I also had the feeling for quite some years now, that in todays football there are much less typical superstar players around than it used to be. Back then the top nationalteams were stacked with superstar players, every single one of them. Just compare the 2006 WC teams for example with todays teams. Now i look at teams like Spain, Netherlands, Italy, England and others and i struggle to find any true superstars (or just 1-2). Only France, and to some extend Belgium, seem to be stacked with stars. And even this France squad doesn't look as good as the 2006 one.
And this obviously also translates to club football.
Maybe the problem is that at that time we still hadn't the chance to see every game from the top leagues week in week out, added with the globalization of Champions League Football.
Well there's a case to say in 2006 we already saw much more football from foreign leagues, but having grown up watching football Pre Bosman Rulling I have to say European Competitions were way more magic because you had the chance to see the best players from your country playing for your clubs.
Ok there is nostalgia on this. Then if we add the evolution of Football where everything is studied, padronized, more collective, less space for the individual, where the elimination of the number 10 is almost certain, or for some coaches they have to play on the wings, having 2 on your NT is a problem (hello Santos), where you are only allowed to make at least 2 touches, dribbling is show boating, reason why players like Neymar are hated, or Damsgaard look refreshing to watch, and now we want to turn the number 6 to more Kante likes, and the guys like Jorginho or Pirlos are labeled as passengers on your team and lack of pace, I don't know if the natural evolution of the game has been 100% perfect.
Far from being a reactionary, but football without individuals is turning into a monolithic scientific predictable stuff. If is that
@Poltophagy is mentioning, maybe it really is different, but hey, there's always pricks like Ronaldo ready to light up the it's all about me, don't worry, he will put the cream for the chicks.