Dan Ashworth - Newcastle DoF currently tending to his garden

OleGunnar20

Full Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2018
Messages
2,194
Some more completely rational and normal takes:





























:wenger::lol:
Hahaa, yes, we're the horrible club for pushing our generationally talented young striker out for his horrific behaviour. NUFC on the other hand are a bastion of the community, all the way up to the top of their spotless, not at all oil drenched club..

Where was that photo of the geordie sheiks again ..
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,806
I love how everyone is now an expert on contract law there now. Going off a hunch, it's only a hunch mind you, I reckon Ineos' legal team will know more on that than a random geordie.
 

Paul778

Full Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2017
Messages
1,188
Location
London
I don't think this is actually what he does FYI, he's oversees and builds the departments - I don't know how hands on he is with identifying players. At Brighton that was Paul Winstanely (now at Chelsea) and at Newcastle it's Nickson. It also depends how advanced our data project is given that is where Brighton's strength lay, in Star lizard. Basically, Ashworth isn't coming in and saying x, y and z are our targets for players, he is doing that for staff.
Yes. But in his absence who would do that? Any of the people involved in the Mount/Anthony/Onana transfers? <shudder>

It may be that we have a head of recruitment already lined up in the next few days that will be coming in, but time is moving on and anyone good is likely to have their own gardening leave problems.

In the absence of a good new Head of Recruitment and with INEOS saying in numerous forums that recruitment is the first thing they are going to get a handle on you've got to assume that Ashworth is going to be involved in it more than he would hopefully be in subsequent years.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,806
Yes. But in his absence who would do that? Any of the people involved in the Mount/Anthony/Onana transfers? <shudder>

It may be that we have a head of recruitment already lined up in the next few days that will be coming in, but time is moving on and anyone good is likely to have their own gardening leave problems.

In the absence of a good new Head of Recruitment and with INEOS saying in numerous forums that recruitment is the first thing they are going to get a handle on you've got to assume that Ashworth is going to be involved in it more than he would hopefully be in subsequent years.
We already have a massive scouting team so would assume they will still operate as normal. Not sure Onana is a bad transfer and Mount is a bit unknown.

I doubt he’ll be hands on, he’ll just set it all up and keep evolving it. Otherwise it’s just Glazer management all over again, putting someone like Murtough into a role he’s not done before, because he was good at something else. 100% he’ll be giving staff targets to the club already but not picking players.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,768
Downie was on a Utd fan channel yesterday (I know) and he thinks they will reach a compromise. His gut feeling is that he won't be here until the January window unless Utd stump up enough.
 

RedRocket9908

Full Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
2,364
Location
Manchester
20 signatures so far, bless him.
Starting petition like that is truely pathetic, I always though Newcastle had a good loyal fanbase but some of the stuff theyve done in recent times like punching Police Horses and filming themselves chanting about the Munich Air Disaster outside St James Park has put them in a whole new light and show just how horrible a lot of them are.
 

Stinkypete

Full Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2022
Messages
152
Roy Keane made a good point. He isn’t very loyal is he. Leaves clubs within a couple of years. Who’s to say he won’t join Madrid or something in a year or 2.
He might, and if that were to be a move upwards for him then fair play to him. At the very least within those two years he will have put the hierarchy in place and have people working around him that know those inner workings, whilst it's a mid to long term project that a DOF tak
I don't think this is actually what he does FYI, he's oversees and builds the departments - I don't know how hands on he is with identifying players. At Brighton that was Paul Winstanely (now at Chelsea) and at Newcastle it's Nickson. It also depends how advanced our data project is given that is where Brighton's strength lay, in Star lizard. Basically, Ashworth isn't coming in and saying x, y and z are our targets for players, he is doing that for staff.
Plenty of Q&A's with him online where he describes all aspects of the role. He doesn't specifically go out and pick targets, however he has a veto alongside all those involved in the recruitment process and can suggest other targets or a need to see more of the suggested target. Same with the manager, CEO and head of recruitment.
 

Laurencio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2017
Messages
3,149
Can Newcastle even hire a new DOF as long as Ashworth is serving his notice period? If he has a new job and they have hired someone to do his old job, is the notice period reasonable? Would they really just not hire a DOF for a few years just out of spite?
 

