Because they scored straight after?!
Premier League Gameweek 37
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
They just said on sky that by the letter of the law, it should only be a yellow because Newcastle went on to score.
Looking at it now, I wish Atsu missed and TAA received a red and Newcastle won a pen.
This. There was no advantage there for Newcastle. A man up with a penalty and the game completely changes.
Then he should find a new career.
Dutch pundits think TAA shouldve at least gotten a yellow.
Whatever happens this season, Liverpool have had more than their share of luck. This won't continue and they'll struggle to replicate the form into next season.
Luckily people explained it in posts above
So if VAR is in play here and Atsu scores, does the goal get disallowed and play brought back?
Exactly. The ref did them a big favour that night.
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/ref-i-did-chelsea-a-favour-1607622
No. The goal trumps the offence.
exactly.
the whole, things even themselves out, play on just doesn’t seem enough in these instances.
2 games till the end of the league & the assist machine fullback handballs on the line; doesn’t get sent off & assists.
officiating is so inconsistent & bad, will VAR alert that the goal should stand as a play on but TAA should be carded i wonder
Haha what? It’s the same as it was. Different crosses for different situations. The same way Beckham and Giggs, hell even Neville and Evra spent years putting in different kinds of crosses. The same way TAA and Robertson do it at Liverpool. Does help when you have people like Mane, Salah in the box on the move, or going back Yorke, Cole and Van nistelrooy as opposed to Lukaku and Martial and Lukaku standing still. But yeah ‘outdated something something, modern day football the best something something ‘..
Absolutely gutted that the pub I’ve chosen has a disco going on at the same time.
Trying to watch the football while some wanker wailing out ELO stands next to me
Trying to watch the football while some wanker wailing out ELO stands next to me
He should have been sent off regardless.
My point is people aren't against crossing.
They're against the rather aimless crossing we've resorted to at times over the years.
I'd always prefer a cutback at the byline versus a cross.
So teams should actively try not to score after such an offense by the opponent to gain full advantage of the situation.
It means nothing if the goal is allowed to stand. The result of the play doesn’t absolve an earlier infraction. If the ref plays advantage, that is his recognition of the infraction having taken place, you can’t have advantage without an infraction.Why would it be a red if the ref allowed the goal to stand? You can’t have it both ways.
I have seen numerous retroactive cautions where the ref shows ref after the play. I have only seen a handful of retro sending offs, but they do exist.
Fair enough.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Mr BLUEEEE SKYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!
Is there a link to this law?
I searched for like 10 minutes and I couldn't find it.
Closest thing I was found was this: "Advantage should not be applied in situations involving serious foul play, violent conduct or a second cautionable offence unless there is a clear opportunity to score a goal. The referee must send off the player when the ball is next out of play but if the player plays the ball or challenges/interferes with an opponent, the referee will stop play, send off the player and restart with an indirect free kick, unless the player committed a more serious offence." But it doesn't quite deal with the situation of what happens when a goal is scored.
Watching football and listening to ELO, not bad
Thank you.
Newcastle have similar composure to us.
Just watch them, hoofing balls from open space etc.
Just watch them, hoofing balls from open space etc.
So it means that the refs did not even see the handball.
"If the referee applies advantage..." is a big if, in this case. Especially as he didn't give him a booking.
I reckon he didn't see it at all, which is the worst of the possibilities. Get him a carriage clock in the summer and wish him all the best in his future endeavours.
I'm still no clearer on this ruling after reading all that.
Then again, I have been drinking most of the day
I like ELO, don’t get me wrong, but when the cnut who can’t sing is screaming it in your ear, it ruins the vibe significantly.
It was Xanadu.
There's a slight difference in the general positions of the crosses TAA and Robertson make compared to past players. In the past, wide players used to rarely cross before reaching the 18 yard box. Most crosses would be some yards past the 18 yard line wide to the side of it. TAA and Robertson's crosses, typically are some yards prior to reaching the 18 yard line and more infield, creating a cross that goes in diagonally, whereas, older wingers used to cross horizontally across the box.
Weirdest thing is that in a multibillion (insert currency of choice) sport, some of the rules are unclear even to people who commentate on it for a living.
After 30 minutes of searching Im still not sure what the correct call would've been.
After 30 minutes of searching Im still not sure what the correct call would've been.
Have you ever watched football before?
When do you ever see someone sent off for a handball, AND the goal given?
Yeah that was my thought. People were saying if Atsu missed then the ref could have given a penalty and a red. Nah, if Atsu missed we would have played on because Liverpool have had insane luck with refs this year
Xanadu
Last train to LONDON!!!!!!!!!!! That was the Discovery Disco-very album
Does he(FSW) still do zonal marking with newcastle because the defending from them has been p!ss poor.
How can you deny a goalscoring opportunity when the opportunity leads to a goal?
First goal was man marking.
First off, no need to be condescending.
Everything I read earlier pointed to TAA being sent off, until I saw the tweet linked from @Mogget
Doesn't the ref stop the game immediatley for a red card offence?
Don’t know what to do with Henderson, him running around like a madman helps us neither in defence or attack at the minute. We look very open
So Liverpool have gone from having a clown of a defense to having the best CB in the league and two of the best young fullbacks in the country, British too!