He was fine. Hard to judge his ability based on a match against Newport, but can't complain about the performance.
Altay Bayındır | 2023/24 Performances
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
Thanks for the memories king
Give the guy a run of games, for gods sake. Looks already more composed that Onana. No soap on his glows.
Don’t think he did much wrong
He was decent. Nice to see a keeper catch the ball in a United shirt. Nothing he could do with both goals from deflections.
Thought he did okay in his first and potentially last game for the club.
He didn’t need to.
Cant make a judgement on the performance and normal position will be resumed at the next match...
Onana gets crucified every time we concede a goal whether it’s preventable or not is what he’s saying and it’s true.
It's not true at all.
Onana gets blamed for every goal he conceeds whether its his fault or not.
Ah, don't spend much time in the Onana thread do you?
Decent performance, some good claims and saves. Looks a bit dodgy with the ball at his feet though.
When did he look dodgy with his feet? Dealt with everything very well.
It’s very true even the media does it.
Happy that he finally got to debut. Looked comfortable and relaxed. Hope he gets another chance soon.
Did his job well, didn't look shakey but also wasn't really tested.
Why?
The first goal was a humdinger that took a deflection off Martinez and the second was Varane's to stop.
Passing choices and execution didn't look good, came close to giving the ball away a couple of times with it and looked rushed at other times under a bit of pressure.
Because Onana always gets the blame for the goals we conceed even though the reason we conceed so many is because of our woeful defence as the 2nd goal proved today.
Nothing he could have done with the first. Almost nothing he could have done with second.
Other than that he had very little to do.
Other than that he had very little to do.
Did fine.
Probably his only appearance for us
Probably his only appearance for us
Feck I thought he was very good with his feet. A few passes looked a bit risky but if it was Ederson or Allison doing it we'd trust they knew what they were doing. It's how I want us to play trusting players technical ability to get out of tight spots. If it was McTominay or Maguire rather than Martinez or Shaw I wouldn't be encouraging playing out to
He should be given a chance to start against Forest/Bristol. At least show Onana he isn't irreplaceable
Be he won't be...
Be he won't be...
Absolutely. We do this constantly in here with our players. Decisions, passes, finishes, tackles that would be absolutely fine from an opposition player are seized on as evidence of incompetence. He was good with the ball at his feet.
Not sure, I thought they were great passes and well weighted but those types are always going to be risky, it's the nature of them.
Agree, but at least he doesn't instil a sense of 'omg what's gonna happen next' as Onana does.
I mean we were playing against League Two opposition...
His passing under no pressure was fine, but his touch and passing under pressure was ropey.
He seemed alright, i'd probably keep picking him until he gives us a reason not to.
Absurd that it took this long for him to get his first start. Not bad at all. I'd like to see him given a few chances.
Great short passes that Onana is scared to make.
He looked good. No chance with either goal, but his full length dive for the first one demonstrated his athleticism - Onana would’ve just fallen to his right.
Distribution was generally decent and looked composed.
Right now I’d much rather have him between the sticks.
Distribution was generally decent and looked composed.
Right now I’d much rather have him between the sticks.
Agreed. Don't think we can learn too much from this tbh, beyond the fact that we probably need a new keeper in the summer.
He’s miles better than Onana - he moves like an actual goalkeeper for starters.
Great effort for a goal that we conceded. This is where we are at.
He looks like and plays like a Goalkeeper, which Onana doesn't unfortunately.
Did quite alright. Looks a bit nervous on the ball when under pressure, but I like that he looks like a goalkeeper: lean, very tall and moves and jumps like goalkeeper.
It's only fair and well deserved he gets to play in the next game vs Wolves.
It's only fair and well deserved he gets to play in the next game vs Wolves.
Onana isn't playing much in Africa, so he will probably fly back in for that Wolves game, and fly back in for that game.
Give him a run of games.
Looked quicker moving the ball outfield than Onana.
Looked quicker moving the ball outfield than Onana.