lex talionis
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2017
- Messages
- 14,018
Debut performance with questions still to be answered, but I like the cut of his jib. Criminal if ETH shuns him for Onana.
He went very close twice to losing the ball. Martinez was screaming at him for one of them. It’s great to have a keeper who is confident at playing the ball out, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you have to cut it that fine against a league two press.Feck I thought he was very good with his feet. A few passes looked a bit risky but if it was Ederson or Allison doing it we'd trust they knew what they were doing. It's how I want us to play trusting players technical ability to get out of tight spots. If it was McTominay or Maguire rather than Martinez or Shaw I wouldn't be encouraging playing out to
It was a bit unnerving given it was the first time most of us had ever seen him and so he hasn't had any time to build up any trust. However I didn't think it was really any different to how most of the top keepers play outHe went very close twice to losing the ball. Martinez was screaming at him for one of them. It’s great to have a keeper who is confident at playing the ball out, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you have to cut it that fine against a league two press.
Onana is a top keeper at playing out and he’s rarely under that much pressure against much better presses. It’s too small of a sample size to make any judgements regardless.It was a bit unnerving given it was the first time most of us had ever seen him and so he hasn't had any time to build up any trust. However I didn't think it was really any different to how most of the top keepers play out
It would be great if he was a top keeper at being a keeperOnana is a top keeper at playing out and he’s rarely under that much pressure against much better presses. It’s too small of a sample size to make any judgements regardless.
Yes agreed, he’s been really bad. Doesn’t really impact on me assessing Bayindir last night though.It would be great if he was a top keeper at being a keeper
No I agree it's too small of a sample size and I need to see more. But I was quite impressed with his coolness on the ball and would give him the benefit of the doubt that he knew what he was doing on the occasions it looked a tad risky/close to losing itOnana is a top keeper at playing out and he’s rarely under that much pressure against much better presses. It’s too small of a sample size to make any judgements regardless.
Agreed. I like to see my goalie actually catch the ball and look like he knows what he's doing in goal.You wonder how many of those routine catches Onana would have needlessly punched....
But yeah, fine enough debut - couldn't do anything about either goals and made a pretty good save right at the end.
So what?I mean we were playing against League Two opposition...
Yeah, he played well. Would have been nice to see him come out and catch a few corners or high balls into the box. If he’d done that it would have made a fairly strong case for him to take Onana’s place in the team.Decent showing. I like the quick release throws, although he did give a few of them away.
Shag all he could have done for either goal, not a game where you can read too much into his performance, did what he had to do competently and that's what should be expected.
This is never going to happen during our remaining existance of watching United. We should just embrace it now.Yeah, he played well. Would have been nice to see him come out and catch a few corners or high balls into the box. If he’d done that it would have made a fairly strong case for him to take Onana’s place in the team.
This is never going to happen during our remaining existance of watching United. We should just embrace it now.
You ask too much.Yeah, he played well. Would have been nice to see him come out and catch a few corners or high balls into the box. If he’d done that it would have made a fairly strong case for him to take Onana’s place in the team.
Yeah he should of been starting in the Carabao Cup games as well, smacks of short-sightedness to play Onana constantly.I would like to see him being our Cup keeper this season but don't rate his chances.
We've already been using 2 goalies based on the competition - Europe-Onana and Domestic-Onana. One's been terrible and the other's been just about acceptable.As usual, the Caf wanting him to start until he makes his first error and deciding we should bin our two goalkeepers
I agree, I think he'd have saved it but for the deflection - even then he was very close to keeping it out.Fine debut, nothing special. Given our current bar with Onana it probably looked better than it was.
Think he would have saved the first one had it not been for the deflection too. He did well to get across that quickly.
Certainly wouldn't have been any expectation on him saving it, I was still impressed with how quickly he got over/reacted. Think there was a chance he'd have got there.I don't think he would've saved the shot even without the deflection, I don't think many Goalkeepers would tbf.
The effort came completely out of the blue and there was a ridiculous amount of venom on the shot.
Fairly sure that's what psxg / xgot is used for.There are a lot of debates on if DDG or Onana would or should have saved this or that shot. With technology why isn't there a program that says, the shot came in from x yards away, clear sight for the goalkeeper, it travelled at x miles per hour and was x distance from the keeper and x height; goalkeepers in the Premier League save this shot x % of time?
I think if you look at it from the best angle the shot is actually going just wide of the post before the deflection.I don't think he would've saved the shot even without the deflection, I don't think many Goalkeepers would tbf.
The effort came completely out of the blue and there was a ridiculous amount of venom on the shot.
Cameroon are outOnana isn't playing much in Africa, so he will probably fly back in for that Wolves game, and fly back in for that game.
I guess ETH will just have to rush him backCameroon are out
Cant. Two weird and probably unstoppable goals. Other than that, quiet.Can’t really tell much from that match.