ShinjiNinja26

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
11,177
Location
Location, Location
Starting petition like that is truely pathetic, I always though Newcastle had a good loyal fanbase but some of the stuff theyve done in recent times like punching Police Horses and filming themselves chanting about the Munich Air Disaster outside St James Park has put them in a whole new light and show just how horrible a lot of them are.
They’ve always been a bunch of knuckle dragging morons. I don’t know where this narrative came from that they’re a big club with a “great” fan base but it’s utter bollocks.
 

Gabriel Djemba-Bebe

Full Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
2,389
They’ve always been a bunch of knuckle dragging morons. I don’t know where this narrative came from that they’re a big club with a “great” fan base but it’s utter bollocks.
It's the narrative that comes with being a one club city. You hear the same shit with Leeds.
 

RedRocket9908

Full Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
2,364
Location
Manchester
They’ve always been a bunch of knuckle dragging morons. I don’t know where this narrative came from that they’re a big club with a “great” fan base but it’s utter bollocks.
You never used to hear or see very much from them though other than the odd moan about Mike Ashley but over the last year or so they all seem to have popped up all over social media constantly wittering on arrogantly about being the richest club in the world and posting complete and utter nonsence about Man Utd in a vain attempt to create a rivalry between us and them.
 

Crimson King

Full Member
Joined
May 11, 2013
Messages
3,085
Because sports journalists have to eat and they apparently have nothing better to sensationalise.
I mean this is the crux of it. The media have massively inflated the story, like they do with most things Man Utd, especially in the media age.

The Samuel article about Ashworth, and the Burt article about the morality of selling Greenwood, are the kind of things you'd find in a satirical comic trying to spoof football journalism.
 

mu4c_20le

Full Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2013
Messages
43,849
Starting petition like that is truely pathetic, I always though Newcastle had a good loyal fanbase but some of the stuff theyve done in recent times like punching Police Horses and filming themselves chanting about the Munich Air Disaster outside St James Park has put them in a whole new light and show just how horrible a lot of them are.
Yeah they are an odd bunch that lot.

Blue moon did it better
 

UTAretro

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
436
Supports
Brighton
I love how everyone is now an expert on contract law there now. Going off a hunch, it's only a hunch mind you, I reckon Ineos' legal team will know more on that than a random geordie.
As someone who is personally knowledgeable about such matters, most of my posts on this matter went ignored on here because they aren’t in line with your fan’s expectations of what you want. They may be factually correct and based on law and precedent, but they don’t match the decided narrative.

Obviously football is tribal; no amount of reasoned debate or explanation of the most basic principles of contract law are of interest to dedicated supporters posting their views - however absurd - to an internet forum.
 

Sniper007

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 6, 2022
Messages
24
Im surprised Newcastle fans are even upset about this. Unless they genuinely believe they are going to miraculously become a big team again.

I would have thought they’d just be delighted every day with any position above 18th in the league.
 

galwayfa

Full Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
751
Im sure this has been said, if on gardening leave, he will be still advising a friend of his who he thinks Utd should buy who will tell some-one at club. He also could set up an account here, tell club his username and post on here, in public, the sheer cheek of it but could be done.
 

Berbaclass

Fallen Muppet. Lest we never forget
Joined
Jan 23, 2010
Messages
39,058
Location
Cooper Station
Im sure this has been said, if on gardening leave, he will be still advising a friend of his who he thinks Utd should buy who will tell some-one at club. He also could set up an account here, tell club his username and post on here, in public, the sheer cheek of it but could be done.
They don't have internet in the midlands yet do they?
 

SalfordRed18

Netflix and avocado, no chill
Joined
Sep 24, 2012
Messages
14,057
Location
Salford
Supports
Ashwood City FC
Im sure this has been said, if on gardening leave, he will be still advising a friend of his who he thinks Utd should buy who will tell some-one at club. He also could set up an account here, tell club his username and post on here, in public, the sheer cheek of it but could be done.
You know there's more to a DOF than just signing players right?


If the right systems not in place yet, and he doesn't a true grasp of the day to day, he'll be recommending no one.
 

