- Joined
- Oct 22, 2010
- Messages
- 21,652
In terms of club seasons, Lewandowski was better than Messi (55 vs 52 G+A, Barca failed in the league while Bayern failed in the CL), in the international tournament Messi had the most goals, assists, MotMs, overall best player, and won the trophy - quite a performance, which nobody came close to in the Euros.It was always heavily political, at least previously there was little doubt Ronaldo/Messi we’re individually levels above everyone so it didn’t really matter who won it.
When neither Xavi/Iniesta won it after doing a Euros,WC, Euros clean sweep plus matching Messi’s domestic trophy haul, it seemed like maybe they were just going off stats/who scored the most and trophies didn’t really matter…Lewa not winning this year (regardless of being robbed by covid last year) then makes it more confusing. Now Messi/Ronaldo are both over hill (yes they’re still great but both way off where they were, naturally so) and one still wins it - essentially for finally winning the Copa you then refer back to Xavi/Iniesta not winning it despite winning superior trophies and ask the question…why does anyone even put value on the BdO?
Among the other standout players from last season - Benzema played great but won nothing, Gundogan???, Haaland scored a ton but won nothing and didn't make a mark in the CL KOs (his biggest stage), Jorginho got all the medals but wasn't the star for either club or country, Ronaldo scored a ton but Juve lost for the first time in forever.
I think Messi is a fair call, same as Lewa. Statistically way ahead of the rest of the field, choosing one depends on weighing Bayern's millionth-in-a-row league win over Argentina's rare Copa.
I think a few things went against Xavi/Iniesta - they're two people, hard to definitively choose one and say he was the best that year, whereas Messi's performance was always more individual, bias against non-goalscorers, and, finally, when the three were on the same team, there was one clear standout. I wanted Sneijder to win in 2010 (treble and WC final) but going back and watching Messi's absurd club season - can't really argue.