Neuer's performance reminded me of some of Phil Jones early games for United. The latter looked good marauding forward (and mostly did well) but he made silly mistakes while doing the actual job he was put on the pitch to do.
Neuer is getting forgiven despite not commanding his box at times today. Granted, he was terrific at commanding the defensive third of the pitch, but I want my goalies to do the basics right first. Neuer, for my money, is far too inconsistent at that whenever I've seen him.
None of this is to say he didn't do well overall today, but a more savvy striker could have pounced on his errors and probably forced him to make a couple more.