Which of the regulars are left?
@Gio @Balu @Pat_Mustard
feck...was out today for far longer than I'd planned and missed the poll closing. I'm still no closer to deciding who would win for what its worth. When I first looked I thought Annah decisively for individual quality which is still my main criteria. Aldo was brilliant with his tactics and arguments though, and I felt Annah slipped up after nailing it perfectly in his last game. Both managers get bonus points for unearthing some awesome youtube footage that I'll have to get round to watching. All in all, if I'd been in front of the computer all day there's every chance I'd not have voted anyway!
Some random observations...
Is it just pride fecking with me when I reflexively disagree with Annah's argument that Conti would have skinned Irwin enough to give Annah's team a decisive advantage? Its strange, when Trippy fielded Bruce-Pallister my arse twitched at the mere thought of them up against a 'continental' strike pairing with good movement, yet I have a tough time viewing Irwin as unreliable at virtually any level.
This was a great thread to read, but someone should have posted Anto's great post about Platini vs Maradona in the all-time great standings from an old draft!
Slim Ronaldo is ridiculously hard to judge against all-time level company - there's plenty of valid arguments against him in terms of aesthetic playing style and skill-set omissions, yet his worth in these drafts does seem far too low versus his real-world accomplishments.