Anderlecht vs Genk to replayed after VAR error
- Thread starter JuriM
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Did it disallow a game?
Is this true? cant find the news in any reliable site only that reddit post.
The Reddit post cites the Genk website.
Feck me don’t set this precedent
Sounds like a bad idea to me
What was the error?
Liverpool straight on the blower to the PL.
That is just so minor, do they really want to do this?
Oh jesus, Klopp to stay then
If that's the bar you'd be replaying a match every gameweek.
They're nutters for even considering it.
They're nutters for even considering it.
That's an incredibly low bar.
Bad move, sets a ridiculous low bar for further replays to be considered. Every poor decision could then be appealed for a replay.
It's a logical consequence of VAR. Either you want the 'correct' result or you don't.
These days i dont celebrate a goal until VAR check is complete. Now i wont celebrate wins until season is over.
Interesting. It's obviously a direct goal-scoring opportunity that was messed up, but then lots of situations get judged wrongly and could have been a goal otherwise; think of an offside call that was about to result in a good one-on-one (xG can help quantify which ones would have let to truly great opportunities), but is cancelled because the assistant ref erroneously put up the flag.
Also, shouldn't the match rather be replayed from that moment? I know it's fairly early (23rd minute), but still. I'd say it should restart in the 23rd minute with the Genk penalty kick.
Also, shouldn't the match rather be replayed from that moment? I know it's fairly early (23rd minute), but still. I'd say it should restart in the 23rd minute with the Genk penalty kick.
Why not celebrate twice per goal?
Then some tosser will come on and say 'oh no, I celebrate each goal twice'. Leaves me speechless.
edit: feck me duffer, you didn't even wait for me to finish typing. And I know you're joking, but there were people saying it that were serious.
The entire arena did this at the Sens-Sharks game (NHL) I was at a few weeks ago. Was fun actually - but it helped that the goal was ruled in.
This sets an awful precedent. For me, nothing but a proven case of corruption should result in a match being replayed. Mistakes happen, deal with it.
The entire arena did this at the Sens-Sharks game (NHL) I was at a few weeks ago. Was fun actually - but it helped that the goal was ruled in.
On the contrary, this means he's headed to the Belgian Pro League, if true (which it does not seem to be).
Duffer the type to raise his hand to answer the teacher's question when he doesn't have a clue.
If this is true and can be applied here we are in a title race
Makes it one small step to a club saying “it was a clear ref error… you replayed the one with the VAR error.”
Mistakes happen. Far too many mind, but they happen.
We’d be replaying a quarter of our season!
Mental decision and I hope to feck we don't see this happen ever again, especially over something totally minor.
Not really. We wanted the correct result before VAR too. And the same logic (retrospectively looking at a decision and saying the ref made the wrong one so let's replay the match) could have applied then.
It would be great. Pretty much every game being replayed and people will be bored of it. The quicker we get rid of VAR the better.
That isn't enough the season was over wasn't it? This was a game from last season right?
Edit Sorry last year...
Actually, it might force football to figure things out properly re. VAR - or otherwise something would go into the rules around the ability to challenge referee decisions. No way they'd just let a situation be where every goal-involving decision can be challenged and lead to a rematch.
This is an incredibly stupid idea. Why are they doing this?