Ratings vs Chelsea

WR

Frankie Barwell ITK
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
15,574
Location
Well done he’s 13
VDS - 8

O'Shea - 7
Vidic - 7.5
Evans - 7
Fabio - 6.5

Scholes - 9 - MOTM
Carrick - 7.5
Park - 6
Valencia - 8

Owen - 6
Rooney - 7.5

SUBS -

Berba - 7
Hernandez - 7.5
Smalling - 6
Fletcher - 6
Nani - 7
Giggs - 6
 

wade

Full Member
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
346
Location
USA
VDS- 8

O'Shea- 7
Vidic- 8
Evans- 7 while he was in the center, 5 once he was shifted out wide
Fabio- 6

Scholes- 9
Carrick- 7
Park- 6
Valencia- 8

Rooney-7
Owen- 6

Subs:
Hernandez- 7
Berbatov- 8
Smalling- 5
Fletcher- 6
Giggs- I don't remember him doing anything upon coming on?
Nani- 6
 

Cina

full member
Joined
Aug 10, 2007
Messages
50,911
VDS - 7 - Sloppy at times, brilliant at others.

O'Shea - 7 - Solid as usual.
Vidic - 7 - Beast
Evans - 6.5 - Good at CB, poor at LB.
Fabio - 6 - Young and learnin'

Scholes - 9 - Best midfielder the Premiership has ever had. Legend. MoTM
Carrick - 7 - Played well, looked confident.
Park - 5.5 - Invisible
Valencia - 8 - Class. Made a fool out of the worlds best Left Back.

Owen - 5 - Invisible
Rooney - 7 - Good. Magical assist.

SUBS -

Berbatov - 7 - Great goal, looked confident.
Hernandez - 7 - Looks the business, and his goal had me in stitches :D
Smalling - 6 - Meh
Fletcher - 6 - Didn't spend long enough on the pitch.
Nani - 7 - Brilliant assist, looked menacing.
 

RonaldoVII

Full Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2008
Messages
24,270
Location
PSN:FrozenInHell
VDS - 8

O'Shea - 7
Vidic - 7.5
Evans - 7
Fabio - 6.5

Scholes - 9 - MOTM
Carrick - 7.5
Park - 6.5
Valencia - 7.5

Owen - 6.5
Rooney - 7.5

SUBS -

Berba - 7.5
Hernandez - 7.5
Smalling - 6
Fletcher - 6
Giggs 6
Nani - 7
 

kiristao

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
4,654
Location
Goa, India
VDS - 8 Brilliant few saves.

O'Shea - 6 A couple of good interceptions but looked out of sorts overall
Vidic - 8 Looked good in the middle but looks very average when he has to go to the sides to cover for a LB/RB
Evans - 7 Looked better at CB then at LB
Fabio - 7 Positionally suspect but did quite well considering he got no support from Park

Scholes - 9 - MOTM. Ran the show. Chelsea gave him too much time and space though.
Carrick - 7.5 The best I have seen him play in a very long time
Park - 6 Very poor, Specially defensively where he generally does a very good job.
Valencia - 8 Should have done better with his crosses. GOod movement for the goal

Owen - 6.5 Hardly got a chance
Rooney - 7.5 Great movement and assist for the goal

SUBS -

Berba - 7 Good determination, movement and a peach of a finish
Hernandez - 7.5 Great movement and touch. Dodgy finish but glad to see him score on debut
Smalling - 6 Looked a little nervous
Fletcher - 6 Didnt have to do much
Nani - 7 Took too long to pass the ball a few times but got 2 good assists.
 

barros

Correctly predicted Portugal to win Euro 2016
Joined
Mar 8, 2004
Messages
8,638
Location
Where liberty dwells, there is my country
VDS - 8.5

O'Shea - 7
Vidic - 7
Evans - 7
Fabio - 6.5

Scholes - 9 - MOTM
Carrick - 7.5
Park - 6
Valencia - 7.5

Owen - 6.5
Rooney - 7

SUBS -

Berba - 7.5
Hernandez - 6.5
Smalling - 6
Fletcher - 6
Nani - 7.5
 

nemanja15

Full Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2008
Messages
4,408
Location
Amidst squeaky bums.
van der Sar - 8

O'Shea - 7
J Evans - 7
Vidic - 8
Fabio - 6

Valencia - 8
Carrick - 7
Scholes - 8
Park - 6

Rooney - 7
Owen - 6

SUBS:
Nani - 7
Berbatov - 7
Hernandez - 7
Smalling - 6
Giggs - 6
Fletcher - 6
 

johnmufc

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
4,521
van der Sar: 8 - Made some quality saves.

