Next permanent manager | Poll updated

Who should be the next permanent manager?

  • Luis Enrique

    Votes: 113 7.4%
  • Erik ten Hag

    Votes: 1,300 84.7%
  • Julen Lopetegui

    Votes: 10 0.7%
  • Mauricio Pochettino

    Votes: 79 5.1%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 32 2.1%

  • Total voters
    1,534
Status
Not open for further replies.

Hoof the ball

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2008
Messages
12,319
Location
San Antonio, Texas.
How can you be so sure about someone you haven't followed closely?

He's level with on points with PSV, potentially behind Feyenoord if they win their game in hand. Can't help thing people are getting carried away about him.
Some context on this.

13 games, 9 wins, 3 draws, 1 loss for Ajax.
13 games, 10 wins, 0 draws, 3 losses for PSV.

However......

Ajax have scored 42 and conceded 2.
PSV have scored 33 and conceded 20!

Equal points, but read the fine details and it's plain to see that Ajax have been much more dominant in all their games than PSV have been. Considerably so. Based on goals scored and conceded, it's a matter of time before PSV drop more points and Ajax develop a sizable lead.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
It's gonna be Ten Hag or Poch and I have always said I have a gut feeling it will be Poch. This board just cannot let their obsession of him go.
Yeah does look like they are prepared to miss out on Ten Hag to finally see whether Pochettino can manage this club
 

JB7

Full Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Messages
8,851
Well, they're topping the group now and have been dominant all season with a worse team of individuals compared to 2018-2019. Doesn't that prove it's not a fluke?

I didn't closely follow them in those seasons specifically, so someone who followed them more closely would likely better explain the reasoning for the poorer results.

That said, he did lose some key players in both seasons and had to reshape the squad.
I don't disagree, they are flying this season. But doing well in a group stage 3 years later doesn't prove that a run to the semi-finals was not a fluke in my view, no.

Equally, the fees that some of those key players have been sold for would suggest that it was an incredible crop of players and that possibly they deserved to make the semi-finals despite their young ages.

Look, I'm not against the idea of Ten Hag and I think his work has been very impressive but I don't understand how he is seen so definitively (56% of this poll for example) as the answer to our problems at this stage
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
Some context on this.

13 games, 9 wins, 3 draws, 1 loss for Ajax.
13 games, 10 wins, 0 draws, 3 losses for PSV.

However......

Ajax have scored 42 and conceded 2.
PSV have scored 33 and conceded 20!

Equal points, but read the fine details and it's plain to see that Ajax have been much more dominant in all their games than PSV have been. Considerably so. Based on goals scored and conceded, it's a matter of time before PSV drop more points and Ajax develop a sizable lead.
Yeah that level of dominance in a game is another thing which really appeals to me
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
I'm pretty much lost by the decision making at this club.

We've got rid of Ole and all i'm hearing is "Interim"

What kind of forward planning is this? It's utterly shambolic we haven't got a plan in place seeing as Ole has been under fore for weeks, if not months!

Whoever we hire will suffer under this club purely as we are not run with any logic.

This club needs a shake up, from top to bottom.

Carrick cannot be given this job for any length of time
 

diarm

Full Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2014
Messages
16,805
There's something about Poch that people seem to like, myself included.

But at the end of the day, you can only really judge a manager on results - and his aren't good enough.

He managed to finish 3rd in a 2 horse race the year Leicester won the title and all the traditionally big clubs in England were off the boil.

The biggest question mark surrounding Ten Hag, is the league he has been successful in - but at least he's been successful in it.

Poch took over one of the most expensively assembled teams in the history of football, and came second in a weaker league than the Dutch.

Make whatever excuses for him that you like, but there is absolutely no evidence that Poch is the man to bring success back to Old Trafford. He might come in and be successful, but it would be a lucky punt that came off, rather than a shrewd appointment.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
I'm pretty much lost by the decision making at this club.

We've got rid of Ole and all i'm hearing is "Interim"

What kind of forward planning is this? It's utterly shambolic we haven't got a plan in place seeing as Ole has been under fore for weeks, if not months!

