • Klopp lost today's game 7-2
  • SAF lost some games conceding 5 or 6 goals in his legendary career
  • No manager could do anything better with the squad
  • It's Woodward and Glazers doing the tactics and coaching
  • It's fecking Mourinho's fault
  • No preseason
  • Players are brain-dead
  • Let's stick with this because next manager will not be backed.
  • We need Sancho Koulibaly etc to be competitive.
It really is pathetic.
 

Eddy_JukeZ

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
17,130
Part of me is up for it - that part of me then also wants the club to identify all the Ole in crowd, set up a family planning program at OT and breed stupid out of the fanbase for good. If we want to go long term, lets go real long term.
The sad part is, I don't think your hypothetical is entirely unrealistic.

This entire club(fans too) is so enamored by the idea of 1 man leading for years and years, they might just give Ole 5 years.
 

Random Task

WW Lynchpin
Joined
Feb 7, 2010
Messages
34,503
Location
Chester
The sad part is, I don't think your hypothetical is entirely unrealistic.

This entire club(fans too) is so enamored by the idea of 1 man leading for years and years, they might just give Ole 5 years.
Nah, Ole will be sacked if he fails to make top four this year.
 

r0663664

Worships Man City
Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Messages
2,684
Location
Singapore
Imagine Ole is sack right now. Will Fulham, Aston Villa, Brighton, Newcastle sign Ole? The answer is "no". Anyone who watch Utd play knows Ole has nothing. All he wants is a star player through individual brilliance to win a game. Anyone of old boys will do better than him. Bruce or Mark Huges, they have works at club with limited budget where they needed the team is structured and compact. Ole isn't the right person from day 1, I knew it would not sustain. Feel good factor in his first season, then Bruno's effect in the 2nd season. This season, it is Sancho. Ole forget that football is a team sports. Poch in, we need someone who start from the bottom. Not someone who get the keys to Old Trafford because he is one of the favourite son.
 

Enigma_87

You know who
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
27,654
Imagine Ole is sack right now. Will Fulham, Aston Villa, Brighton, Newcastle sign Ole? The answer is "no". Anyone who watch Utd play knows Ole has nothing. All he wants is a star player through individual brilliance to win a game. Anyone of old boys will do better than him. Bruce or Mark Huges, they have works at club with limited budget where they needed the team is structured and compact. Ole isn't the right person from day 1, I knew it would not sustain. Feel good factor in his first season, then Bruno's effect in the 2nd season. This season, it is Sancho. Ole forget that football is a team sports. Poch in, we need someone who start from the bottom. Not someone who get the keys to Old Trafford because he is one of the favourite son.
If by some strange reason they indeed employ him, they will be rock bottom by the end of the season. He'll get found out very soon enough at the next club that decides to appoint him.

With all the shite and namecalling of our players they are still streets ahead with what he would have at Fulham, Newcastle and Brighton.
 

Dominos

Full Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
7,006
Location
Manchester
It's genuinely shocking how far people will sink before admitting we're getting nowhere under him. Absolutely pathetic lack of standards.

I wonder if some of these people work for their parents or something because I haven't been allowed such leeway in normal job, ever.
He's had 1 full season here and his target was top 4 and he finished 3rd.

If you don't think he's ultimately up to it in terms of turning us into champions then fair enough, but to paint the narrative that he's got away with murder by keeping his job is completely false when he has met the target given.

We're 3 games in and we turned our season round from a much worse point last year, so I can see why the board haven't panicked yet.
 

Eddy_JukeZ

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
17,130
He's had 1 full season here and his target was top 4 and he finished 3rd.

If you don't think he's ultimately up to it in terms of turning us into champions then fair enough, but to paint the narrative that he's got away with murder by keeping his job is completely false when he has met the target given.

We're 3 games in and we turned our season round from a much worse point last year, so I can see why the board haven't panicked yet.
Not sure if we had a run of 3 games where we got utterly dominated like this last season.

Brighton should have comfortably won their game were it not for divine luck.
 

Wilt

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
6,751
Skybet have now made Ole clear 5/4 favourite to be the next manager to leave/sack
 

Luke1995

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2016
Messages
3,460
Wouldn't someone like Carlo Ancelotti have been better for us ? At least he has a proven track record in management...

Multi time champion for Milan

Champion for Chelsea

Champion for PSG

Champions league winner for Madrid

After Madrid he did decline a little bit, yeah, but he is still Carlo Ancelotti

I don't understand why we weren't in for him when Jose was sacked. It looks like he will do a great job at Everton.
 

Dominos

Full Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
7,006
Location
Manchester
Not sure if we had a run of 3 games where we got utterly dominated like this last season.

