Ronaldo Keane Cantona Giggs
Wonder who's the fifth? Whoever it is he's not deserving imo. Maybe G. Neville?
Wonder who's the fifth? Whoever it is he's not deserving imo. Maybe G. Neville?
Greatest ever player under Sir Alex - Results
- Thread starter The Law of Denis
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
As far as I remember without looking in my inbox, my list was Irwin, Ferdinand, Beckham, Van Nistelrooy, Keane, Scholes, Giggs, Cantona, Ronaldo, Schmeichel (the lack of Robson came from my interpretation of the question at the time, where I took the 'Golden Era of Fergie' to mean the time from which we started regularly winning things, as opposed to his arrival).
of course it does...I don't not rate him, I think he's a Legend... I just don't think he's the greatest player ever to play for United under Fergie
good point, I didn't even notice we were at 6th with Scholes...
It'll probably be Rooney or Ruud. Which is more to do with the fact that their more fresh in peoples memories.
Alright going to take a little break for a meal before the final countdown 
Alright going to take a little break for a meal before the final countdown
Me neither. I think I placed him third on my list, even though he's probably not in the top 3 most talented. The word 'greatest' doesn't just mean most talented, to me. It about having the talent and what you do with it - whether it be making a huge impact over a short space of time (Eric and Ronaldo), or making slightly less of an impact, but over a long period of time (Giggs and Scholes).
Can you imagine the controversy that would ensue if Ronaldo is at number 1?
5. van Nistelrooy
4. Keane
3. Ronaldo
2. Giggs
1. Cantona
4. Keane
3. Ronaldo
2. Giggs
1. Cantona
it would be a mess, the still angry/bitter lads would come out of the woodwork, lots of insults will be thrown about, etc.Can you imagine the controversy that would ensue if Ronaldo is at number 1?
I'm pretty sure it'll be Cantona or Keane though
Scholes has miraculously turned into Ronaldo...wtf?
? This poll is fixed, adding an extra player, change players around, wrong numbering...
Things are being changed during the results! I call shenanigans!
Aahh big mistake by me, I accidentally edited the Scholes one into Ronaldo
Scholes deserves to be higher than Ronaldo anyway :P
I guess that means Scholesy is at number 5 then?
Sounds about right. I certainly think Ronaldo should be higher than 6, though - probably at two or three, or even one.
Sounds about right. I certainly think Ronaldo should be higher than 6, though - probably at two or three, or even one.
Agreed !
one of the top 5 is going to be a suprise - probably votes for Rooney from the kids on here who dont know any better
interesting
And Brad.
Eh. Scholes back to 6th?
What's going on, TLoD?
What's going on, TLoD?
like i said 'the kids on here who dont know any better'
Damn I liked it better when Scholes was above Ronaldo.
what's with all the shenanigans
Yeah that's right Mockney, I stole your line.
Alright everything should be fine now, Scholes was voted 6th but when I wanted to enter Ronaldo I hit the wrong edit button so I wrote over the Scholes entry
I wonder who 4th's going to be
Yes, but how many points did Scholes score?
*Awaits ninja edit, making me look like strange pillock*
*Awaits ninja edit, making me look like strange pillock*
Bruce, Hughes, Gary Neville?
(I hope its not Ruud or Rooney)
(I hope its not Ruud or Rooney)
...it's certainly the most apt, regardless of djemba djembaI think 5 is a better position for Ronnie than 6...he should at least be in the top 5. It's a straight fight between Cantona & Giggs now I think
I think Keane's position in the results is going to be surprising for everyone
Keane, Giggs and Cantona clearly top 3... but who's 4th?
Rooney? Bruce? Ruud? Ole? Neville? Whatever happens, some great player's are missing out...
Rooney? Bruce? Ruud? Ole? Neville? Whatever happens, some great player's are missing out...
Giggs 4th?!!
Keane and Cantona left. WTF who's the mystery player?
Keane and Cantona left. WTF who's the mystery player?
to be fair, whoever it is isn't the 4th greatest player ever to play under Fergie...no matter how much I love & respect all those players
What the hell? Giggs at #4?! Are you people mad?! He should be far and away #1....
Correction...3rd (or maybe 2nd!!!)
someone in the top 3 definitely doesn't belong to be there, at all
Sir Alex is probably #1, or something like that.
Oh dear. What have you lot done?!
Crazy !