I like Herrera a lot and I hope things work out and he stays.
But, if he does leave it's not going to leave me broken hearted.
But, if he does leave it's not going to leave me broken hearted.
Ander Herrera to PSG? | Gone.
- Thread starter roonster09
- Start date
- Status
We've got a little terrier sat around doing nothing, he must feel like a caged animal. Time to drop Ander and let him off the leash.
How did we get here with a player like him?
He is on of those players you think we should have renewed and with ease 2 years ago.
He is on of those players you think we should have renewed and with ease 2 years ago.
We could always switch to 4-2-3-1 or 4-2-2-2 if we picked up a quality creative player like Sancho rather than go hunting a replacement for Herrera.
We need a Tanguy Ndombele in our midfield to compliment Pogba and Garner who will divide time with Matic next season.
Herrera is a brilliant squad player but we need a bona-fide first teamer in there.
Herrera is a brilliant squad player but we need a bona-fide first teamer in there.
Feel like this is the aftermath of Sanchez’s signing. Those wages made everyone’s eye’s open up. Think this departure signals De Geas inevitably departure too. No doubt people will be on here saying his limited, can be replaced etc. This deal should have been wrapped up months ago. Could of got a fee if we deemed him surplus.We’re a mess. That’s another 50m we need to spend on a replacement while Matic gets another season “running” out for us next season. No way we can afford to replace all the positions we need to this summer. Also a Pogba transfer episode is 100% going to happen this summer. Fun.
It’s leviosa not leviosaaaaaaaar!
Great, so that would be about another 100 million we'll have to spend on 2 CMs this summer. Plus we'll have to buy a RW, a CB and RB. Perfect. Imagine if we don't get top 4. We'll have to pay our new signings even more than we would pay Herrera.
I really hope Castles is just full of shit. Or the April fools thing.
I really hope Castles is just full of shit. Or the April fools thing.
I share your concerns. It's not that he isn't replaceable it's just that I worry we'll replace him with someone of similar/higher quality. Despite his recent form I don't think he's justified the wage he's requesting, regardless of whether or not previous managers have misused him, he's only really become a starter since Solskjaer came in.
HoneslHo me too, I love his passion and commmitmco but hesh 30 soon and signing a player who's reliant on ohysucsl attributes to a 3 year £180k-£200k P/w(!!!) contract would be crazy imo, hope ole wants to build from a younger base with lots of energy (though Herrera admittedly offers that at the moment).
Entering the season with 11 players that gonna be out of contract by the end of it was bound to lead to some of them leaving. Letting an important player's contract running out for as long as this season went is just another proof Ed knows feck all about managing a football club.
You ok mate.
If it forces the club to seriously invest and revamp the midfield then good.
Yeah I dont really believe him either. Although apparently hes saying he has an inside source to do with Ander's deal, its pretty much you either believe all of what Castles is saying or none of it.
I'm sorry but this made me laugh.
I'm starting to notice that really good defensive players are underrated on redcafe. Multiple people saying how easy it would be to replace Herrera when in recent windows United have spent £40m on Matic and £50m on Fred, neither of whom are as good as Herrera. It's the same with Smalling, every summer people think he will be replaced by a Bailly or a Lindelof (£30m each) and then he ends up being an important first team player.
I blame Jose for his treatment of Herrera last season. You bench your player of the year for Matic who, despite a good opening few months to his career, has not been a great success overall. He should have had an improved contract offer after 16-17 when he deserved it.
Yep. Not just good defensive players, but the harder working players too. Each year posters dream of replacing them with luxury players and it never seems to work out well for us in practice.
Its almost as if you need a balance of defensive and hardworking players as well as classy and skillful players
Probably just forces Matic to stay around much longer than he should
I'm almost certain we've signed someone which is why we're letting Ander go. I reckon Rabiot on a Free.
Well, this makes me angry. I can't blame Herrera for taking what PSG are offering... great team, playing with superstars, winning titles every season. People will complain about him choosing a long contract (for his age) on big money after the way he's spoken about the club, but we let his contract situation get to where it is. Many of us would make the same choice in our own areas of expertise. Then there's our political situation with Europe (I'm acknowledging it, without wanting to discuss it).
I'm angry though, because whenever I think of who I want playing for us against Liverpool next season, he's one of the first people that comes to mind.
I'm angry though, because whenever I think of who I want playing for us against Liverpool next season, he's one of the first people that comes to mind.
How we let this happen is absolutely comical. He should have been signed up over a year ago
Even if thats the case and thats best case scenario, they are different kinds of players.
Do we necessarily need to replace Herrera with a like-for-like player ?
Funny enough as he isn't a Spain regular it might actually have played small part. We don't know yet what will happen after 'that which shall not be named'. Maybe better being abroad, just in case. Cannot blame him, regular CL, nice pay packet, financial security for his family.
Has to be. Otherwise this can be disastrous. Don't trust in Eddie's ability to get deals through to address all our issues.
No, I think we should go for a more cultured passer. Then we need a strong & mobile defensive player to take over from Matic.
If we arent replacing Matic then yes
We have Fred for that
That's my worry, same old people dealing with transfers, even if we get a DOF, another same old face. Then a manager not used to dealing with the scale of transfers we need. I am worried about the impact that lot could have on Ole. They have to get it right. We cannot be going through another rebuild/bedding in period.
We are imbalanced though because we have too many hardworking but limited players, and we need to replace some of them with classier players. Everyone around Liverpool's hardworking midfield (bar Matip) is comfortable enough with the ball at their feet. Spurs lack class in midfield too but have more than we do in front and behind them to generally make up for it. City we won't discuss.
We're built more like a jammy team currently, and that has to change.
Yes, it's all speculation at the moment. We need two midfielders now IMO.
This summer window is vital, we can't feck it up especially if Liverpool win the league. The pressure on Ole and Woodward will be immense; i have a sneaky feeling that we're selling Pogba too.
15:31KEY EVENT
Update on Ander Herrera PSG speculation
Regarding the Herrera-to-PSG reports, one of Herrera’s confidants is unconvinced but hasn’t emphatically denied it, either, whereas two weeks ago they were adamant the initial PSG speculation was wide of the mark.
The source said: “We are entering into rumour wind tunnel and can’t get involved.”
Herrera has entered the last three months of his United contract.
Update on Ander Herrera PSG speculation
Regarding the Herrera-to-PSG reports, one of Herrera’s confidants is unconvinced but hasn’t emphatically denied it, either, whereas two weeks ago they were adamant the initial PSG speculation was wide of the mark.
The source said: “We are entering into rumour wind tunnel and can’t get involved.”
Herrera has entered the last three months of his United contract.
Fred is far from a cultured passer. Prone to over hit them or leave then short. In addition, so far the guy's general awareness in the league has been seriously found wanting. I am unsure about his long term future with us.
too many hardworking players? we only had Ander for midfield and now he might be gone
If we feck it up and Liverpool do win the league, maybe that will be the timescale for the next time we win the league.
Fred is a good passer he just hasnt completely settled yet. His passing is the last thing I would be worried about with him.
They'll be a riot if that happens, Liverpool will have 19 and look strong. I don't know but I have to say I'm not feeling optimistic. That Saudi takeover is looking more attractive by the dayIf we feck it up and Liverpool do win the league, maybe that will be the timescale for the next time we win the league.
They'll be a riot if that happens, Liverpool will have 19 and look strong. I don't know but I have to say I'm not feeling optimistic. That Saudi takeover is looking more attractive by the day
I'm thinking so too. Ole said some agents have already been in touch with the club to get their client moves here.
- Status