Brighton should have comfortably won their game were it not for divine luck.
True but we were in a genuinely awful position as late as December/January last year which looked irretreivable, no one would have predicted our turn around.

Frankly we can't be as bad as we've shown in the first 3 games, our performances must pick up at some point.
 

LDUred

Full Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2019
Messages
1,872
Liverpool lost 7-2 to Villa today: should they fire Klopp? It was a bad day at the office, and coupled with the complete absence of fans inside Old Trafford and the loss of Martial early on, it turned into a mismatched training session.

Ole has made it pretty clear that the board haven't backed him even close to what he has asked for. That indicates pretty strongly that the money simply isn't there to make the reinforcements we need to make a genuine challenge at the top of the league. So an incoming manager would be lumbered with the same abject, demotivated squad and tasked with limited funds to make new acquisitions. He wouldn't have the limited success Ole has had with the same group of players to fall back on, and would be surrounded by the strange, discomforting atmosphere of an empty Old Trafford.

Our best option is to take this on the chin and remind ourselves that this is the same group of players who finished third last season and who got to the latter stages of the Europa League. It is not the time to call for Ole's head. He's not what's holding the club back, the owners are.

Some of you just have to accept that the club has been run in a lacklustre fashion for a while now and the man bearing the brunt of it is the manager, who is in a hopeless position. He's the fall guy for the lack of investment in the club, season after season.

With a bit of togetherness and team spirit we might go on a run again and get a head of steam, but this idea that a new manager would work wonders with this current squad and the overarching structure of the club is a pipe dream. We are where we are for a reason and it is chronic lack of investment in Manchester United Football Club.
 

caid

Full Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2014
Messages
8,332
Location
Dublin
I wouldn't be against firing him at this point. He's not as bad as his critics will say but hes not that good either. Won't solve the 1000 other problems at the club though.
 

Matt6677

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 20, 2019
Messages
95
Should be sacked for the Maguire signing and then making him the captain straightaway

Absolute idiot.
 

Cloud7

Full Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
12,854
Can’t believe that Liverpool losing is being used to defend our dead end manager. There really are no lengths that our fanbase won’t go to.
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
Liverpool lost 7-2 to Villa today: should they fire Klopp? It was a bad day at the office, and coupled with the complete absence of fans inside Old Trafford and the loss of Martial early on, it turned into a mismatched training session.

Ole has made it pretty clear that the board haven't backed him even close to what he has asked for. That indicates pretty strongly that the money simply isn't there to make the reinforcements we need to make a genuine challenge at the top of the league. So an incoming manager would be lumbered with the same abject, demotivated squad and tasked with limited funds to make new acquisitions. He wouldn't have the limited success Ole has had with the same group of players to fall back on, and would be surrounded by the strange, discomforting atmosphere of an empty Old Trafford.

Our best option is to take this on the chin and remind ourselves that this is the same group of players who finished third last season and who got to the latter stages of the Europa League. It is not the time to call for Ole's head. He's not what's holding the club back, the owners are.

Some of you just have to accept that the club has been run in a lacklustre fashion for a while now and the man bearing the brunt of it is the manager, who is in a hopeless position. He's the fall guy for the lack of investment in the club, season after season.

With a bit of togetherness and team spirit we might go on a run again and get a head of steam, but this idea that a new manager would work wonders with this current squad and the overarching structure of the club is a pipe dream. We are where we are for a reason and it is chronic lack of investment in Manchester United Football Club.
Why should they fire him? He has won them the PL last season, he has won the CL the previous season, he has been in a CL Final with Dortmund and won the Bundesliga with them a couple of seasons. What has Ole done as a manager that is even close to what Klopp has done or doing now?
Losing to Spurs at home is not the issue nor is it the scoreline but we have been terrible this season and even last season we would not have made it to the CL spot until Leicester imploded. We should have been beaten by Brighton and that means we would have been in the relegation zone now. He has no plan and not the ability to change the system and get the 11 players to play in a system. It has been down to individual brilliance to get us out of trouble all the time. Last season mostly due to Bruno Fernandes.
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,423
Location
left wing
If he wanted to emulate SAF, he should have brought in a top coach or two to assist him - Ole could have left the backroom staff to get on with the tactics and fitness, while he did the "United legend" cheerleader stuff.

Carrick et al clearly aren't up to it - AWB, James, Maguire all looked like they had something to offer when they arrived, but we've coached that right out of them. Fernandes will probably be next to regress and VDB must be wondering if he's just committed career suicide.

The structure of the side is appalling, we can't defend as a unit, can't build up from the back, can't press the ball, can't play in an organised attack, our fitness levels are atrocious and the players don't look motivated. From a tactical/coaching perspective, it's difficult to think of anything that is actually going well.
 