Whoever we hire will suffer under this club purely as we are not run with any logic.

This club needs a shake up, from top to bottom.

Carrick cannot be given this job for any length of time
I would take an interim to get Ten Hag
 

hurricane thunderclap

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
1,154
I'm pretty much lost by the decision making at this club.

We've got rid of Ole and all i'm hearing is "Interim"

What kind of forward planning is this? It's utterly shambolic we haven't got a plan in place seeing as Ole has been under fore for weeks, if not months!

Whoever we hire will suffer under this club purely as we are not run with any logic.

This club needs a shake up, from top to bottom.

Carrick cannot be given this job for any length of time
It's because they want someone until they get someone else but get them in the summer. Ffs.
 

glazed

Eats diamonds to beat thermodynamics
Joined
Sep 30, 2012
Messages
7,707
23 year old or peak Ronaldo doesn’t press either, that’s what I am trying to say, if lack of pressing is your main concern.
High concerted pressing from the front wasn't really as much of a thing in those days so no-one cared. Bit further back but Gary Lineker didn't get a single yellow card in his entire career iirc.

Not with the current squad no. If we want to appoint a manager like that then we would have to get rid of Ronaldo.

Makes no sense employing a manager who wants to set up his team to play a certain way, then basically saying you can’t play that way because it wouldn’t fit in with our highest profile and highest paid player who can’t be dropped.
This is exactly right and also exactly the way we are headed. Some people square the circle by saying you can do a high press and allow yourself one luxury player excused from that duty. They say other teams do that, like Bayern. But I don't see it happen at City or at Liverpool and they are the gold standard of club football right now. I don't know about Chelsea having not watched them - perhaps others can comment? Seems to me that high press involves incredible work rate which becomes unsustainable if one player isn't doing it.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
There's something about Poch that people seem to like, myself included.

But at the end of the day, you can only really judge a manager on results - and his aren't good enough.

He managed to finish 3rd in a 2 horse race the year Leicester won the title and all the traditionally big clubs in England were off the boil.

The biggest question mark surrounding Ten Hag, is the league he has been successful in - but at least he's been successful in it.

Poch took over one of the most expensively assembled teams in the history of football, and came second in a weaker league than the Dutch.

Make whatever excuses for him that you like, but there is absolutely no evidence that Poch is the man to bring success back to Old Trafford. He might come in and be successful, but it would be a lucky punt that came off, rather than a shrewd appointment.
I won't boot him for finishing third that season as clearly the squad were broken by blowing the league at Chelsea. I just cannot get away from the thought of Ten Hag putting his blueprint on this club
 

hurricane thunderclap

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
1,154
High concerted pressing from the front wasn't really as much of a thing in those days so no-one cared. Bit further back but Gary Lineker didn't get a single yellow card in his entire career iirc.



This is exactly right and also exactly the way we are headed. Some people square the circle by saying you can do a high press and allow yourself one luxury player excused from that duty. They say other teams do that, like Bayern. But I don't see it happen at City or at Liverpool and they are the gold standard of club football right now. I don't know about Chelsea having not watched them - perhaps others can comment? Seems to me that high press involves incredible work rate which becomes unsustainable if one player isn't doing it.
As if this years buzzword high press is going to compensate for our back four.
 

Rhyme Animal

Thinks Di Zerbi is better than Pep.
Joined
Sep 3, 2015
Messages
11,193
Location
Nonchalantly scoring the winner...
High concerted pressing from the front wasn't really as much of a thing in those days so no-one cared. Bit further back but Gary Lineker didn't get a single yellow card in his entire career iirc.



This is exactly right and also exactly the way we are headed. Some people square the circle by saying you can do a high press and allow yourself one luxury player excused from that duty. They say other teams do that, like Bayern. But I don't see it happen at City or at Liverpool and they are the gold standard of club football right now. I don't know about Chelsea having not watched them - perhaps others can comment? Seems to me that high press involves incredible work rate which becomes unsustainable if one player isn't doing it.
So sell Ronaldo…

Surely the manager has ultimate power..? If not, who does…?

