talking robot
Full Member
If we can get a decent fee, let him go and buy antony.
Madnessstate of people in here...aye we are crying out for forwards and going to sell Rashford
You're deluded. If Sterling goes for £50m in EPL, Rashford would be worth £32m. Outside of EPL, probably £25M maxIn the current market and with his form, what would realistically Utd get for him? Considering how bad we are at dealing on sales, I'd be surprised if we got more than £40m but if it was Liv/Chel/Shitty they'd be getting around £65-70m.
25m barely gets you a championship winger nowadays, having a right laugh if your think the club would sell him for 32.You're deluded. If Sterling goes for £50m in EPL, Rashford would be worth £32m. Outside of EPL, probably £25M max
This is correct25m barely gets you a championship winger nowadays, having a right laugh if your think the club would sell him for 32
Wages.25m barely gets you a championship winger nowadays, having a right laugh if your think the club would sell him for 32.
Raphinha went for almost double that to a club outside of England after 2 years with a bottom table club
Because I think last season was an impossible situation. It was a toxic situation. The squad was horribly coached, horribly balanced, it spiralled, and just as Ralf started improving things and Rashford looked like he was about to get a glimpse of form back, Greenwood gets arrested and we are thrown back into turmoil. That does shit to a squad mentality. Ralf also had an interim title, which is very hard to fully invest in. Half the squad was leaving. They didn't give a feck, hard for the rest who are staying to perform normally. Once we lost to Atletico, the season was done for all. Rashford had a tough summer the year before, put off a surgery for playing in the euros, didn't end up playing at all apart from the penalty miss. He was mentally fecked after that too. And then had surgery to fix his injury. There were COUNTLESS reasons why last season went to shit. Yes, the players are also to blame. Yes, their mentality was shit. Yes the work rate was shit. Yes they gave up. But it's a 1 off season where everything snowballed and went wrong.Why are you writing off? The team that started last season was the team that finished 2nd the season before, and then added Varane, Sancho and Ronaldo, therefore it was an even better team. And when he failed in that team he was given a second chance and failed worse, finished the season on the bench. When other clubs replace their manager midseason, you know, like Tottenham, that doesn't seem to give their players free reign to down tools the remainder of the season, in fact it's usually a kick in the ass. I just want to know why that has to be written off? And no vague hyperbole, specifically.
Raphinha wasn’t sitting on north of 200k a week, though. A Raphinha transfer fee + Rashford’s wage puts a total package at a ridiculous number, even for a club like PSG25m barely gets you a championship winger nowadays, having a right laugh if your think the club would sell him for 32.
Raphinha went for almost double that to a club outside of England after 2 years with a bottom table club
Sell him and use the money to get Antony.
Bingo.If we can get a decent fee, let him go and buy antony.
Quite a big point that many seem to be missing.I’d be a lot more comfortable letting him go if I trusted the manager and board to replace him with someone better.
We’re struggling to get hold of one average one, let alone one to two top forwards.
Why would it matter what Raphina’s wage was at Leeds? That’s not what Barca are paying him.Raphinha wasn’t sitting on north of 200k a week, though. A Raphinha transfer fee + Rashford’s wage puts a total package at a ridiculous number, even for a club like PSG
Yes and yes.For the past ten years it feels like every time a player wants a better deal there is a curiously timed story of interest from another club, ultimately leading to us paying through the nose. Is this just me?
Are we this stupid to keep falling for the same move?
I never said they were? But a players current salary is generally indicative of what sort of salary they’ll receive at their new club. Reports say Raphinha was on 60k at Leeds and they also say he’s on 100k at Barcelona. That’s a relatively modest salary for a big club and is a big part of why Barcelona were willing to pay the large transfer fee.Why would it matter what Raphina’s wage was at Leeds? That’s not what Barca are paying him.
Time to go - he's completely regressedI'd sell if they offer more than £50mil for him.
You mean the value of the club and it’s assets. That’s different from sale value here, these contracts made them unsellable but kept the club valuable.I know it gets slated around here because it always seems to backfire, but I can see why Woodward felt justified in extending contracts to lock in value.
We need 3 starting forwards and 3 competent back ups, dont be silly.If you have a forward and still crying out for one. Then it mean he is not good enough. Simple. No two ways about it.
Nah he needs to stay and also continue to go against the government to help look after under privileged kids because that, weirdly, fecking annoys people.Meh. Guy is hardly a footballer these days, never mind a forward of any kind of use to us. Get rid. Even if we fail to get a replacement I'd rather see Garnacho and other kids get the chance than waste more time on this dude.
You putting Rashford on the same level as McTominay renders you unworthy to debate.We are also crying out for midfielders but will you be sad if McFred is linked elsewhere?
What did he do the season before, when he didnt have a broken back Statto?He scored 5 goals last season.
Some forward.
Fred scored as many league goals as he did, and 1 less in all comps.
Did you read some of those replies? agenda or what?Madness
I'm talking about this summer, though I wouldn't put it past these clowns who handle contracts to convince him to stay till next summer, only then for him to leave on a free.He'll leave on a free. His contracts up
Their contributions to the team are comparable over the last 18months and Rashford can command a decent fee that can be reinvested to the team. I don’t see why you feel surprised by the reactions on hereYou putting Rashford on the same level as McTominay renders you unworthy to debate.
Completely agreeWon't be a knock down fee because of the +1, quite clearly they are trying their hand at briefing to the media to try and force our hand for more money/years knowing they can ride the current sentiment/situation and use it to their advantage.
Call their bluff, I hope Rashford gets dropped for this personally and I hope he is gone by September. What a dick move.
You may well be right although its not beyond the realms of possibility that'll he'll return, time will tell.Some deluded Spurs fans thought the same about Alli.
He is busted flush. Cash in while he's still worth some millions.