Russian invasion of Ukraine | Fewer tweets, more discussion

TMDaines

Fun sponge.
Joined
Sep 1, 2014
Messages
13,999
Through his lawyers or through his wife, yes, when they get visits. Plus, I’d imagine, he has some stuff pre-written for certain scenarios.

He probably gets punished for that but he gets punished for literally anything including no reason at all, so it’s hardly changing anything for him.

Edit: this particular series of tweets look like the work of his team entirely, I doubt that Navalny had anything to do with it, except for probably approving the initial idea.
It is also worth emphasising that he has a whole team working in his name in exile.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow
Does anyone even live there?
Around 18000 people. It’s not news though, Japan & Russia both claim that theory as theirs for decades and we don’t even have an active peace treaty for them — de jure it’s probably the longest current war in existence.
 

TMDaines

Fun sponge.
Joined
Sep 1, 2014
Messages
13,999
:lol:

To be fair if Zelenskey survives this (and im pretty sure putin will be trying everything from thermobaric bombs to polonium tea to ensure he doesnt) hes going to be a real player in world politics as I cant think of any leader around the world who commands more personal respect
That’s not Zelenskyy.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow
surprised hes not fallen down the stairs and had a fatal accident where the back of his head lands on a bullet than just happened to fall from a guards pistol who was trying to catch him
Yeah, at this point it’s not like Putin’s public image would take any damage from that :(
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow
It is also worth emphasising that he has a whole team working in his name in exile.
Yeah, I posted this before looking at the tweets and thought that this was one of his personal addresses that he gives through his lawyer or wife, but this is the work of his team that has access to all of his social media.
 

Maticmaker

Full Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2018
Messages
4,695
That's not the real issue at all. NATO was set up to defend against (not oppose) the Soviet Union
Not if you view it from the standpoint of a Russian Dictator, from that position NATO is presented as a (convenient) sort of 'boogieman' figure to frighten the people with. The closer the 'boogieman comes', (and Ukraine is damned close from that perspective) then your reason for taking action becomes easier to justify inside Russia. Short of starting WW3, Putin will not be stopped by outsiders, the only really possibility to stop him is for his own people to realise what kind of a future he is storing up for Russia with the rest of the world.

Unfortunately Putin has had decades (and sometimes perhaps with unwitting support from the West) to as it were 'salt' the organs of power in Russia, be that political, militarily, economically, with his own people/supporters and right at the top sit a number of the so called oligarchs, these initially are the only ones even capable of exerting any sort of pressure/sense on Putin.

The worry for them, and the rest of the world, is that Putin intends to go down 'all guns blazing'.
 

sun_tzu

The Art of Bore
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
19,536
Location
Still waiting for the Youthquake
Yeah, at this point it’s not like Putin’s public image would take any damage from that :(
Exactly... perhaps hes going to go full north korea and stick in front of an anti aircraft gun

Would be very surprised if he survived even the first murmurs of any popular uprising though ... I suspect the coup of 91 would have played out differently without yeltsin and im sure putin has learned at least that lesson from history
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,029
Location
Moscow
Interviews of Moscovites after the war/special operations started:


* the couple interviewed is pretty funny. A comedy act esp the guy.

Probably not the most relevant demographics to be fair as he’s shooting next to a university (Russian State University for the Humanities) with mostly students that also study history & other humanitarian disciplines (I’d hazard a guess that the channel’s owner is probably a student there). I’d imagine that the anti-war sentiment in that demographic would extremely high — probably even above 90%, but it’s not the same in general population. Haven’t seen the second video though.
 

Smores

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
25,532
It's ironic because we always proclaim that no price can be put on human life, but we do constantly do it.

However, if the EU were to embargo Russian Oil/Gas it would take a very big financial hit that would affect lower social strata and poorer countries the most and it would require an expensive coordinated response. It's not just about Germany alone here and it's not just about inconveniences.

Think about what happens to the poorest members in Southern, Eastern and Balkan Europe when the price of oil and gas blows up. What happens in Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria. Slovakia, Greece etc. when the energy bills start to cost more than what people bring home each month. That's not just a minor inconvenience.
Indeed, I'm sure their impact assessments are pretty grim if the embargo went forward. Millions thrown into poverty, pensions hit, associated overall poverty and fuel poverty leading to deaths.

