Russian invasion of Ukraine | Fewer tweets, more discussion

carvajal

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2015
Messages
11,089
Location
Spain
Supports
Real Madrid
The only thing I'd disagree with about the contents of that thread is the comment that for the Russians "... time is likely on their side if they are will to endure the punishing sanctions and casualties".

Time is not on their side IMO. There are questions over how long they can finance their campaign at a huge cost per day, plus there will be growing unrest inside Russia over sanctions biting and troops arriving back in coffins, and all the while more defensive weapons and pro-Ukrainian fighters pour into the country.
but if you were a very nationalistic russian patriot, or a non-nationalist but caught up in that propaganda, you would think "how bad is the ruble, let's go home" or you would continue, even more convinced that together they want to end Russia, trying their weapons against your poor soldiers.
Maybe they would be willing to call reservists, volunteers and send everything they have. Maybe in another country it wouldn't happen but I imagine them prepared to accept (by hook or by crook) the absolute shit as long as they don't give up.
 

sport2793

Full Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
3,170
Location
USA
The only thing I'd disagree with about the contents of that thread is the comment that for the Russians "... time is likely on their side if they are will to endure the punishing sanctions and casualties".

Time is not on their side IMO. There are questions over how long they can finance their campaign at a huge cost per day, plus there will be growing unrest inside Russia over sanctions biting and troops arriving back in coffins, and all the while more defensive weapons and pro-Ukrainian fighters pour into the country.
Ya to be fair I don't think Michael Kofman himself necessarily agrees with everything in the thread (based on what he said on the twitter space yesterday where at the moment he thinks this may end like the First Chechen War and that it will be hard for the Putin regime to survive this conflict), just saying that it's fair to state that it's hard to know what the balance of forces are currently without knowing how many casualties and losses of equipment the Ukrainians have suffered. With that said, the US again reiterated today that the Ukranian military still retains a significant amount of their pre-war air assets, which is ridiculous as these should have been eliminated in the first 24-72 hours.
 

sport2793

Full Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
3,170
Location
USA
but if you were a very nationalistic russian patriot, or a non-nationalist but caught up in that propaganda, you would think "how bad is the ruble, let's go home" or you would continue, even more convinced that together they want to end Russia, trying their weapons again your poor soldiers.
Maybe they would be willing to call reservists, volunteers and send everything they have. Maybe in another country it wouldn't happen but I imagine them prepared to accept (by hook or by crook) the absolute shit as long as they don't give up.
I think it comes down to the number of casualties that Russian forces suffer and if/when the population starts to see the impact. You will always have hard-liners in the population but there is a lot of precedence for the Russian people to turn on a government if a war is going bad. I'm talking about the 80s/90s, you don't have to go back to the early 20th century to see examples.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Not sure a revanchist Japan is really what we need in this world.
I think its all part of a coordinated attack by the West. Now Putin cant spare as many resources as he had originally planned for Ukraine.
F-35s sent up to the Baltic, two B52s circling around Romania, near the Ukrainian border and now this?

That train of tanks from Vladivostok that was heading towards Ukraine may have to turn around now.

Wars cost money. The West will try and bleed Putin out financially before he gets to achieve any of his goals. The only thing he would have achieved in the end will be re-creating the USSR 2.0 economy. Flat ass broke.
 

RedDevilQuebecois

Full Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Messages
8,121
Not sure a revanchist Japan is really what we need in this world.
The Kuril Islands have been invaded by the USSR and after Japan announced its surrender in August 1945. By definition, you could say that the Soviets violated a ceasefire prior to the formal surrender that would come on September 2. The last legal treaty regarding specific control of the islands was the Treaty of Saint Petersburg (1875), in which the eighteen islands north of Uruppu were ceded to Japan while all of Sakhalin is Russian. If anyone was revanchist, it was the Soviets only because their forebears were humiliated in the Russo-Japanese War. That and unfaithful translations in the Treaty of San Francisco are the reasons why Japan never wanted to sign a formal peace treaty with the USSR nor Russia to cede the Kuril Islands.

