It isn't, so you should stop with that assumption for one.
My opinion is based on seeing the same thing happen to LVG, Jose and Ole
The club do not address the obvious squad issues
ETH issues last season are well documented too, lack of away wins vs top 9 and we didn't score enough goals (for obvious reasons)
You don't care what ETH did at previous clubs but you want to talk about managers at other clubs being better... right. Unless you are being disingenuous none of the managers mentioned have achieved what ETH has achieved in their careers
Does that mean ETH is the right manager to take United forward and should not be sacked, no it doesn't
You’re conflating different points and creating non existent arguments. My initial post was just to point out how United fans on here criticise other managers because Ten Hag is a failure. I never actually critiqued any of those managers.
But for arguments sake Ange has certainly achieved equal to what Ten Hag has. He has won titles in Australia and Japan. He won 6/8 trophies in Scotland including a treble. Not that I put much weight on those but it’s “disingenuous” to imply Ange hasn’t achieved what Ten Hag has.
Your opinion is based on managers being hired and then managers being fired?
This is how it works in football. Managers get hired, sometimes do well, sometimes do ok, sometimes do badly and sometimes get fired. We are not going through managers at a rate any higher than most clubs. It’s only at Man United where we make such a big song and dance about changing managers in 2024.
All of those managers were fired at different points of their reigns, everything wasn’t identical and they didn’t all have the same players.
As has been mentioned, Ten Hag vetoed against having someone above him build the squad, he wanted to do it. I absolute hate that the Glazers have continually allowed managers to do this over the years. But if you put yourself out there as a manager to take control over squad building then you damn sure better be ready to accept responsibility when it goes tits up. And apart from Ole, all our managers have put their egos before the club and have chosen that method and so any resulting squad issues are down to them I’m afraid.