They have, if the defender makes an honest attempt for the ball.
Premier League Gameweek 22
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Is that the penalty?? That more like a red card for diving
Its a pen but never a red card. They made a rule that those type of reds only apply when intentional these days
Looks like the strikers left heel connects with Luiz knee as he's pulling his leg back for the shot.
Harsh, would be fuming if that was against us.
VAR didn't overturn?
VAR didn't overturn?
It s a pen because luiz accidentally clipped the opponents foot. But never a red card
Thats not a pen
Luiz clips him. That's a pen all day.
It's soft, but going by the law it's a pen and red. Luiz really needed to avoid that step across. Had to let him shoot.
They don’t tend to overturn the on field official
It is probably a penalty but no way is that a red card.
How can you tell if it was accidental or not? Can you read his mind?
Yeah take it. They were playing well enough to win anyway
How is it not a pen David Luiz literally touches him. Look at David Luiz's reaction when he accidentally hits him
As soon as he touches him he starts to stumble
then show me a gif with the contact.
if there is a touch, it is a red. but i can see nothing.
That's a sly attempt at a trip. It's good to see that David Luiz couldn't get away with that. Efan Ekoku sounded annoyed, though; he thought that the attempted trip was just an accident!
Why the feck do they keep asking Peter Walton his opinion on key refereeing decisions in a match when you know he’s always going to side with the official?
Our game against Sheffield Utd last week is a prime example.
Our game against Sheffield Utd last week is a prime example.
That’s the point, you can’t! Luiz is cnutish enough to do that.
Never forget the simile on the smug bastard after getting Rafael sent off
I'll happily take credit for jinxing that
"It's accidental". So fecking what? He touches him in full sprint, falls over himself because of it which makes it obvious there was contact and he denies Wolves a clear goal-scoring opportunity. Clear pen, clear red all day.
So fecking what? He touches him in full sprint, falls over himself because of it which makes it obvious there was contact and he denies Wolves a clear goal-scoring opportunity. Clear pen, clear red all day.Think I am going blind. I can't even spot the clipping of Luiz leg. Maybe need an alternate angle
Have to get home to earn his money somehow
That worked out well.
I can't see any contact and if there is it certainly isn't enough to make him go down.
That didn't look a penalty but from Luiz's reaction it looks he did make a contact. A soft red for me.
It is a penalty. Not sure if it's a red card though, I thought they changed the rule?
Between 46 and 47 seconds in the GifLord clip. Luiz's left leg clips the left heel of the forward.
All it takes is one mistake for the house of cards to collapse. That penalty incident exposed their defensive weakness.
Partey got sucked into the ball instead of holding his good position. Holding was not aware of where Podence was, and when he got the ball, he got sucked towards him instead of cutting off the passing option to his left. David Luiz was slow to recover to his defensive position and got caught off as a result.
It started with Partey, but it could still have been prevented had the defenders remained alert to the dangers around them.
I hate Arsenal but that is a ridiculous decision
You Can’t be sent off for the striker clipping you
He didn’t even go for the tackle
He pulled out of the tackle,how VAR can’t overturn that I don’t understand?
You Can’t be sent off for the striker clipping you
He didn’t even go for the tackle
He pulled out of the tackle,how VAR can’t overturn that I don’t understand?
The wolves lad is winding up to shoot and Luiz slyly gets in the way and throws his shooting leg off so much he misses the ball completely.
It's a pen for impeding the attacker. Whether it is a red depends on the rules, whatever they are these days
It's a pen for impeding the attacker. Whether it is a red depends on the rules, whatever they are these days
Are people losing sense of reality claiming that wasn't a penalty?
He cut across him on the run and clearly caught the back slide of the attacker who clear opportunity to shoot and score.
.
If that's not a penalty then everyone should just run into people to clip them from behind
He cut across him on the run and clearly caught the back slide of the attacker who clear opportunity to shoot and score.
.
If that's not a penalty then everyone should just run into people to clip them from behind
Pen and no card for me.
Precisely.
You just know what he’s going to say regardless if it’s correct or not. Whatever the ref gives, it’s always the correct call even if it’s blatantly not.
All the people saying they can't see contact urgently need to visit the opticians.
Luiz's left knee at 47:39/40. There.
Luiz's left knee at 47:39/40. There.
Only the ref can after looking at the monitor
Luiz clips him so no question penalty, in my view is red, I can understand why some say it wasn’t red. He pretended it was accidental but I think he knew what he was doing, I never give penalty away like that but I gave fouls like that before by clipping player from behind to stop counter attack, pretend that it was accidental so I knew what Luiz was doing there. Cannot wait for AFTV today with Ty blaming referee, arsenal controversy since 2003 and wolves got relegated clips, it will be fun.
Clear pen, because he tripped him up. Red is very harsh I must say.
Looking at the clips about he caught the Wolves players, whether accidently or not. I thought it was only a sending off if they deem it as not attempting to get the ball. If he claims it as accidental, then he wasn't attempting to get the ball.
Thought Partey was pretty weak against us too.