Laurencio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2017
Messages
3,149
As someone who is personally knowledgeable about such matters, most of my posts on this matter went ignored on here because they aren’t in line with your fan’s expectations of what you want. They may be factually correct and based on law and precedent, but they don’t match the decided narrative.

Obviously football is tribal; no amount of reasoned debate or explanation of the most basic principles of contract law are of interest to dedicated supporters posting their views - however absurd - to an internet forum.
I have a question. Can Newcastle hire a new DOF while they keep Ashworth on garden leave?
 

DavelinaJolie

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2013
Messages
3,492
I have a question. Can Newcastle hire a new DOF while they keep Ashworth on garden leave?
I should imagine so. I would have thought though, that unless they appoint internally, or hire someone currently out of work, they'll have a club demanding money from them in lieu of their chosen one going on gardening leave...

Given how dismissive Howe was of Ashworth I can't imagine he'll be that thrilled about any replacement either.
 

Lemoor

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
849
Location
Warsaw
I mean this is the crux of it. The media have massively inflated the story, like they do with most things Man Utd, especially in the media age.

The Samuel article about Ashworth, and the Burt article about the morality of selling Greenwood, are the kind of things you'd find in a satirical comic trying to spoof football journalism.
I was only barely exaggerating. This is a situation that happens dozens of times each year among football clubs, these journos have nothing specific to point to that would suggest that United did anything out of line. Yet they are clutching their pearls and playing pretend like they're part of negotiations and their clickbaity headlines actually influence anything.
 

Gandalf

Full Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2018
Messages
4,796
Location
Alabama but always Wales in my heart
I have a question. Can Newcastle hire a new DOF while they keep Ashworth on garden leave?
Yes. Legally once gardening leave commences it triggers a notice period and so the position is deemed vacant and the role can be filled without impacting the notice period. If Newcastle want to replace him with an external candidate they will probably be faced with paying some sort of compensation, significant wages and also potentially have to wait for their target to complete a period of gardening leave. Digging their heels in on their demands would be incredibly self destructive in this scenario.

It has also been mentioned a couple of times that Ashworth taking them to court could impact how other employers view him but it is equally fair to say that if Newcastle don't back down here they run the risk of damaging their reputation with the kind of employees they will want to target. If you want to be a big club then the people you will target will naturally be of the caliber where they will have a lot of options. If they see you being petty and punitive towards an employee because he dares to leave they probably won't even pick up the phone to discuss your vacancy. The NUFC fans here seem to think reputation is a one way street in these scenarios and it most definitely is not.

I do think their owners will be more rational though. There is a deal to be done and so both sides will posture for the media and in private they will reach a compromise that probably sees him here in time for the start of next season with a fee well below the asking price paid.
 

UTAretro

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
436
Supports
Brighton
Yes. Legally once gardening leave commences it triggers a notice period and so the position is deemed vacant and the role can be filled without impacting the notice period. If Newcastle want to replace him with an external candidate they will probably be faced with paying some sort of compensation, significant wages and also potentially have to wait for their target to complete a period of gardening leave. Digging their heels in on their demands would be incredibly self destructive in this scenario.

It has also been mentioned a couple of times that Ashworth taking them to court could impact how other employers view him but it is equally fair to say that if Newcastle don't back down here they run the risk of damaging their reputation with the kind of employees they will want to target. If you want to be a big club then the people you will target will naturally be of the caliber where they will have a lot of options. If they see you being petty and punitive towards an employee because he dares to leave they probably won't even pick up the phone to discuss your vacancy. The NUFC fans here seem to think reputation is a one way street in these scenarios and it most definitely is not.

I do think their owners will be more rational though. There is a deal to be done and so both sides will posture for the media and in private they will reach a compromise that probably sees him here in time for the start of next season with a fee well below the asking price paid.
Pretty much spot on. They absolutely can do this for the reasons given by Gandalf. The role - in UK employment law - is indeed deemed vacant.
 

UTAretro

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
436
Supports
Brighton
One other thing to add about the hypothetical (but extremely unlikely) scenario in which Ashworth sought legal remedy it would be on one of two grounds.

1. Breach of contract - argument would be made that the terms of contract relating to length of notice period were unreasonable on repudiatory grounds.