You've got to weigh that up against the impact it would actually have on Russia and in turn Ukraine. It's easy to shout down something that looks like a lack of support from a position of complete ignorance about its effectiveness and impacts.
 

youmeletsfly

New Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2018
Messages
2,528
Wow, really? So cybersecurity is just a pipe dream? I always thought it takes a genius to hack some site. Damn.
Cybersecurity works if companies spend money for passive and active(most expensive) measures. You'd be amazed how many big companies still use old and not secure operating systems, certificates, storage etc.
 

Rightnr

Wants players fined for winning away.
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
14,308
Shameful. The Ukrainians are being bombed and killed, but we can't handle minor inconveniences.
I get the sentiment but people in Western nations sometimes forget their poor is not really the same as poor nations' poor.

By that I mean that having such high energy costs literally means no heating for a lot of people (most even) and that can also lead to political extremism and division which serves Putin yet again. High energy costs could also lead to firms closing, so no jobs. We are literally talking about 5-10x increase in costs which is monumental.

It's just not as simple as people make it out to be. The real bad decision was relying on Russia in the first place without contingencies. Now, you're at their beck and call, at least in the very short term.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Probably not the most relevant demographics to be fair as he’s shooting next to a university (Russian State University for the Humanities) with mostly students that also study history & other humanitarian disciplines (I’d hazard a guess that the channel’s owner is probably a student there). I’d imagine that the anti-war sentiment in that demographic would extremely high — probably even above 90%, but it’s not the same in general population. Haven’t seen the second video though.
But at least we know its not monolithic and not everyone has bought into the propaganda. As they say, the kids are our future. Teach them well and let the lead the way.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Wow, really? So cybersecurity is just a pipe dream? I always thought it takes a genius to hack some site. Damn.
A friend of mine used to work for the NSA. He claims he can hack into ny bank's system within 20-30mins. And as a result, is paranoid too. He does any/all financial transactions using a virtual machine within his linux pc.
 

onemanarmy

Full Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
4,712
Location
Belgium
Wow, really? So cybersecurity is just a pipe dream? I always thought it takes a genius to hack some site. Damn.
Even if you invest a lot of money in cybersecurity, there are bound to be vulnerabilities. If you are targeted by a hacking collective, you can hope they don't get in. If you are targeted by countries that are known for hacking such as Russia, you can forget about it.
 

Sphaero

Struggling to explain his genius to the hoi polloi
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
4,620
Location
Potsdam, Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
It's ironic because we always proclaim that no price can be put on human life, but we do constantly do it.

However, if the EU were to embargo Russian Oil/Gas it would take a very big financial hit that would affect lower social strata and poorer countries the most and it would require an expensive coordinated response. It's not just about Germany alone here and it's not just about inconveniences.

Think about what happens to the poorest members in Southern, Eastern and Balkan Europe when the price of oil and gas blows up. What happens in Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria. Slovakia, Greece etc. when the energy bills start to cost more than what people bring home each month. That's not just a minor inconvenience.
It goes far beyond that for Germany aswell which is why they are so hesitant to sign off on a full on gas/oil embargo, the hardest economic sanction they could deliver. That would be an incredibly hot double edged sword that might deliver the killing blow to the remnants of the Russian economy but it would also cut deeply into their own economy.

A lot of people connect such an embargo just with higher costs to heat homes or run their cars or price hikes for a lot of goods, but the brunt of this embargo would not be felt by the households, but the industrial sectors of the country. This is where the majority of Russian gas and oil goes to and if they stop importing these ressources it won´t be long until the factories stand still. Keep that up long enough and whole supply chains (which are already compromised by the the other sanctions) will choke up leading to massive trouble for the suppliers of parts, which are majorly specialised businesses of the "Mittelstand", the backbone of the economy.

People can by all means advocate for doing that if they believe that this is the necessary step but they should be aware of the full consequences of it: a deep recession and damage to a stable but struggling economy that is still recovering from Covid, a lot of bankruptcies of smaller busineses and a large number of layoffs. Let´s see how long the solidarity for the Ukrainian people and tolerance of the three million strong Russian population lasts when that war will be the reason for losing their livelihoods.

The problems would not be contained inside the country aswell. Putin was rightfully accused of trying to destabilise the European Union, but there are few things that would be more damaging to the stability of the Union than a severly damaged German economy. Germany has been the biggest economical profiteer of the EU but it is also by far the biggest net payer and in times of crisis it was the robustness of its economy that build the spine and held it together. You bring Germanys ecomomy to its knees and a lot of smaller less richer countries will follow. This whole thing is a damn mess.
 