Paul_Scholes18

Full Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2014
Messages
13,891
I wanted to give him this season, but this is so bad that we have to try something else.
Bring in someone with a bit of winning mentality that can help us in the cups.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,594
Supports
Mejbri
If he wanted to emulate SAF, he should have brought in a top coach or two to assist him - Ole could have left the backroom staff to get on with the tactics and fitness, while he did the "United legend" cheerleader stuff.

Carrick et al clearly aren't up to it - AWB, James, Maguire all looked like they had something to offer when they arrived, but we've coached that right out of them. Fernandes will probably be next to regress and VDB must be wondering if he's just committed career suicide.

The structure of the side is appalling, we can't defend as a unit, can't build up from the back, can't press the ball, can't play in an organised attack, our fitness levels are atrocious and the players don't look motivated. From a tactical/coaching perspective, it's difficult to think of anything that is actually going well.
Yeah, pretty much.
 

Blood Mage

Full Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2019
Messages
5,990
Can’t believe that Liverpool losing is being used to defend our dead end manager. There really are no lengths that our fanbase won’t go to.
Solskjaer is a club legend so the top reds are out in full force to defend him. Even they know deep down we're going nowhere under him though.
 

DOTA

wants Amber Rudd to call him a naughty boy
Joined
Jul 3, 2012
Messages
24,504
I'd probably keep him for now but I'm not particularly confident he'll turn things around. I just still think it's reasonably plausible and I'm not particularly confident a new manager will turn things around.
 

shahzy

Full Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2014
Messages
985
Wouldn't someone like Carlo Ancelotti have been better for us ? At least he has a proven track record in management...

Multi time champion for Milan

Champion for Chelsea

Champion for PSG

Champions league winner for Madrid

After Madrid he did decline a little bit, yeah, but he is still Carlo Ancelotti

I don't understand why we weren't in for him when Jose was sacked. It looks like he will do a great job at Everton.
oh but you see he doesnt "Get the club" or something.

Above i said i wouldnt really blame ole before the 1-6 because its clear as day the problem is in the roots of this club ie: the board and woodward. They need to be ripped out. Cutting off the leaves serves no purpose if the roots are rotten. However its hard to defend ole, hes out of his depth too.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
If he wanted to emulate SAF, he should have brought in a top coach or two to assist him - Ole could have left the backroom staff to get on with the tactics and fitness, while he did the "United legend" cheerleader stuff.
Carrick et al clearly aren't up to it - AWB, James, Maguire all looked like they had something to offer when they arrived, but we've coached that right out of them. Fernandes will probably be next to regress and VDB must be wondering if he's just committed career suicide.
The structure of the side is appalling, we can't defend as a unit, can't build up from the back, can't press the ball, can't play in an organised attack, our fitness levels are atrocious and the players don't look motivated. From a tactical/coaching perspective, it's difficult to think of anything that is actually going well.
I strongly agree with you on this. I've heard Ole talk about MetalPepBall and he is obviously trying to implement his version of that. He should have recruited the best coaches available who knew how to implement this rather than rely on inexperienced coaches like Carrick and McKenna who are also having to learn on the hoof.
 

Jezpeza

Full Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2018
Messages
2,035
I'd probably keep him for now but I'm not particularly confident he'll turn things around. I just still think it's reasonably plausible and I'm not particularly confident a new manager will turn things around.
I’m in this boat. Whoever the manager is, we still need 6 or 7 players, and All the Clubs around us have good managers and players. Liverpool and Man City are stronger than last year. Huge investment at chelski. Jose has a Good squad at Spurs now. Everton looking reformed under Ancelotti. Arteta getting a tune out of the Gunners. Wolves have had strong recruitment and were already a good well managed side. Even Villa and Leeds are playing some ball.

All of them have done more than us in this market. Even if we bring in a new manager, all of those teams will still be strong tactically and personnel wise. Its not like we get a new manager and tactics and can suddenly blow everyone away. Even in the next couple of days, a relic and a rotation left back who we needed 5 years ago are going to do what?

I can well see Ole being sacked by xmas, but How many times are we going to let the board throw A manager under the bus after withdrawing the financial support at a pivotal moment?
 
Last edited:

Hawks2008

Full Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2015
Messages
4,912
Location
Melbz
The team just looks undercoached ue did will to get is where he did but I still maintained that we should upgrade on him.

That said I can't even get excited about the idea of a new manager either, it's just another guy for Woodward and his cronies to feck over.

What's the fecking point?
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
This is a decent team and they are not playing up to their best. Look at the way we are set up. A bunch of individual players and not a team.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.