The whole team can't be this bad at the same time. This is why it's on manager and coaching.
17
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 36
- Goals
- 4
- Assists
- 5
- Yellow cards
- 8
- Status
When the biggest defense of Fred in this thread from even some of his biggest advocates is “Atleast he tries”, we know we’re in an utterly dire situation with our central midfield.
He’s absolutely rotten, and it’s hilarious to see people on here try to stat pad why he’s a good player.
Roy obviously hasn't seen how good his stats are.
Give over and talk about Fred, both of them are pathetic. At least he gets involved? In what actually? Cluster fecks?
Fred's soundtrack:
Fred's shit too, McTominay's just shitter.
Fred obviously isn’t world class but he’s far from our biggest problem either.
Keane is concentrating his frustration on the wrong man.
Keane is concentrating his frustration on the wrong man.
Saying Fred isn't World Class is a lot like saying a Nissan Micra isn't a supercar.
cool. teams have won trophies with a lot worse players in their teams/squad.
Basically this. Fred runs about and actually puts a shift in. McT is like Anderson at his worst, hiding behind opponents. I mean to watch and focus on his movement is like watching a meme come alive. The guy literally moves along with his marker to ensure he stays behind him. How are the coaches ever allowing that! Just goes to show how incompetent we are at all levels when this thing either hasn't been improved or the player been benched given his position.
Our best player today, not that it's saying much. He must have covered twice the ground of anybody else in our team and actually made City players think about their game a bit.
Maybe so, any come to mind?
The only reason he's picking out Fred is because McTominay is so anonymous you forget he's even playing. You can't make a mistake if you never get the ball.
drinkwater at leicester stands out. could probably go through half of fergies teams and pick out some dossers that never should have been PL winners but the manager makes it happen.
For some, Utd lose straight to the Fred thread and this happens even when he is not playing. For me, calling a player who isn't good enough isn't the issue, it's more about those who ceiling is higher that should be. Maybe if those so called better players so has much heart as Fred, then at least even if we lose, would be at least trying to win. Shite hits the fan on the pitch, Fred is always the first to turn up. Bigger waste is not trying irrespective of your ability.
Drinkwater maybe yeah, you wouldn't find any starters in Fergie's teams though. For squad players Gibson comes to mind.
I'd argue Fabio was of Fred's ability too. Anyway yes Fred probably shouldn't be the first name on the team sheet but he'd be a good squad player.
I just find everybody picking on him a bit crazy as he's not the guy that keeps losing us games.
Fred apologists always are sure to include the phrase “covers more ground” in their defense of him and his continued, unwarranted, selection in the team. Too bad the rules of the game require him to touch the ball from time to time.
Let's be honest if Fred went to City he'd be playing amazingly as their B2B and we'd be saying how we suck at recruitment.
The simple issue is we don't have a proper DM and playing Fred in a double pivot is a terrible idea because he doesn't have the defensive skills.
Fred is excellent at pressing, can run with the ball, decent at picking the right pass in counter attacks. All attributes that would shine at Liverpool, Chelsea or City. Just watch how well he does with the Brasil NT under a decent coach. (It's like getting mad at Ronaldo for not scoring if the coach decides to play him as a wide winger)
The simple issue is we don't have a proper DM and playing Fred in a double pivot is a terrible idea because he doesn't have the defensive skills.
Fred is excellent at pressing, can run with the ball, decent at picking the right pass in counter attacks. All attributes that would shine at Liverpool, Chelsea or City. Just watch how well he does with the Brasil NT under a decent coach. (It's like getting mad at Ronaldo for not scoring if the coach decides to play him as a wide winger)
Players don't buy or pick themselves. Don't think many come to be squad players either. It's all on the manager not the individual players. Squad players become that, cause there are better in their position and sorry, whilst on paper they might be, the games they have equally been bad.
Amazing for a player who can't pass seems to be able to do so in a Yellow shirt? Yes it's international football but anyone who knows football, there is no more forensic view and criticism on a player than Brazilian football.
Wow. Fred was among the shittest players in a shit bunch. His job is not running around covering ground, it's to link defense into attack, help in 2v1 overloads, slow down attacks, and to spring counters. He did feck all today. Fred is a fecking disgrace and should be given away if no one will buy him.
Yeah our main problem with Fred is how we us him and how often.
He's more suited to a 3 man midfield and yeah he'd be a good option to have but he's our best central midfielder probably.
No. Literally none of that is true. Fred is shit at pressing, can't control a ball, passes right to the opponents, and is light as a feather when trying to win the ball back. He would never go to City because they aren't fecking stupid when it comes to signing players. Is there any player in teh premiere league in Fred's position who is worse at his job than Fred is? I seriously doubt it.
Not sure who you are actually talking about here mate.
And there's your problem, half that stuff is not what he's actually good at. But our manager plays him there because he doesn't know what he's doing.
In a functioning team he would actually be a very good player.
He can't pass the ball. You can't be a midfielder and not be able to pass the ball no matter what else you're good at.
Fred isn't good at anything. He's a below average player who would probably get found out in the more physically robust Championship. The fact that Ole doesn't have a clue is not helping Fred or us, but Ole is also not the source of Fred sucking shit week in week out.
Well that's just nonsense.
To be honest I feel the same. He even had some nice moments of play. Even when Bruno and McT kept playing him in to trouble with hospital passes. He had quite a few situations where they put him in a position where he had no chance.
I just feel like people don’t watch Fred’s game, and only pay attention to the actions of when he is on the ball. Like take that dribbled pass stat for example. If anyone actually watched what was happening that’s completely understandable as he was moving from one player to try and get at another at impossible speeds and angles where he couldn’t adjust.
The whole team is an issue from workrate, positioning, structure, passing, movement. It’s an utter complete mess but in all honesty I feel like we need Fred because of his ability to put people under preasure and Harry them in to mistakes. For me it’s easy to see why he’s one of Oles go to guys.
Fred and McT should be squad players but sorry Pogs and Matic haven't been significantly better. You could argue Pogs has been worst when he's played centrally. You could argue Pogs is now a squad player.
I wouldn't be surprised if he's the new managers guy either.....
Right ok and what does any of that have to do with my post that you replied to?
I never mentioned McTominay, Matic or Pogba in that post and I've actually also said on this very page that Fred would be a good squad option but is probably our best central midfielder.
Is it though? It's well known Brazilian internationals routinely get found out in the brutal Championship. That league is so much more competitive than the Copa.
Didn't have the chance to read through all your previous post unsurprisingly and my point as you have just said, Fred would be a good squad option but is probably our best central midfielder. My point is as you also mentioned Gibson, there was a clear disparity between him and the starters in ability that's not here currently at Utd (only on paper). If Pogs and Matic played to their ability, we aren't having these discussions about Fred and McT...Right ok and what does any of that have to do with my post that you replied to?
I never mentioned McTominay, Matic or Pogba in that post and I've actually also said on this very page that Fred would be a good squad option but is probably our best central midfielder.
And the rest of the team.
It was a bit of an odd reply to that post even in isolation to be fair mate.
I was having a discussion where someone said there were worse players in some of fergies teams and I pointed out that in my opinion Gibson fits in that category but none of the starters in those teams do.
Wes Morgan was the shittest player to win the premier league. Fred isn’t far behind in that table.
If Fred is bad McTominay belongs on the U18 team. Fred is bad in this position, but at least he tries. McTominay has been the more useless of the 2. But yet I don't see people lining up to scapegoatting him.
- Status