For the record, the Okinawa prefecture was under American control between 1945 and 1972. There comes a time when it's better for a country with little or no historical business in a region to let it go.
 

nimic

something nice
Scout
Joined
Aug 2, 2006
Messages
31,440
Location
And I'm all out of bubblegum.
The Kuril Islands have been invaded by the USSR and after Japan announced its surrender in August 1945. By definition, you could say that the Soviets violated a ceasefire prior to the formal surrender that would come on September 2. The last legal treaty regarding specific control of the islands was the Treaty of Saint Petersburg (1875), in which the eighteen islands north of Uruppu were ceded to Japan while all of Sakhalin is Russian. If anyone was revanchist, it was the Soviets only because their forebears were humiliated in the Russo-Japanese War. That and unfaithful translations in the Treaty of San Francisco are the reasons why Japan never wanted to sign a formal peace treaty with the USSR nor Russia to cede the Kuril Islands.

For the record, the Okinawa prefecture was under American control between 1945 and 1972. There comes a time when it's better for a country with little or no historical business in a region to let it go.
The thing about revanchism is that it doesn't always matter who is right or wrong. Were the French right to be revanchist over Alsace-Lorraine after the Franco-Prussian War? Probably. But it's still a contributing cause of WW1.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Interviews of Moscovites after the war/special operations started:


* the couple interviewed is pretty funny. A comedy act esp the guy.

 

frostbite

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2021
Messages
3,250
Now we know: Russia’s horrific past could become our future under Putin

Dmitry Glukhovsky

Dmitry Glukhovsky is a Russian novelist and journalist. This article was first published by Novaya Gazeta in Russia

[ In October 2021, Novaya Gazeta's editor-in-chief Dmitry Muratov was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, alongside Maria Ressa, for their safeguarding of freedom of expression in their homelands. ]


https://www.theguardian.com/comment...ias-past-future-under-putin-soviet-repression
 

We need an rvn

Full Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2015
Messages
3,871
Location
Down south...somewhere
:lol: :lol: :lol: The fact that they lost encrypted communications is amazing. I've seen a few pics of dubious origin of Russian pilots with Garmins for use as GPS in their planes, but there do seem to be more stories about the shoddy comms equipment the Russians are using more broadly. Hopefully the Ukrainians captured some of the secure comms equipment as well so it can be used against the Russians.


Just thinking out loud here, but seems odd they someone would design a system like this and not think that through? Could western cyber hacking be partly responsible for this? Sure the US could shut down most networks and systems should they want to do so
 

Beans

Full Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2019
Messages
3,514
Location
Midwest, USA
Supports
Neutral
The Trilogy looms

All costs? Not sure any concession is worth all.

At this point Putin would accept only the seperatist regions and Crimea, before he has to retreat back to those areas anyway.

At that point Ukraine will militarize the border with those regions with equipment and materials sent from from all over the world, exactly what Russia didn't want.

Before this NATO was asleep, Germany had no army. Next time his army intervenes somewhere like Kazakhstan or Georgia it will likely be world news and bring more sanctions.

I thought Russia not paying foreign bond holders was a smart move, as far as some way they can retaliate. I'm sure they'll find some ways to make the West hurt a bit. You'd think they'd refuse to sell fuel to Europe, even if only for a few days to generate headlines. They might need the money too badly for such a stunt.
 

youmeletsfly

New Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2018
Messages
2,528
Just thinking out loud here, but seems odd they someone would design a system like this and not think that through? Could western cyber hacking be partly responsible for this? Sure the US could shut down most networks and systems should they want to do so
I work in cybersecurity and I can definitely confirm that anyone and their dog can hack most networks and systems should they want to do so, not only the US.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
Before this NATO was asleep, Germany had no army. Next time his army intervenes somewhere like Kazakhstan or Georgia it will likely be world news and bring more sanctions.
I don't think EU or NATO would intervene (militarily) in anything that happens in Kazakhstan (in particular) or Georgia though. Especially the EU has no reach there. NATO via Turkey might, but only barely and it'll again be a case of Russia being far more willing to raise the stakes than anyone in the West would be. Kazakhstan is part of the CSTO organisation too.
 

Mickeza

still gets no respect
Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
14,109
Location
Deepthroating information to Howard Nurse.
Interesting polling about the shift in opinion on the war within Russia. Very small sample size but still gives a bit of hope that the propaganda is no longer sticking. FYI - It doesn’t mention anything about Iraq.

