I'm not saying McTominay is better. Rice is better. He's more consistently good for a start.
But at their best there's not much between them.
Declan Rice
- Thread starter roonster09
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have two new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting for the new Premier League season.
A new Premier League Predictions competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
A new Last Man Standing competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
For Last Man Standing you have until the 16th August to submit your predictions. Submissions will be open for the next 20 days, 16 hours, 35 minutes, 55 seconds, and will close on Aug 16, 2024 at 20:00.
Bonus: for fans of Odds or Evens, the thread will be going up mid-August with a deadline for after the transfer window shuts.
- Status
But at their best there's not much between them.
Only reason he gets rated highly is he's a young English player who performs at a decent level consistently. We could do better for the prices quoted for him.
Let's be serious, I'd have Rice over McTominay every single day of the week. McTominay has had about 6 games of good form, Rice has a couple of seasons worth and the only reason the comparison is even there is on reactionary consideration of the last few weeks where their form has shifted.
But this ship has sailed anyway, Rice and Casimero is a completely wrong balance so there's just no way the manager pays what he'd see as an inflated English transfer fee for this type. I believe he'd want a good dribbler and technical player next.
But this ship has sailed anyway, Rice and Casimero is a completely wrong balance so there's just no way the manager pays what he'd see as an inflated English transfer fee for this type. I believe he'd want a good dribbler and technical player next.
We kind of did do better for half the price quoted.
No he hasn't. Best midfielders in the last couple of years have been Kevin De Bryune, N'golo Kante, Bruno Fernandes, Bernardo Silva, James Maddison, Gundogan, Fabinho, Rodri Jorginho et al
He's just an overrated English player - and thankfully he's not the type of player EtH likes/requires for his system.
Amen - and he doesn't fit the system our manager wants to play.
I really doubt how many West Ham games you watch. Moyes seldom plays 3-5-2 and if anything he tries this season, it is more defensive rather than open.
There is a reason you need to play with 3 centerbacks behind Rice and Bellingham. And it is not in positive way.
If he was avaiable for around £20m I would consider. Otherwise no.
If he was avaiable for around £20m I would consider. Otherwise no.
Or Southgate could have just dropped Rice if he's as mediocre as everyone suggests. He cuts out so many dangers in an outnumbered midfield and people still complain because "it is not in positive way".
Outnumbered? There are 5 defenders and 2 central midfielders. It is more people in those zones than what is in Tokyo. Just watch how many times one of the center backs help those two out. It is ok, it is team game. But as I said, there is reason why you need 3 defenders behind him and Bellingham. They are not good enough to play without help.
Last edited:
He's getting even cheaper. Gone from a £40m player tops, to a £30m player, now 20.
One more average game in an average England side and suddenly it'll be 'I wouldn't even take him on a free' on this forum.
Why would we take him on a free if we don’t think he’s suited to our style of play and is overrated on top of that?
Rice himself had 4 tackles and 6 duels won at halftime. He won so many 1v1 or even 1v2 in the midfield and I don't see how the 5 defenders are relevant. He had Musiala in his pocket until Flick moved him out wide. Needless to say he mostly plays in a back 4 at West Ham.
Because you still have utter dross like McTominay playing regularly?
Or he’s playing because he’s bang on form while keeping a player who is 10x the player Rice is in Casemiro on the bench?
Rice has been shit for a while now by the way. I wouldn’t be slagging McTominay in defence of “3rd CB in a 4-4-2” Declan fecking Rice
Most of this forum (rightly so) was on McTominay's back last season and suddenly a handful of decent games and he's a good player again. Meanwhile Rice 'has been shit for a while' after a handful of bad or average games.
More proof of how fickle most of you lot are.
If fans were rightfully on Scott’s back then why aren’t the fans rightfully on Rices back? Rice was shocking for 3/4 of last season. His drop in performers isn’t a drop in form, it’s been there for approaching 10/11 months now.
Feck knows what Scott has to do with this by the way.
My point is why would we bloat the squad by taking a player that doesn’t suit Ten Hag or be the type of player he wants his Utd midfield to play though?
For us to be fickle we would have all wanted Rice in good form but not in bad form. The same posters claiming he isn’t good enough now are the same posters who were claiming he wasn’t good enough when he was bluffing the likes of you.
