Oscar Zambrano

DarkRed

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 28, 2019
Messages
359
Location
wolf den
Our chief scout is of South American base, so this is basically the first time the scouts are listened to.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,852
He actually looks legitimately very good, I wonder if we've just decided it's easier to hack Brighton's emails now and get their targets.
 

Kramer

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 30, 2019
Messages
359
He actually looks legitimately very good, I wonder if we've just decided it's easier to hack Brighton's emails now and get their targets.
Something we should have done a long time ago.
 

GreatDane

Full Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2019
Messages
1,607
He actually looks legitimately very good, I wonder if we've just decided it's easier to hack Brighton's emails now and get their targets.
Yeah, hire their IT specialist would work.

But agree, he looks good. A fighter that can both tackle and pass.
 

luke511

Full Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2013
Messages
6,966
Didn't we just, in all our wisdom, turn him down for something paltry like £5m? Hardly hijacked.
We approached him then Brighton followed. Whilst we were having difficulty with the nature of it, they were much more familiar with the process due to a similar signing the previous summer, and made the advancement before we could (I think).
 

Ali Dia

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
14,336
Location
Souness's Super Sub/George Weahs Talented Cousin
We approached him then Brighton followed. Whilst we were having difficulty with the nature of it, they were much more familiar with the process due to a similar signing the previous summer, and made the advancement before we could (I think).
There was a third part ownership situation if my memory serves me. For a player that cheap it would have been quite easy to pay them off. We just aren’t very good at signing good players on the cheap.
 

Grande

Full Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
6,352
Location
The Land of Do-What-You-Will
We approached him then Brighton followed. Whilst we were having difficulty with the nature of it, they were much more familiar with the process due to a similar signing the previous summer, and made the advancement before we could (I think).
Yea, I seem to remember it was issues around third party ownership or something. Either way, it wasn’t that we hadn’t scouted him properly or weren’t interested.
 

Uniquim

Full Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
5,747
Location
Location, Location
Didn't we just, in all our wisdom, turn him down for something paltry like £5m? Hardly hijacked.
Hardly as simple as that. The South American countries, especially outside of Argentina and Brazil, is a nightmare transfer dealings if you don't shop there regularly. That's part of the reason so many move to Argentina/Brazil before Europe.

Brighton have been shopping in the other south american countries several times and had done business with Independiente del Valle prior to Caicedo. In some cases just finding the right representatives is a hassle in itself. Having relationships with clubs in the region gives a huge advantage. One of the reasons (other than stature) that Real Madrid lands so many Brazilian gems and get them to sign (Vini, Rodrygo, Endrick etc) is because of Juni Calafat who have been working the region and establishing good realtions with clubs and families of players over time.

Caicedo said his dream was to play for Man Utd and be like Antonio Valencia (also Ecuadorian), so had we had better relations with IDV we would've 100% landed him. I know Zambrano is from Liga de Quito, but IDV is doing exceptionally well with their academy. Chelsea signed Kendry Paez (16) from their in the summer too. He's alredy in the first team.


Here's an excerpt on the Caicedo deal:

The Athletic said:
Brighton know, from experience, how awkward transfer dealings can be in South America. Aside from the language barrier, there are cultural differences to take into account. The level of mistrust inside the industry escalates further when outsiders are involved. Building relationships with the right people gives you a head start — provided you can establish who the right people are. Players often have several different representatives with ownership rights.

On one occasion, during what Brighton’s negotiating team assumed was a private meeting about a South American player they were interested in, an apparent stranger wandered into the talks unannounced. He turned out to be the player’s uncle.

Brighton have grown accustomed to such difficulties. They made an audacious attempt five years ago to sign Jonathan Calleri from Boca Juniors before the striker had a brief dalliance with the Premier League at West Ham in the 2016-17 season.
There's also this
[Caicedo's] representatives recognised there is more chance of their client playing regularly in the Premier League at the Amex Stadium than at Old Trafford or Stamford Bridge.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,852
Hardly as simple as that. The South American countries, especially outside of Argentina and Brazil, is a nightmare transfer dealings if you don't shop there regularly. That's part of the reason so many move to Argentina/Brazil before Europe.

Brighton have been shopping in the other south american countries several times and had done business with Independiente del Valle prior to Caicedo. In some cases just finding the right representatives is a hassle in itself. Having relationships with clubs in the region gives a huge advantage. One of the reasons (other than stature) that Real Madrid lands so many Brazilian gems and get them to sign (Vini, Rodrygo, Endrick etc) is because of Juni Calafat who have been working the region and establishing good realtions with clubs and families of players over time.