Ed Woodward?
 

Leftback99

Might have a bedwetting fetish.
Joined
Jan 11, 2015
Messages
14,479
Some context on this.

13 games, 9 wins, 3 draws, 1 loss for Ajax.
13 games, 10 wins, 0 draws, 3 losses for PSV.

However......

Ajax have scored 42 and conceded 2.
PSV have scored 33 and conceded 20!

Equal points, but read the fine details and it's plain to see that Ajax have been much more dominant in all their games than PSV have been. Considerably so. Based on goals scored and conceded, it's a matter of time before PSV drop more points and Ajax develop a sizable lead.
Expected goals looks a lot closer, suggesting they have been very lucky to only concede 2.
 

Berbaclass

Fallen Muppet. Lest we never forget
Joined
Jan 23, 2010
Messages
39,179
Location
Cooper Station
Presume you mean Ten Hag not Pochettino
No I’m taking about Poch. Simon Stones information is obviously solid. What would you do if you were PSG and you saw your manager flirting with other clubs. They’d probably decapitate him if they were allowed to.
 

hurricane thunderclap

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
1,154
Just cannot see any way he leaves Ajax now and Mitten article backs up he would be cheaper to get in the summer
Stop being silly, if you or anyone is offered a better, higher paid job then they take it. If he wants to stay then he didn't want the job or he feels it is too much to do and they cannot do it.
 

Keefy18

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
2,653
I'm pretty much lost by the decision making at this club.

We've got rid of Ole and all i'm hearing is "Interim"

What kind of forward planning is this? It's utterly shambolic we haven't got a plan in place seeing as Ole has been under fore for weeks, if not months!

Whoever we hire will suffer under this club purely as we are not run with any logic.

This club needs a shake up, from top to bottom.

Carrick cannot be given this job for any length of time
The mistake they made was not sacking him after City, they'd of given themselves the international break then to search for a new manager. Instead wasted it and saw out the Watford game and now we've fixture congestion and no one really in mind.

As we've games tomorrow and the weekend someone on the coaching team must remain to take charge, that's Carrick.

They obviously want someone to take the job full time but most everyone is in jobs currently.

So interim it shall be til May to try salvage the season.
 

UnsungHero

Full Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2012
Messages
905
Location
Monitoring the preparation of the Vidal bid
So we're all patiently waiting for an update from the likes of Bouhafsi/Laurens about whether PSG are prepared to let him go...

I'd probably rather Ten Hag, but given what we're dealing with (Woodard & Glazers), I think we should all be happy with Pochettino, it's a balance all round.

There are absolutely no signs they are going to overhaul the football operation and get in a fancy Sporting Director and slightly obscure and untested manager in the PL (Ten Hag). Wishful thinking IMO.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
Stop being silly, if you or anyone is offered a better, higher paid job then they take it. If he wants to stay then he didn't want the job or he feels it is too much to do and they cannot do it.
I really want to believe that but the information is from a strong Utd source
 

Jeffthered

Full Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2015
Messages
2,710
It is a bit of a mess, and the Board are going to continue to feel the pressure of discontent from us fans, sponsors, high-profile pundits, former players etc, because this is an absolute disaster. The resources Man Utd have, and we are run in such a shambolic way, highlights a profligate culture within the club, and a lack of leadership. Woodward has to go soon, he's a big problem and he doesn't work for the footballing side of the club.

Anyway, back to manager.. my feeling is we stick with Carrick till end of the season, BUT.. he has to bring in some new people as coaching staff.. he has to, because if we can get a new energy in there, we could still have a half-decent season. The squad is v good, (a little over-rated I personally think..) but still v v good. And he must have plenty lessons to draw on as to what to avoid.

The thing is, and I obviously do not know him, Carrick strikes me as a quiet kinda' guy... and we don't need another 'friend of the fans and players'. We need a bleedin' good manager.