O'Shea: 6 - Rather sloppy defensively.
Vidic: 7 - Solid.
Evans: 6 - Good as a centre-back, awful as a left-back.
Fabio: 6 - Encouraging performance against a quality team.

Valencia: 8 - Fantastic. Effective.
Carrick: 8 - He's back.
Scholes: 9 - Flawless passing.
Park: 5 - Heavy touch.

Rooney: 7 - Looked sharp. Good vision.
Owen: 5 - Rusty.


Berbatov: 7 - Class.
Hernandez: 7 - Great movement.
Nani: 7 - Good.
Smalling: 5 - Raw.
Giggs: 6 - Bloody.
Fletcher: 6 - Scottish.
 

Utd heap

Models for Coin.
Joined
Aug 15, 2006
Messages
21,604
VDS - 6.5, good shot stopping, but shaky on the odd cross, and confusing.

O'Shea - 6, Can't pass for shit.
Evans - 7, unlucky to be shifted to LB, but solid beforehand.
Vidic - 7.5, initially looked a bit out-muscled, but recovered and was beastly.
Fabio - 6.5, looked better defensively than Rafael.

Valencia - 7, slow start, but came in to the game and influenced it.
Scholes - 9, Ridiculous.
Carrick - 8, Looked back to the form of two seasons back, perhaps the break has done him good?
Park - 6, a bit shit really.

Rooney - 7, another slow starter, but when he raised his game so did we.
Owen - 5, may aswell of not been there, and will hopefully be 4th choice.

Subs:
Nani - 6, good assist but average otherwise.
Hernandez - 7.5, good link up play, and assisted his own goal.
Berbatov - 7, Standard Berbatov, silky.
 

Burak1878

Full Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2001
Messages
1,670
Location
Antalya
VDS - 8 Great saves, couldn't do anything with Chelsea goal.

O'Shea - 7 was ok at RB.
Vidic - 7.5 made terrific challenges. played well.
Evans - 7 dealt with Chelsea strikers but on the wide struggled.
Fabio - 7 run fast and stoped Kalou well.

Scholes - 9 - Man of the match. Superb passing and challenges in the midfield.
Carrick - 7.5 - was quiet this afternoon, though made some good tackles.
Park - 6 - not his best afternoon.
Valencia - 8 had an excellent game.

Owen - 5.5 was also very quiet. I was expecting more from him.
Rooney - 7 worked hard and played well.

SUBS

Berba - 7.5 good touching and score.. should be more active with Hernandez.
Hernandez - 8 excellent debut! more to come im sure.
Smalling - 6 needs more time.
Fletcher - 6 played ok.
Nani - 7 fantastic winger. unlucky didn't score today.
Giggs - 6 nothing too much to judge his performance.
 

Raees

Pythagoras in Boots
Joined
May 16, 2009
Messages
29,470
First X1:

VDS - 8: Excellent contribution, flawless distribution and great handling/shot stopping for the most part, unlucky with the goal.

O'Shea - 7: A good solid performance, at times caught out of position surprisingly for him but sound usually nonetheless. Decent distribution, hit and miss.. but he struck gold with that ball in behind Ashley Cole for Valencia.

Vidic - 7.5: Looks far more settled now that the contract saga is behind him and marshalled the troops well, nice to see him lifting the shield too:devil:.

Evans - 7.5: Looked at ease throughout and kept errors to a minimum, him and Vidic will form the bedrock for our title campaign and I'm glad we have such an able deputy in Jonny.

Fabio - 6: I just don't get the hype with this lad with regards to the left back position, he's good at tackling, but positionally suspect and he looks very awkward when the ball runs to his left foot.. which is surprising as he is supposed to be the two-footed brother. Can't wait for Evra to be back.

Scholes - 9(MOTM):. Flawless, struggled abit in the second half when him and Carrick were being overrun but whenever they actually had the ball, they oozed quality with Scholes at the forefront of anything positive we produced.

Carrick - 7.5: Credit where its due, thats much better from Carrick, actually being positive with the ball, please maintain this level of confidence against the better teams.

Park - 5.5: Don't like seeing him start for us in the big games, always a negative move for my liking.. especially out wide, he just blunts our penetration and I'd like Valencia and Nani used for the majority of the season even against the most dangerous of teams.

Valencia - 8: Off the ball movement very good, but I thought his general play was decent rather than spectacular... needs to add more arrows to his bow and show more variety in his play when up against top quality full backs.