How is that fickle?
Stats like tackles and duels won don't mean anything when you put them in context. Example, you can win every header if nothing happens with that. Or when someone says that someone have 89% passing rate when every pass is two meters and back to goalkeeper or defender.
That pocket seems to be full of holes because England have been open in the middle of the park.
The anti-Rice brigade here is unbelievable. I understand Rice is overpriced, I can see why fans don't want him, but the constant underestimation on his ability (especially defensive side) is clueless. I doubt how many know how to analyze a defensive player, and how many actually watch West Ham regularly.
So what's the context here? Your examples are irrelevant and I don't see one accounting for Rice's stats. Those stats are simple proof for his outstanding defending, which could easily be captured through an eye test.
Giving up the midfield to pack the defence.
Why is it irrelevant. I'm telling you that you can't judge by taking out some numbers. You got to look at the whole picture when you judge a midfielder. Let me give you a better example. WanBissaka, one of the best one on one defenders in country. Would you say that he is good defender and a player? Or is it more to his game when we need to judge?
And if you want to talk about stats in Premier League this year. Go and check out his stats and compare to players that people see as "average".
Im not sure why anyone serious thinks England plays 3 CBS because of the midfield. Infact England till Bellingham's emergence has been forced to play two defensive minded pivots infront of the defence because the cbs aren't that special.
How was he tonight against Germany?
I definitely dont. I dont feel like that needs explanation.
Did what he usually does gives up the midfield and becomes like another CB, made a lot of tackles and interceptions.
I thought he and Bellingham as a partnership were quite good. Complimented each other very well.
To be fair, how many of the people pushing for us to sign Rice watch West Ham regularly?
Of course you can't judge a player solely by numbers, because there are plenty of parameters to decide and sometimes you don't know which are important. But now we are talking about a certain department (defending) of Rice's game, which I think he's excellent (which is obvious through eye test) but you insist it's due to the 5 defenders. There is no way he's making those stats if he wasn't actively winning so many possessions in the outnumbered midfield.
Rice ranks 1st in terms of interceptions (20) and 11th in terms of tackles (18) as a midfielder this season. McTominay has 8 interceptions and 11 tackles. Again we need to consider the contexts when we compare stats of course, but average?
Anyone sensible human would know. Anti-Rice brigade has a different opinion though.
It's totally fine not to watch West Ham regularly, but don't pretend you do just by joining the dots. Moyes playing 3-5-2 in majority of the matches? Trying to play more open this season? These are obviously made up to suit the agenda that Rice can't attack.
60M would be way too much for him, nevermind 100M.
He's the AWB of midfielders.
He's the AWB of midfielders.
The only time i'd bother watching west ham was if they were playing someone good. In which case Moyes will park the bus as thats what hes been doing for the best part of 20 years. How good Rice is in that context just doesn't mean much to me.
Even if moyes opens up against fulham or something im not sure how useful it is to know he can keep a midfield of that level in check. He could do with a new manager, a different kind of manager at international level or a different club and i dont think he'll get any of them for a while yet.
Even if moyes opens up against fulham or something im not sure how useful it is to know he can keep a midfield of that level in check. He could do with a new manager, a different kind of manager at international level or a different club and i dont think he'll get any of them for a while yet.
If Rice ever came here for 120 million, he'd buckle under the scrutiny and pressure, and never live up to the price tag, then fans will start spewing abuse towards him and mocking him and the club for playing him when he starts making errors and found out to be not elite level just like what happened with maguire and awb who many fans lusted after before we signed them
He's not even the most likeable character on the field, evidenced by his unprofessional after west ham got kicked out of europa last season and he accused a ref of being corrupt, neither is he most more introspective as I'm sure I remember him doing an interview saying he's already world class and has nothing to prove.
He's not even the most likeable character on the field, evidenced by his unprofessional after west ham got kicked out of europa last season and he accused a ref of being corrupt, neither is he most more introspective as I'm sure I remember him doing an interview saying he's already world class and has nothing to prove.
Best thing he could do is run his contract down, if he goes for big money his massive limitations as a midfielder will turn him into the next Maguire-esque internet meme.
He is talented but no one will touch him unless he has a year left or he is a free agent.
Please discuss football performances in the football thread. This forum is for transfer news
- Status