In many ways, having these conversations seems somewhat surreal to me. Incredible situation.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,815
So we're all patiently waiting for an update from the likes of Bouhafsi/Laurens about whether PSG are prepared to let him go...

I'd probably rather Ten Hag, but given what we're dealing with (Woodard & Glazers), I think we should all be happy with Pochettino, it's a balance all round.

There are absolutely no signs they are going to overhaul the football operation and get in a fancy Sporting Director and slightly obscure and untested manager in the PL (Ten Hag). Wishful thinking IMO.
Yeah you do feel Ten Hag equals too much structure change in our board's eyes
 

Berbaclass

Fallen Muppet. Lest we never forget
Joined
Jan 23, 2010
Messages
39,179
Location
Cooper Station
So we're all patiently waiting for an update from the likes of Bouhafsi/Laurens about whether PSG are prepared to let him go...

I'd probably rather Ten Hag, but given what we're dealing with (Woodard & Glazers), I think we should all be happy with Pochettino, it's a balance all round.

There are absolutely no signs they are going to overhaul the football operation and get in a fancy Sporting Director and slightly obscure and untested manager in the PL (Ten Hag). Wishful thinking IMO.
Pochettino reportedly wants control over things so I doubt he’d want all that anyway.
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
I would take an interim to get Ten Hag
There's no benefit in an interim until the summer than keeping Ole in post.

We are ether changing or we aren't. We wont get a good interim manager and what's the point in another thought process until it's changed in the summer! Crazy
 

glazed

Eats diamonds to beat thermodynamics
Joined
Sep 30, 2012
Messages
7,707
This is a great summary. Id also add that Poch’s team don’t seem to have a distinct identity or style of play. Even if you look deeper, it’s more pragmatic than visionary. Also, I can’t make up my mind whether Poch is Brendan Mk 2 or someone who’ll get elevated at the right club.
Poch's pragmatism is actually of concern. You can see how he took the PSG job knowing that he couldn't implement his preferred style and doing a bit of a bodge without making a fuss. That would appeal to the Glazers.
 

CallyRed

Full Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2009
Messages
11,123
I'd take Brucey until end of t'season if was told we would then be getting T'Hag.
 

Hoof the ball

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2008
Messages
12,319
Location
San Antonio, Texas.
Expected goals looks a lot closer, suggesting they have been very lucky to only concede 2.
I'm all for expected goals as it's a very useful tool to determine performance indicators, but we're dealing with a differential of 18 goals in 13 games between them. Perhaps there's some luck, but another factor that raises an xG rating is the number of shots, so it could be also that PSV concede better chances whereas Ajax court more volume of shots overall but not necessarily from as dangerous positions. This too would elevate the xG score, whilst giving a reason as to why they've conceded few goals.

Besides, not only have Ajax conceded less, but they've scored 11 more. They might be 'lucky' in one metric, but in two? Nah.
 

MUFC OK

New Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2014
Messages
7,216
There's something about Poch that people seem to like, myself included.

But at the end of the day, you can only really judge a manager on results - and his aren't good enough.

He managed to finish 3rd in a 2 horse race the year Leicester won the title and all the traditionally big clubs in England were off the boil.

The biggest question mark surrounding Ten Hag, is the league he has been successful in - but at least he's been successful in it.

Poch took over one of the most expensively assembled teams in the history of football, and came second in a weaker league than the Dutch.

Make whatever excuses for him that you like, but there is absolutely no evidence that Poch is the man to bring success back to Old Trafford. He might come in and be successful, but it would be a lucky punt that came off, rather than a shrewd appointment.
Assuming that you think ETH is the shrewd appointment? I don’t disagree, but I think it’s between these two now with Zidane clearly uninterested.

Honestly, I’d be happy with either but we know SAF is a big fan of Poch so I think it will be him. We should do all we can to get him bedded in this season.
 

Berbaclass

Fallen Muppet. Lest we never forget
Joined
Jan 23, 2010
Messages
39,179
Location
Cooper Station
I like the idea of Pochettino now. Gives him two windows before we essentially start next season. I think he’d get into the CL this season too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.