Which just shows how little football fans generally know - he’d be their best CB.
Maguire | he stays!
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
Agree with this. I actually think Maguire is a decent defender but expecting any more than £20m for him is pure fantasy.
He probably would be due to not a lot of competition in that position at the moment. The problem is that he comes with a very high wage that would be disruptive to the team, he has a high price tag with zero sell off value & probably the biggest issue is that Ange Postecoglou wants to play attacking highline football & Maguire just isn't mobile enough to play that way.
Unfortunately, at his prime age, he is hardly good enough and commands too much in wages. So he prefers to sit it out on the bench for another 2 years and collect his pay than to take a pay cut and play elsewhere. Why should he bother moving?
That's awful
You’ve missed his excellent fitness record, which he’s even managed to maintain while at United; an injury graveyard for centre backs over the years.
Surely that’s something a decent salesman would bring up in the event of potential buyers scratching their chins over his high wages?
He needs a Michael Owen style brochure. "Stays fit"
Imagine this:
He stays
He scores a goal when we're losing 1-0
He does his "I can't hear you" celebration at 90th minutes for a total of 1 minute, draw.. 1-1
At 92th min he tackles a player and gives away a penalty
The game ends 2-1 (we lose)
The fans boo him and he taunts them back "Catch me outside how about that? I'm rich you are not"
Feeling angry yet?
He stays
He scores a goal when we're losing 1-0
He does his "I can't hear you" celebration at 90th minutes for a total of 1 minute, draw.. 1-1
At 92th min he tackles a player and gives away a penalty
The game ends 2-1 (we lose)
The fans boo him and he taunts them back "Catch me outside how about that? I'm rich you are not"
Feeling angry yet?
Thanks for the info.
If he doesn’t take the pay cut and push for a move it’s okay, it’s his good right. I just hope for the sake of justice that he will lose his England place for this and will have worse teams to chose from when he finally moves in 24/25. Btw, has the captains duty been removed from him already?
Here's the article: https://theguardian.com/football/2022/apr/04/manchester-united-phil-jones-football-injury-englandThat's awful
I checked his twitter and its the same as his Instagram. A few tweets over the last couple of months about leaving United and that's it. Most of the replies seem positive which is good.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
It would be quite helpful to the credibility of reports if "current suitors" were named.
He’s worth 35m of anybody’s money. Everton pay that sort of cash for Michael Keane and James Tarkowski ffs.
Both would be on a third of his wage, that’s a consideration.
We should just take his break even value (£27m for the remaining amortization of his contract) and run, provided we don’t have to subsidize his wage.
This is the problem. If Southgate picked on merit then he’d be out of the England set up and would be actively looking for a move right now. The fact that Gareth has clear favourites means Harry can pick up his fat cheques on our bench and still start for his country.
Would be an absolute travesty if we aren't able to make a deal with someone (West Ham?) before the window closes.
The only thing he'll "achieve" by staying on is to lose his status as a starter for England (maybe even his status as a squad member). Nobody wants that, surely.
The only thing he'll "achieve" by staying on is to lose his status as a starter for England (maybe even his status as a squad member). Nobody wants that, surely.
Surely not in the long run.
How many starts are we talking about, realistically, next season? How many appearances from the bench? He isn't a player ETH wants to rely on either as a starter (obviously) or as a backup (he doesn't fit the system).
Southgate won't keep picking someone who's a mere fringe player at his club.
'Caught offside' has zero credibility regardless.
Yes. Yes he will.
Philips and Maguire will almost definitely be in the starting XI next summer for England even if they don’t play a single minute for their clubs this upcoming season.
Just Southgate things.
I doubt that.
Can't see any clubs paying him close to the reported 220k a week he's now on though.
At this point I'd accept a transfer fee of £27 million and make him an offer of around £10 million up front just to get him away from the club.
If they offer him a £120k ish 4 years contract I think he would take that, if he sits on his ass for another 2 years with us for that £190k, by the time that runs out its hard to see any club offering an out of shape 32 year old anything close to £100k, so he’d be missing out.
Didn't Southgate say a few months ago that if Maguire doesn't start getting more game-time his place will be in jeopardy? Of course saying it and doing it is a different story.
Honestly if he played for wolves, Aston villa, Fulham I bet teams would pay this price, it's just weird how undervalued United players are to other sides
Bullshit. Of course he’s worth £35m. He’s England’s first choice CB. Teams just think we are mugs.
If he was playing for any of those clubs he wouldn't be on 220k a week.
Yes, but even if Southgate genuinely loves Maguire (on a personal level, a professional level or a combination of the two), he obviously can't keep picking him if he doesn't get the minutes at his club.
This is basic stuff. The England manager cannot and will not pick a player who hardly features for his club over a significant period of time.
thing is with maguire, is that none of his team mates have any respect for him. they don't rate him and they hold him in poor regard as a defender and a leader. he's stealing a living there and he knows it. he simply doesn't have the skills or attitude to turn things around for himself and it's going to be rough on him if he stays next season.
He's not going to take that sort of a pay cut. He could easily sit it out here and get a big offer from an overseas club in two years time.
Tbf, this goes back to the Sir Alex days, we would take any sort of reasonable fee just to move players on as it usually signified that we were done or the player was desperate to move on in search of more football. Butt and Phil Neville for instance went for fees that were absolute bargains for what they were and had achieved at all levels.
He will if theres no standout replacement. Englands CBs arent exactly top quality, and you know Maguire/Stones has had the best partnership even with Maguire having limited minutes time before the last world cup in Qatar. The tournament format woul work or somebody like Maguire with Southgate in charge.
With Colwill, Mings and Stones, alongside Walker, Southgate has fairly strong tactical selection of CBs. I wouldn't be surprised if Maguire is dropped.
Didn't realize you were on the in with the United squad, pray tell us whether they rate Sancho, does Rashford deserve a massive pay raise, are they glad to see the back of DDG - spill please
To be fair to Southgate, why would he drop Maguire? Maguire always play very well for England. In fact he is England best CB under Southgate. He is a very good player in certain system that suits him.
I think there will be club interested in signing him especially Italian clubs where Maguire's style will be perfect for them because Serie A is generally less intense and slower pace.
I think there will be club interested in signing him especially Italian clubs where Maguire's style will be perfect for them because Serie A is generally less intense and slower pace.
It's not his value that is the stumbling block for most clubs, It's the wages that are a killer. Very few Premier league clubs are in a position to pay a player 200,000 a week.
i'm best mates with verane, we own a vineyard together. he keeps sending me pictures on whatsapp of maguire with 'kick me' written on the back of his jersey and luke shaw filling his boots up with shampoo. my fave is a pic of one of the canteen staff sticking his knob into harry's spinach and ricotta roulade with a beetroot jus. i won't even mention what they did to his tuscany three-bean salad. i'll send it on to you if you like. what's your number?
He should drop him if he can't get in the side. It's what good international managers do they pick the players who are playing. I know the international game is slower, but if he can't get a game how is going to be match fit?