Caicedo said his dream was to play for Man Utd and be like Antonio Valencia (also Ecuadorian), so had we had better relations with IDV we would've 100% landed him. I know Zambrano is from Liga de Quito, but IDV is doing exceptionally well with their academy. Chelsea signed Kendry Paez (16) from their in the summer too. He's alredy in the first team.


Here's an excerpt on the Caicedo deal:



There's also this
Appreciate the detail but nothing here changes what I said. I have no doubt it's harder to deal with some of these leagues/agents but the mooted fee for Caicedo was so comparatively small, you can't be telling me that United turned down signing someone they wanted for £4.5m (the fee Brighton paid) because they found it "difficult". From other replies above, I assume the scouts didn't rate him high enough or we were just wary of the 3rd party ownership piece.

The part about game time is a real factor but then if the player loved United as much as you point out above + would get a bigger contract, I'm not sure his representatives would think Brighton was a much better spot. They didn't have European football, they don't pay that well, and when you look at him choosing Chelsea over Pool (as much as I dislike Pool, one of those clubs is much more likely to win trophies than the other) I imagine he's at least somewhat money motivated given he's now got an 8 year deal with an optional year.

Surely it's more logical that the reason Brighton/similar clubs look in minor, less well known leagues is most bigger clubs won't take a risk on those players until they see them in a more established league i.e. Brasil/Argentina. hence the ability to find a player with huge resale value versus the signings Real etc. make - for example Vicinius cost Real £40m from memory and whilst that fee looks great now, it's a major transfer. Similar for Rodrygo.
 

Zaboot

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 5, 2019
Messages
56
how about Nice sign him and loan him to Utd

easy way to avoid FFP as we don't have to pay anything up front for his signing
Nice are going to be most likely playing in the champions league next season.
I very much doubt they are there to meet our needs.
 

Uniquim

Full Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
5,747
Location
Location, Location
Appreciate the detail but nothing here changes what I said. I have no doubt it's harder to deal with some of these leagues/agents but the mooted fee for Caicedo was so comparatively small, you can't be telling me that United turned down signing someone they wanted for £4.5m (the fee Brighton paid) because they found it "difficult". From other replies above, I assume the scouts didn't rate him high enough or we were just wary of the 3rd party ownership piece.

The part about game time is a real factor but then if the player loved United as much as you point out above + would get a bigger contract, I'm not sure his representatives would think Brighton was a much better spot. They didn't have European football, they don't pay that well, and when you look at him choosing Chelsea over Pool (as much as I dislike Pool, one of those clubs is much more likely to win trophies than the other) I imagine he's at least somewhat money motivated given he's now got an 8 year deal with an optional year.

Surely it's more logical that the reason Brighton/similar clubs look in minor, less well known leagues is most bigger clubs won't take a risk on those players until they see them in a more established league i.e. Brasil/Argentina. hence the ability to find a player with huge resale value versus the signings Real etc. make - for example Vicinius cost Real £40m from memory and whilst that fee looks great now, it's a major transfer. Similar for Rodrygo.
Going by South American transfers outside of ARG/BRA, I think clubs can very easily drop a player they want of transfer complications, or that they end up having such a slow process that other clubs get the signing done before you even get in front of the right representatives. It's a huge advantage to have good relations with clubs, and to actually travel for the meetings. But yeah, very much possible in this case that scouts just didn't rate him that highly too, but there were like 8 clubs reportedly in for him at the time. There's a lot of bullshit you have to trundle through with agents from smaller leagues, it could end up costing a lot of money.

Re: contract, I think Brighton were the only team that actually got to the point where they had an offer accepted from clubs and reps, and a contract to sign on the table for him to sign. I remember following the Caicedo deal quite closely because I'd seen him play a few times and wanted us to get him.

It's definitely a factor that Brighton and clubs like them more often look outside Argentina / Brazil. That's why they have the established relations as well.
They expect to sell starters, and can plan a clearer pathway for emerging players, but the talents at IDV gets into the first team early, they regularly play in the Copa Libertadores and even made the final once (which is very impressive for a team outside of Brazil/Argentina), they've also won the Sudamericana (their version of Europa League) twice in the last 5 years, and Liga de Quito (Zambrano's team, also from Ecuador) won it this year, so there are plenty of chances to see the talents in established competitions that compares to experience in the Brazilian league, but yeah I'm sure it's factor. It's also easier to buy from Brazilian clubs. Most players from the Brazilian league won't cost ~40m like Vini either. Or €60m like Endrick cost Real Madrid when he was 16.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,852
Going by South American transfers outside of ARG/BRA, I think clubs can very easily drop a player they want of transfer complications, or that they end up having such a slow process that other clubs get the signing done before you even get in front of the right representatives. It's a huge advantage to have good relations with clubs, and to actually travel for the meetings. But yeah, very much possible in this case that scouts just didn't rate him that highly too, but there were like 8 clubs reportedly in for him at the time. There's a lot of bullshit you have to trundle through with agents from smaller leagues, it could end up costing a lot of money.