2. Restraint of trade - possibly the stronger case, but closely entangled with the first. The terms of contract restrict the worker’s freedom of employment unfairly, due to the contract of employment not being of industry norm. Even if it was of industry norm, there is plenty of supportive case law arguing that a contract is unreasonable based on specific circumstances of the special relationship between employer and worker.

Very unlikely though, and 99.9% of these cases are solved behind closed doors through intermediaries (lawyers) and compensation agreed privately. It will simply take a long time so don’t expect to hear anything unless Manchester United want to settle quickly.
 

Laurencio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2017
Messages
3,149
Yes. Legally once gardening leave commences it triggers a notice period and so the position is deemed vacant and the role can be filled without impacting the notice period. If Newcastle want to replace him with an external candidate they will probably be faced with paying some sort of compensation, significant wages and also potentially have to wait for their target to complete a period of gardening leave. Digging their heels in on their demands would be incredibly self destructive in this scenario.

It has also been mentioned a couple of times that Ashworth taking them to court could impact how other employers view him but it is equally fair to say that if Newcastle don't back down here they run the risk of damaging their reputation with the kind of employees they will want to target. If you want to be a big club then the people you will target will naturally be of the caliber where they will have a lot of options. If they see you being petty and punitive towards an employee because he dares to leave they probably won't even pick up the phone to discuss your vacancy. The NUFC fans here seem to think reputation is a one way street in these scenarios and it most definitely is not.

I do think their owners will be more rational though. There is a deal to be done and so both sides will posture for the media and in private they will reach a compromise that probably sees him here in time for the start of next season with a fee well below the asking price paid.
So basically, they can but it would be detrimental for their finances to do so without agreeing compensation with us?
 

UTAretro

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
436
Supports
Brighton
And it would be very long (massive court backlogs, huge amounts of discovery), hugely expensive and with no guarantee of success. And the additional risk of further costs in legal fees.

A court case like this would likely take as long to be heard as the gardening leave would last anyway, with no guarantee of success.
 

UTAretro

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
436
Supports
Brighton
So basically, they can but it would be detrimental for their finances to do so without agreeing compensation with us?
If Newcastle appointed a replacement, while continuing to pay Ashworth’s (media reported) salary of £2.5m p.a, Newcastle could also make a legal case under the “principals of fairness” to a court that Manchester United would have to pay some or all of the salary of a replacement employee. Newcastle would have to demonstrate to the court that the new employer (Manchester United) has given them a significant financial burden by having to pay two salaries for the same position.

Again, this is rare and won’t happen. But the legal recourse is there if it all got very messy. Which it won’t.
 

bringbackbebe

Full Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2021
Messages
1,694
Roy Keane made a good point. He isn’t very loyal is he. Leaves clubs within a couple of years. Who’s to say he won’t join Madrid or something in a year or 2.
It mainly comes down to two things:
1. Role within the club
2. Pay

Ashworth is able to command a pretty power role at United & what I'm assuming will be a hefty pay because we're desperate and because of his relationship with the new owners & directors.

Doubt Madrid would entertain this.
 

Mr Pigeon

Illiterate Flying Rat
Scout
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
26,338
Location
bin
Some more completely rational and normal takes:

"Mind the feckers on that red cafe are as thick as shit."
They probably meant that as an insult but I see it as more of a compliment. On any given day I'd say we're as thick as pig shit, which is much worse.
 

Mr Pigeon

Illiterate Flying Rat
Scout
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
26,338
Location
bin
Starting petition like that is truely pathetic, I always though Newcastle had a good loyal fanbase but some of the stuff theyve done in recent times like punching Police Horses and filming themselves chanting about the Munich Air Disaster outside St James Park has put them in a whole new light and show just how horrible a lot of them are.
I love Geordies, most I've met have been pretty decent folk. Granted, they're family so I'll be a bit biased.

But Newcastle United fans? fecking hell. They've turned into that Waynetta Slob character after she wins the lottery, sitting on a golden toilet in the living room telling the butler to wipe her arse.
 

Newstyle

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 24, 2016
Messages
113
It’s a bit rich in the Newcastle forums they actually giving Ratcliffe stick for avoiding taxes. They should they a looong look in the mirror before criticizing any other owner.
 

Grylte

"nothing wrong with some friendly incest, bro"
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
14,012
Any pictures of his garden yet?