Keane 3rd
Cantona 2nd
Djemba Djemba 1st
simples
Cantona 2nd
Djemba Djemba 1st
simples
Greatest ever player under Sir Alex - Results
- Thread starter The Law of Denis
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Cmon get it over with. Do the top three together.
it's possible that all my post ending with regardless of djemba djemba were counted as votes!
I suspect the Irish have voted in record numbers. 
I hereby declared this poll null and void, regardless of Djemba Djemba.
Since I can see no names in the last 3 spots, I'm assuming they are all occupied by Liam Miller.
we should do a poll of the top 11 and see how it comes out compared to this list...it'd be interesting
I think this is a good delve into the psyche of Caftards...i can't wait to see who the top 3 are
unless the reason there are 11 is cos 1 is someone like Eric Harisson or Fergie himself....though that would contradict the 'player' part
I think this is a good delve into the psyche of Caftards...i can't wait to see who the top 3 are
unless the reason there are 11 is cos 1 is someone like Eric Harisson or Fergie himself....though that would contradict the 'player' part
Close now!
I could see one or two posters voting like that, but the entire forum isn't that cheeky
Keano in at 3.
Giggs at #4!!!
Arguments could be made for 2nd or maybe even 3rd but 4th? Nah!
Arguments could be made for 2nd or maybe even 3rd but 4th? Nah!
madness?!?!?!?! THIS IS REDCAFE!!!!!!!!
Who the hell is at #2? then
I think it's safe to assume who number one is.
I think it's safe to assume who number one is.
Since the countdown started at #11 I suspect the top place isn't based on the votes at all, either Sir Alex or just a tribute to everyone to play under him.
it'll be a trick...there are 11 for a reason people...I've sussed it now
Benzema?
Rooney
Cantona
Jobs a good un
Cantona
Jobs a good un
its gotta be a WU from TLOD - well done mate - had us all going !
Cantona is 2.
Who the hell is number 1 ?
Gotta be a trick.
Who the hell is number 1 ?
Gotta be a trick.
This is a good composition so far...
Taibi? Djemba? Miller? Prunier? Goram?
I like the way he's keeping us in suspense here....proper
Shortlisted
Wow
We should have had odds running on this. The bookies would have made a killing with Cantona coming in second!
We should have had odds running on this. The bookies would have made a killing with Cantona coming in second!
Was always between him and Giggs I think..
Yeah its some sort of joke.
Ha it is Sir Alex, I called it.
Still, Giggs should have been top of the players.
Still, Giggs should have been top of the players.
Nah Giggs was never gunna be first here
Pretty stunned Cantona isn't
I'm gunna be stunned if Rooney isn't even on the list, and equally surprised if he turns up first!
Well, with everyone shifted up a position, I think it's actually a pretty good list...I wouldn't have had Keane 2nd, but thats a personal preference...Good Job Caftards, your sensible people
We should still do a poll though
We should still do a poll though
Irwin
Ferdinand
Beckham
Robson
Schmeichal
Scholes
Ronaldo
Giggs
Keane
Cantona
Not a bad list.
Ferdinand
Beckham
Robson
Schmeichal
Scholes
Ronaldo
Giggs
Keane
Cantona
Not a bad list.
Conclusion is done as well, hope you all enjoyed that! The reason I put SAF first was because otherwise it would have been slightly too obvious 
Well, looks like he is not.
Out of interest, who would you have taken off the list to make room for Rooney?
Only one player who was on my list didn't make the official list, and that was Ruud. I'd have had him in for Irwin.
1) Cantona
2) Ronaldo
3) Giggs
4) Scholes
5) Keane
6) Schmeichel
7) Rooney
8) Van Nistlerooy
9) Beckham
10) Solskjaer
I think I'd go with that list personally. Not included Robson because he was already here when Fergie arrived, and arguably his prime was pre Fergie
2) Ronaldo
3) Giggs
4) Scholes
5) Keane
6) Schmeichel
7) Rooney
8) Van Nistlerooy
9) Beckham
10) Solskjaer
I think I'd go with that list personally. Not included Robson because he was already here when Fergie arrived, and arguably his prime was pre Fergie
the list is actually better than I expected - should have had more faith in the Caf - glad Irwin made it over people like Rooney or RvN
I did have Bruce in my 10 though
I did have Bruce in my 10 though
No idea - having all these fantastic players play for us is a curse at times, it really is...
At one point Irwin was up in fifth
If you'd go with that list personally, you should have sent it into the voting.
Haha yeh, I just caught the thread now thoughIf you'd go with that list personally, you should have sent it into the voting.
so you dont rate any of the defenders who have played under Fergie?