 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
Now if only we could also take a few thousand Ukrainian refugees, instead of like 50, that would be nice. Not that I have any real expectations from our Home Office and Priti Patel though.
 
Last edited:

The Corinthian

I will not take Mad Winger's name in vain
Joined
Dec 10, 2020
Messages
11,848
Supports
A Free Palestine
Chaos, upheaval and exhaustion for Ukraine's disabled children

They had been travelling for thirty hours already. There were many hours ahead. The bus to the Polish border was a capsule of exhaustion, grief and tender mercies. Carers hugged the frightened children and whispered soothing sounds. It was not a time or place for words. There were none that could have explained the madness engulfing the world of the children from Kharkiv's Hippocrates Care Centre. They were aged between one and three and all were disabled, with serious medical conditions.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-60648735


:(
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
Shameful. The Ukrainians are being bombed and killed, but we can't handle minor inconveniences.
It's ironic because we always proclaim that no price can be put on human life, but we do constantly do it.

However, if the EU were to embargo Russian Oil/Gas it would take a very big financial hit that would affect lower social strata and poorer countries the most and it would require an expensive coordinated response. It's not just about Germany alone here and it's not just about inconveniences.

Think about what happens to the poorest members in Southern, Eastern and Balkan Europe when the price of oil and gas blows up. What happens in Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria. Slovakia, Greece etc. when the energy bills start to cost more than what people bring home each month. That's not just a minor inconvenience.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
8,112
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
Interesting polling about the shift in opinion on the war within Russia. Very small sample size but still gives a bit of hope that the propaganda is no longer sticking. FYI - It doesn’t mention anything about Iraq.


Out of curiosity, how can he contact the world from his jail cell? There were a bunch of calls to action by him already. I imagine he's generally isolated but talks to his family and friends who then publish it. But I can't imagine he won't be punished for this type of stuff?
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow

Any chance something like this going on? That Generals are telling Putin, everything is okay, just minor hiccups.

I've read that Putin is very isolated, not even having a smartphone.

@harms do you think something like this is possible?
First of all, even the original thread is very speculative to say the least (including misquoting the only direct quote that he includes). It’s incredibly hard to properly reconstruct what was happening at the beginning of the Great Patriotic War (Hitler’s invasion of Russia), as all sources are extremely biased towards themselves, but Galeev’s version is extremely far-fetched.

As for Putin, we’ll never know. He doesn’t have a smartphone or a direct internet access (willingly), so he’s extremely reliant on the rigid chain that updates him with information, but I doubt that anyone would dare to significantly alter the real numbers/situation — if anything, lying to Putin has to be scarier than telling him disappointing truth. Obviously all of the info would be slightly altered to fit the narrative better, but I doubt that it would be completely altered. And you have to understand that the guys that supply Putin with info (FSB & FSS) aren’t military, so Putin’s anger won’t be directed at them.

As the apparent FSB informant said, they were only bullshitting on the potential projections of a future war as no one thought that it was a realistic perspective — so they’ve focused their analysis on different scenarios. Now, when the war is in action, it’s a different point.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow
Out of curiosity, how can he contact the world from his jail cell? There were a bunch of calls to action by him already. I imagine he's generally isolated but talks to his family and friends who then publish it. But I can't imagine he won't be punished for this type of stuff?
Through his lawyers or through his wife, yes, when they get visits. Plus, I’d imagine, he has some stuff pre-written for certain scenarios.

He probably gets punished for that but he gets punished for literally anything including no reason at all, so it’s hardly changing anything for him.

Edit: this particular series of tweets look like the work of his team entirely, I doubt that Navalny had anything to do with it, except for probably approving the initial idea.
 

sun_tzu

The Art of Bore
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
19,536
Location
Still waiting for the Youthquake
Through his lawyers or through his wife, yes, when they get visits. Plus, I’d imagine, he has some stuff pre-written for certain scenarios.

He probably gets punished for that but he gets punished for literally anything including no reason at all, so it’s hardly changing anything for him.
surprised hes not fallen down the stairs and had a fatal accident where the back of his head lands on a bullet than just happened to fall from a guards pistol who was trying to catch him