Alexis was poor for the start of the 2017/18 season before he joined us in January but on the 2016/17 he was on world class form he scored 24 goals and 10 assists. So by any case Varane is coming of a worse patch than Alexis.
We can only hope Varane recovers his form with us.
Arsenal dumped a sack of shit on United. Good business for Arsenal and getting rid of Alexis, but there is no planet in which it can be persuasively argued that United was shrewd in taking Arsenal's problem child off your hands. This isn't just 20/20 hindsight...there really was a constituency here which questioned the wisdom of that signing.
As for Varane, one never can be completely sure of what a new player will bring. Regardless of how decorated is, he may be -- see Di Maria, among others -- but there's every reason to believe that a player of his consistently high caliber over the last decade will improve United in an area where we needed improvement. But we shall see what to pass. Jose not only brought in Alexis, who was already in horror form before we got him, but he brought in Pogba who never really ticked the right boxes consistently for United and he brought in Lindelof, who just hasn't measured up and needs to be upgraded on. Both Pogba and Lindelof came to us with high marks, but most United supporters are in agreement that neither have lived up to their potential, at least in a United shirt.