Last edited:

Drifter

American
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
68,363
CNN's Fareed Zakaria Rejects Idea Of 'White Double Standard' In Ukraine Coverage


Usually agree with Fareed, but he is wrong here
 

Suv666

Full Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2016
Messages
8,767
Wow, really? So cybersecurity is just a pipe dream? I always thought it takes a genius to hack some site. Damn.
I was interested in Cybersecurity during college but didn't pursue it because there were hardly any jobs. Most companies under invest in security.
 

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
It's just not as simple as people make it out to be. The real bad decision was relying on Russia in the first place without contingencies. Now, you're at their beck and call, at least in the very short term.
It was the best option at the time in terms of weighing up costs, going more green (reducing dependence to the more greenhouse gas emitting burning of coal/lignite) and the NIMBY effect in democracies when it comes to building power plants. We're saying what we're saying with quite a lot of hindsight now. I certainly hold my hand up in not expecting the situation with Russia to blow up 10 years ago.

But I hope this becomes a wake up call for Europe in terms of the need to become self-dependent in the future. It will take a lot of investment and time, but for Europe to prosper long term it be needs to self-sufficient when it comes to energy, security, manufacturing and staple foods/water. The latter are not really a concern but we have had a long history of dependence on US/NATO for protection and Russia or Middle East for energy.

We're always happy to spend money on weapons on this continent, so I have no doubt we can become self-dependent security wise. But wrt to energy we'll need a big investment drive for both renewable energy and a backbone of nuclear power until fusion becomes viable. But that discussion is for another thread.
 
Last edited:

MadMike

Full Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
11,612
Location
London
It goes far beyond that for Germany as well which is why they are so hesitant to sign off on a full on gas/oil embargo, the hardest economic sanction they could deliver. That would be an incredibly hot double edged sword that might deliver the killing blow to the remnants of the Russian economy but it would also cut deeply into their own economy.

A lot of people connect such an embargo just with higher costs to heat homes or run their cars or price hikes for a lot of goods, but the brunt of this embargo would not be felt by the households, but the industrial sectors of the country. This is where the majority of Russian gas and oil goes to and if they stop importing these resources it won´t be long until the factories stand still. Keep that up long enough and whole supply chains (which are already compromised by the the other sanctions) will choke up leading to massive trouble for the suppliers of parts, which are majorly specialised businesses of the "Mittelstand", the backbone of the economy.

People can by all means advocate for doing that if they believe that this is the necessary step but they should be aware of the full consequences of it: a deep recession and damage to a stable but struggling economy that is still recovering from Covid, a lot of bankruptcies of smaller businesses and a large number of layoffs. Let´s see how long the solidarity for the Ukrainian people and tolerance of the three million strong Russian population lasts when that war will be the reason for losing their livelihoods.

The problems would not be contained inside the country as well. Putin was rightfully accused of trying to destabilise the European Union, but there are few things that would be more damaging to the stability of the Union than a severely damaged German economy. Germany has been the biggest economical profiteer of the EU but it is also by far the biggest net payer and in times of crisis it was the robustness of its economy that build the spine and held it together. You bring Germanys economy to its knees and a lot of smaller less richer countries will follow. This whole thing is a damn mess.
I agree. I see the embargo of Russian energy as the economic equivalent of the dropping a nuclear bomb at the moment. It's almost like MAD (mutually assured destruction). Yes it will bring the Russian economy to its knees, but equally it will create an incredible amount of hardship in Europe as well. It goes well beyond minor inconvenience. And I'm not sure the democracies will handle that very well, we'll see both a lot of poverty and a lot of political extremism that could erode Europe from within.
 

Zlatattack

New Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Messages
7,374
So how did UK vote against stopping Russian gas then? I though the European Parliament didn’t include UK reps?
i can't find the tweet anymore which referenced BJ's position.

Meanwhile at least UK workers have the bollocks to do the right thing.

https://www.theguardian.com/busines...cheshire-dockers-uk-refinery-ship-russian-oil


found it - https://www.theguardian.com/politic...087f6d099f2a37#block-622620238f087f6d099f2a37


Q: Can you say more about your discussions on energy? The US secretary of state says we should consider cutting off Russian oil. Do you agree? And should we have “a climate change pass”, as it has been claimed you favour?


Johnson says you cannot simply close down imports of oil and gas from Russia overnight.


But all countries should be moving in the same direction, he says. And they should accelerate that.


He says he sees no inconsistency between reducing reliance on Russian hydrocarbons and reducing reliance on hydrocarbons altogether.
 

TwoSheds

More sheds (and tiles) than you, probably
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
12,983
It was the best option at the time in terms of weighing up costs, going more green (reducing dependence to the more greenhouse gas emitting burning of coal/lignite) and the NIMBY effect in democracies when it comes to building power plants. We're saying what we're saying with quite a lot of hindsight now. I certainly hold my hand up in not expecting the situation with Russia to blow up 10 years ago.

