If Ronaldo was the 4th best striker in the world, don't you think someone would want to sign him? 
Best Striker in the World
- Thread starter Idxomer
- Start date
Do you think if you put Haaland in that Madrid team last season, they are winning the CL? Was Haaland better than him last season? Or anybody else? The stats tell only one part of the story. There's a reason the Ballon d'Or is a foregone conclusion at this point, Benzema was head and shoulders above everybody else.
Pretty much this.
Ranking halland ahead of Benzema on the merits of their last season exploits is frankly ridiculous.
Lukaku in the initial list. Deary me.
Aleksandar Mitrović.
Best all round has to be Benzema. He's simply amazing! So elegant, too. It's what I was hoping (still hope) Martial can be but yeah.....
I think it's sad there's very few top strikers who are proper 9s - most of the best are the older ones (Benzema, Lewandowski). Even Kane and Lukaku nearly 30. Haaland is so far ahead of any remotely similiar player under 29. Not that long ago there would dozens of quality strikers around at any one time.
Football always goes in cycles though, expect we'll see more again before long.
Football always goes in cycles though, expect we'll see more again before long.
So is @NewGlory
Are numbers everything though? Halaand does barely anything outside of goals. Someone like Benzema is a completely footballer and for me I'd have him anyday over the Norwegian.
You have to admit, "does barely anything outside of goals" is an odd criticism of a striker. His scrambled egg not as good as it could be?
I would take Benzema over any of them
That doesn't make any sense.
Benzema scores tons of goals and has done so in vital games leading to major trophies. Over and above that he also contributes to the buildup, chance creation, quality of passing, pressing and so on. Why would Halaand be better than him when he contributes less on a football pitch? It's a pointless comparison unless Halaand greatly improves his all round play.
Benzema is the top striker
Followed by Haaland, Mbappe, Lewandowski and Kane
Followed by Haaland, Mbappe, Lewandowski and Kane
Currently Benzema, he doesn’t only score but his link up play is genious. I remember a long time ago when he was rubbish, gives hope for some people like Martial to become very good.
Second place is Lewandowski. Third Kane. Fourth Ronaldo. Fifth M’Bappe closely followed by Halaand (the French got more than goals in his game ala Henry, Halaand is just a goal machine ala RVN)
According to Liverpool fans, Nuñez is number one.
Second place is Lewandowski. Third Kane. Fourth Ronaldo. Fifth M’Bappe closely followed by Halaand (the French got more than goals in his game ala Henry, Halaand is just a goal machine ala RVN)
According to Liverpool fans, Nuñez is number one.
For striker I think goals is the utmost important. I’d rather to have striker to hunt goals/always dangerous inside the box rather than drop deep to involve in build up play, but I guess it depends on system.
In the modern game you expect to see your striker involved in build up play and possibly dropping deeper at times. It's quite rare to see an out and out striker now that is purely all about goals. Personally if a player isn't great at the other stuff but amazing at putting the ball in the back of the net I would think they are missing something even though I'd think they were a great goal scorer.
Haaland, Lewandowski and Benzema are on a different level to everyone else now.
Kane could be, but putting a player along those who has never touched a trophy in his career seems odd.
Kane could be, but putting a player along those who has never touched a trophy in his career seems odd.
At this moment, Ronaldo is not the 4th best striker in the world!Currently Benzema, he doesn’t only score but his link up play is genious. I remember a long time ago when he was rubbish, gives hope for some people like Martial to become very good.
Second place is Lewandowski. Third Kane. Fourth Ronaldo. Fifth M’Bappe closely followed by Halaand (the French got more than goals in his game ala Henry, Halaand is just a goal machine ala RVN)
According to Liverpool fans, Nuñez is number one.
Do you rate the player or the success of the team they happened to play for? Seems an odd reason to discount Kane as an individual player.
Kane in my opinion is getting better and better.
Agreed, Imagine if Benzema played for this City team. Pep would love him as well, he's the prototype Pep number 9.
The other three decided games and scored crucial goals to win finals. Kane came close but wasn't successful at this final step. It's debatable if this counts as individual performance and should be included I guess.
In what final did Haaland decide the game and score goals? Kane won the world cup golden boot remember among many other big games he has scored and won the game for his team in.
People are looking down upon Kane tbh, In my eyes he's third after Benzema and Lewa. Haaland has some insane numbers but it's still too early to put him over Kane at the end of the season that could change though.
There's a reason Kane was Peps first choice and only decided to go for Haaland because of Levy's valuation.
He has been looked down upon for his entire career despite being almost certainly the best striker in the history of the Premiership and one of the best English players of all time. It's because the rivalry between fans is so strong here nobody outside of Spurs wants to admit it. As I said he is still improving and is likely going to continue scoring and impacting games well into his 30's hopefully breaking records and (hopefully) winning medals as he goes.
I disagree with that one, the problem though for Kane is if he goes through his career without winning a meaningful trophy it will be hard for him to get the ratings he deserves.