Re: contract, I think Brighton were the only team that actually got to the point where they had an offer accepted from clubs and reps, and a contract to sign on the table for him to sign. I remember following the Caicedo deal quite closely because I'd seen him play a few times and wanted us to get him.

It's definitely a factor that Brighton and clubs like them more often look outside Argentina / Brazil. That's why they have the established relations as well.
They expect to sell starters, and can plan a clearer pathway for emerging players, but the talents at IDV gets into the first team early, they regularly play in the Copa Libertadores and even made the final once (which is very impressive for a team outside of Brazil/Argentina), they've also won the Sudamericana (their version of Europa League) twice in the last 5 years, and Liga de Quito (Zambrano's team, also from Ecuador) won it this year, so there are plenty of chances to see the talents in established competitions that compares to experience in the Brazilian league, but yeah I'm sure it's factor. It's also easier to buy from Brazilian clubs. Most players from the Brazilian league won't cost ~40m like Vini either. Or €60m like Endrick cost Real Madrid when he was 16.
Yes they seem a very good team - I'm basing that of what you're saying (not going to pretend I follow the Ecuadorian league, SA domestic comps outside of the Copa) and it will be interesting with so much money flowing into the sport if we start to see more 'big' clubs start to comb through these so called lesser leagues. It does make me wonder where the good younger English DM/CM types are, we obviously have Mainoo, Brighton have Hinshelwood, there's that Wright kid at City but it does seem an area we don't produce great players in.

Any others gems you've seen in that league?
 

mikeyt

Full Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Messages
791
The sort of signing I'd love us to make and the type of profile we need to focus on. Meaning he'll be at Brighton before the end of the month.
 

Uniquim

Full Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
5,747
Location
Location, Location
Yes they seem a very good team - I'm basing that of what you're saying (not going to pretend I follow the Ecuadorian league, SA domestic comps outside of the Copa) and it will be interesting with so much money flowing into the sport if we start to see more 'big' clubs start to comb through these so called lesser leagues. It does make me wonder where the good younger English DM/CM types are, we obviously have Mainoo, Brighton have Hinshelwood, there's that Wright kid at City but it does seem an area we don't produce great players in.

Any others gems you've seen in that league?
I mostly watch Brazilian league + Argentinian league and the continental competitions which is where I've seen IDV play. They were in a group with Flamengo (who I follow) a few years ago. Caicedo played there at the time.

Assuming you mean current players in South America, Valentín Barco is the best one yet to move in my opinion. I really enjoy watching him play. Looks like he's ready-made for the Premier League, and have carried a Boca team with Rojo, Romero, Cavani in a lot games in the past year. Echeverri who just signed for City looks good too, he's staying at River on loan. I think Federico Redondo (son of Fernando) have been looking great, especially in the Libertadores. Exequiel Zeballos looked really good, but he's been ruined by injuries in the past two years, tore his ACL among other stuff. Oscar Medina is one that I feel is flying under the radar for the moment. Prestianni on the other hand is a little bit hyped up I think. Good player nonetheless, but I'm not feeling the hype that much. In Brazil a lot of the most exciting players have moved now and in the summer, like Beraldo, Gomes, Vitor Roque, França+++. I'm most excited about Lorran at the moment. Should get some more game time when the Carioca starts in a couple of weeks.

Among the lesser hyped ones to move already, João Gomes is one to keep an eye on. Starting to do well at Wolves now but he was such a good player for Flamengo. Protected the defence incredibly well. Pretty sure they'd win the league this year if he stayed, because their midfield fell apart without Gomes, was noticeable already from the 4-3 Supercopa v Palmeiras which was the first important game after he left.
 

kaku06

Full Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2022
Messages
2,402
Been following him for 15 minutes and after watching videos of him for 3 minutes non stop, i can confirm him to be a mix of Zambrotta and Di Stefano. And with a first name Oscar, he is destined to be star. Never been so sure of a player since Joseph Minala.