But I hope this becomes a wake up call for Europe in terms of the need to become self-dependent in the future. It will take a lot of investment and time, but for Europe to prosper long term it be needs to self-sufficient when it comes to energy, security, manufacturing and staple foods/water. The latter are not really a concern but we have had a long history of dependence on US/NATO for protection and Russia or Middle East for energy.

We're always happy to spend money on weapons on this continent, so I have no doubt we can become self-dependent security wise. But wrt to energy we'll need a big investment drive for both renewable energy and a backbone of nuclear power until fusion becomes viable. But that discussion is for another thread.
Neither the economic nor security arguments have made sense for fossil fuels for an awfully long time. Solar has been cheaper than coal and gas for years now in most countries, and wind not far behind. Most European countries' grids could handle much more renewable input even without significant change in storage capacity or management methods. The stupidity and vested interests of billionaires and politicians in the carbon bubble is the only reason we've not taken the energy transition much more seriously. Even now, Germany just announced €100bn for defence and at the same time hailed €2bn as a "massive investment" in renewable energy. And the Greens form part of their coalition.
 
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
22,148
Location
Behind the right goal post as "Whiteside shoots!"
i can't find the tweet anymore which referenced BJ's position.

Meanwhile at least UK workers have the bollocks to do the right thing.

https://www.theguardian.com/busines...cheshire-dockers-uk-refinery-ship-russian-oil


found it - https://www.theguardian.com/politic...087f6d099f2a37#block-622620238f087f6d099f2a37


Q: Can you say more about your discussions on energy? The US secretary of state says we should consider cutting off Russian oil. Do you agree? And should we have “a climate change pass”, as it has been claimed you favour?


Johnson says you cannot simply close down imports of oil and gas from Russia overnight.


But all countries should be moving in the same direction, he says. And they should accelerate that.


He says he sees no inconsistency between reducing reliance on Russian hydrocarbons and reducing reliance on hydrocarbons altogether.
Ok. Just when you said the UK has voted against stopping accepting oil and gas from Russia, I thought there was some formal vote I'd not heard of (not a tweet by The Guardian)
 

hellhunter

Eurofighter
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
18,055
Location
Stuttgart, Germany
Supports
Karlsruher SC

If true, it shows in impressive fashion how no word from Moscow can be trusted and Ukraine are exactly right not to entertain any negotiations with the requirements mentioned yesterday
 

GlastonSpur

Also disliked on an Aston Villa forum
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Messages
17,716
Supports
Spurs
Not if you view it from the standpoint of a Russian Dictator, from that position NATO is presented as a (convenient) sort of 'boogieman' figure to frighten the people with. The closer the 'boogieman comes', (and Ukraine is damned close from that perspective) then your reason for taking action becomes easier to justify inside Russia. Short of starting WW3, Putin will not be stopped by outsiders, the only really possibility to stop him is for his own people to realise what kind of a future he is storing up for Russia with the rest of the world.

Unfortunately Putin has had decades (and sometimes perhaps with unwitting support from the West) to as it were 'salt' the organs of power in Russia, be that political, militarily, economically, with his own people/supporters and right at the top sit a number of the so called oligarchs, these initially are the only ones even capable of exerting any sort of pressure/sense on Putin.

The worry for them, and the rest of the world, is that Putin intends to go down 'all guns blazing'.
I'm not talking about how it's presented to the Russian people, I'm talking about how it actually is for Putin and his cronies - and for them it's all about holding onto power (and thus wealth) by repressing freedom and democracy. This is why they don't want to see a free and democratic Ukraine for fear of the example its sets to the Russian people.
 

Rightnr

Wants players fined for winning away.
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
14,308

If true, it shows in impressive fashion how no word from Moscow can be trusted and Ukraine are exactly right not to entertain any negotiations with the requirements mentioned yesterday
This is the kind of stuff that annoys me when I watch movies and read books.

No way can someone be this evil and yet again reality is less believable than fiction.
 

11101

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
21,315

If true, it shows in impressive fashion how no word from Moscow can be trusted and Ukraine are exactly right not to entertain any negotiations with the requirements mentioned yesterday
I'm curious how complicit the Russian Generals and below are in all this. The guys loading and firing the artillery will not know what is at the end of the coordinates they are given. Do the commanders know the road they're told to attack has been designated as an evacuation route? How far down the chain does the evil stretch?