Yeah he's the heir to Alan Shearer if there ever was one even though their styles are slighty different as Kane gets older.
Shearer just won 1 PL title with Blackburn, but he's still considered by many to be the best british PL striker of all time. There is Rooney of course for competition, but Rooney didn't spend all that much time playing as a proper nr. 9
It's because he hasn't won anything. People factor that in.
Nobody would discount a spurs player from any list because of rivalry and that's not a snide comment.
Henry ?
I think if you ask the majority of prem fans they'd say Henry, only Spurs fans would say Kane.
That's a horrendous list. Ronald and nunez couldn't touch kane at the minute. Wind up?
For me currently it’s Benzema and Håland, then Lewandowski, then Kane. These are miles above everyone else.
Benzema has been insanely good for the last year, honestly he has surprised me. I think Håland is still underrated because of his rough playing style, he is an absolute monster and he’s the only player I could imagine hitting 40+ goals in PL.
Lewandowski and Kane are just very, very prolific strikers and finishers, get them the ball and they will deliver. Lewandowski is more technically silky, Kane is super smart and determined. I still don’t think they are individually quite capable of what Benzema produced in last season’s UCL, some of those goals were out of this world.
About Håland, I think movement is the key word. Even if his hold-up play is sometimes lacking, he is still making runs and posing a huge threat for the defence. With his combination of speed, power and finishing, he is one of the most lethal strikers I have ever seen.
Everyone else needs to do a lot before they can be in this discussion. Without significant injuries to Håland, I don’t think anyone from his generation will be able to compete with him in the future. Maybe Mbappe if he gets his mentality right (and if he’s being considered a striker at the some point).
Benzema has been insanely good for the last year, honestly he has surprised me. I think Håland is still underrated because of his rough playing style, he is an absolute monster and he’s the only player I could imagine hitting 40+ goals in PL.
Lewandowski and Kane are just very, very prolific strikers and finishers, get them the ball and they will deliver. Lewandowski is more technically silky, Kane is super smart and determined. I still don’t think they are individually quite capable of what Benzema produced in last season’s UCL, some of those goals were out of this world.
About Håland, I think movement is the key word. Even if his hold-up play is sometimes lacking, he is still making runs and posing a huge threat for the defence. With his combination of speed, power and finishing, he is one of the most lethal strikers I have ever seen.
Everyone else needs to do a lot before they can be in this discussion. Without significant injuries to Håland, I don’t think anyone from his generation will be able to compete with him in the future. Maybe Mbappe if he gets his mentality right (and if he’s being considered a striker at the some point).
I feel Kane is underrated on this forum. I don't know if it is because he hasn't had his best games against United.
Benzema, Lewandowski and Kane in that order for me but I do wonder what Kane would have done if he had been at Bayern the last few years, definitely has aspects of his game that are better than Lewandowski's.
Benzema, Lewandowski and Kane in that order for me but I do wonder what Kane would have done if he had been at Bayern the last few years, definitely has aspects of his game that are better than Lewandowski's.
Unfortunately that's the world we live in. Kane will never get the recognition and individual awards because hes not winning the biggest team prizes. I think that's the single biggest driving factor.
I said best british pl striker of all time.
Shearer was a beast before his first injury at Blackburn.
Lewandowski already at 4 goals and one assist in his first three league games for Barca - if he continues this stellar form, the argument of him only getting insane numbers because of Bayern's domination will be a little shaken off I guess. Miles better than Kane and in my eyes to even put Harry in the same discussion with Benzema and Lewandowski is ambitious - over the last 3/5 years I have little doubt Lewy was global striker number one, last season only matched by Benzema in incredible form.
I think you could have either one of Benzema, Lewandowski, Kane, Mbappe as the number 1. All slightly different players but there's not much between them IMO, splitting hairs.
Tier 1
Lewandowski
Haaland
Benzema
Mbappe
Tier 2
Kane
Felix
Tier 3
Lukaku
Ronaldo
Immobile
Jota
Aubameyang
Vlahovic
Moreno
Jesus
Osimhen
Martinez
etc.
Lewandowski
Haaland
Benzema
Mbappe
Tier 2
Kane
Felix
Tier 3
Lukaku
Ronaldo
Immobile
Jota
Aubameyang
Vlahovic
Moreno
Jesus
Osimhen
Martinez
etc.
How can people put anyone on Benzema level?
1. He is incredible goalscorer,
2. His all around game is easily best in the world when it comes to strikers,
3. and he's winning trophies, and recent CL trophy he's won basically single handedly for his team.
Hardly anyone besides Lewandowski ticks 2 out of these 3 boxes, so I have no idea how can people put anyone on his level, let alone as better than him.
1. He is incredible goalscorer,
2. His all around game is easily best in the world when it comes to strikers,
3. and he's winning trophies, and recent CL trophy he's won basically single handedly for his team.
Hardly anyone besides Lewandowski ticks 2 out of these 3 boxes, so I have no idea how can people put anyone on his level, let alone as better than him.