Owen - 5.5: Struggled to get into the game, not helped with the lack of service.

Rooney - 7: Good assist, generally kept it simple, can do much better.

SUBS:

Berba - 7.5: Oozed quality. Drifted deep and picked the ball up, constantly trying to drive us forward albeit in his trademark sloth-like manner.. but very effective against Chelsea's sloth-like defence. He dovetailed well with Hernandez and seem pleased to be surrounded by such pace, which allowed him to operate in alot of space.

Hernandez - 7.5: Constant menace. Perfect partner for Berba, crazy finish.. but it was his general play which caught the eye.. cheeky through ball to Berba which was unlucky and just showed great intelligence off the ball.

Smalling - 6: Hard to judge, good to see him though.

Fletcher - 6:Just coasting through to the end.

Nani - 7: Horny little cameo with a splattering of tricks and an excellent through ball for Berba.

Giggs - Lifetime achievement: Deserves a 10 just for making so many appearances at the community shield.
 

Sassy Colin

Death or the gladioli!
Joined
Jan 29, 2010
Messages
71,278
Location
Aliens are in control of my tagline & location
Charity Sheild - random thoughts...

Right, this is not a ratings thread but just some of my random thoughts and doesn't include all of those who took part today.

SAF - Involved all the main players for this season as well as the new signings.

VDS - A rock, difficult to blame him for the goal, he saved the first effort but had no chance for the rebound. His kick out prior to the goal possibly suspect, he's going to be a hard act to replace next season.

Smalling - No issues as far as I could see. That clearance header just after he came on was immense!

Fabio - Impressed with his first half performance, a fine understudy for Evra.

Scholes - The Master! What are we going to do when he retires? WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO WHEN HE RETIRES?



Alright...I'm calm...I'm calm...

But seriously, although VDS, Neville, Giggs are replaceable, ultimately, who is there who can really replace Scholes? Cleverley?

Carrick - Did well, calm on the ball, good distribution.

Rooney - I'm sure he'll have a good season.

Nani - Right, although he didn't do a great deal today, I can't help getting excited every time he touches the ball...

Little pea - Great start to the season, hope he keeps it up.

Berba - Was going to say that he had started the season the way he ended the last, but then that goal. I'm desperate for him to reproduce the form he had at Spurs, just hope this is a portent of things to come.
 

MG

Full Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2008
Messages
11,811
Location
Friendzoning 'nice guys'
VDS - 7 - good shot stopping, maybe a couple of dodgy moments.

O'Shea - 6 - Meh.
Evans - 7 - Good before he was shifted out wide.
Vidic - 7.5 - A bit left behind at first but got much better.
Fabio - 6.5 - Some very important interceptions, mingled in with some other worrying moments. But he's still yong and lernin'.

Valencia - 8 - Out-ran Cole, gave him a bit of a torrid time, and took his goal well.
Scholes - 9 - Out of this world. His pass to Rooney before the first goal... well, if I was a bloke I would have jizzed.
Carrick - 8 - Very good, which was a pleasant surprise. Some nice tackling and passing. Lets hope this could be a sign of him returning to the form of the seasons before last.
Park - 6 - lightweight. Lost the ball too often.

Rooney - 7 - started slow, but great pass for Valencia's goal and some other good moments
Owen - 5 - Anonymous

Subs:
Hernandez - 7.5 - Some nice touches, hilarious goal. Looks like a girl.
Berbatov - 7 - Silky, showy, very slick goal... usual Berbatov.
Nani - 6 - good assist but not enough time.
Giggs - 5 - Bloody nose. I'd still marry him though.

Park's hair - What was THAT all about??!
 

MUFAN79

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2007
Messages
6,158
Location
Tuzla, Bosnia
VDS - 8,5

O'Shea - 7,5
Vidic - 7.5
Evans - 7
Fabio - 6.5

Scholes - 9 - Incredible display by Scholesy !
Carrick - 7.5
Park - 6
Valencia - 8

Owen - 6
Rooney - 7.5

SUBS -

Berba - 7
Hernandez - 7.5
Smalling - 6
Fletcher - 6
Nani - 7
Giggs - 6
 

Cold_Boy

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Messages
20,095
Location
London
VDS - 8

O'Shea - 7
Vidic - 7
Evans - 7
Fabio - 7

Scholes - 9
Carrick - 7
Park - 6
Valencia - 7

Owen - 6
Rooney - 7

SUBS -

Berba - 7
Hernandez - 7
Smalling - 5
Fletcher - 6
Nani - 6