So basically you are just basing on this season (which has more than half a season to go) and are totally not considering what happened last season. Strange way to judge someone. Unless we are looking at which season was bad. In that case let the season atleast be over.Yeah, it's unfortunate for Erik that he's been manager this season too. If not I'd probably rank him highest of the two.
Strangely in gw 19 under Moyes, we were 6th , just like this season with 34 points. 3 points more. Hardly special. In fact I will argue that's even more worse considering he was taking over a side which had champion players who knew how to win titles. Unless now you will argue this squad is better than that.