Should we scout for strikers from lower leagues?

wolvored

Full Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2016
Messages
10,028
We are going into the new season on the hope one striker (who we still havent signed yet) will get the goals we are lacking. As there is no sign of a decent striker to come in from the youth teams who could step up in a year or two should we be looking at the championship or the 'lesser' leagues around Europe for a cheapish backup, say around £30 mill or less. Who could step up from the championship or abroad and improve here?
 

Ronaldinho's snakebite

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 28, 2023
Messages
105
Absolutely. Nicholas Jackson has been impressive for Chelsea so far, and he was bought on the cheap. But some people will say there's no good striker on the market for cheap. I think our scouting team and manager needs to up their game.
 

norm87cro

New Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2017
Messages
1,782
Location
Split, HR
I dont know TBH its worth a go if we have another squad player for a small amount that can bang in 10 to 15 in the league I gess there is no risk in that. Toney was an option in the beggining of last season but I guess his price has gone up by at least 60%
 

Mr Pigeon

Illiterate Flying Rat
Scout
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
26,587
Location
bin
I've been reliably informed by various soccer experts online that Paul Mullin would score more goals than Weghorst, so he's worth a punt?
 

horsechoker

The Caf's Ezza.
Joined
Apr 16, 2015
Messages
53,670
Location
The stable
In theory yes but only a a very small percentage would be able to make the step up. It would be more worthwhile to improve scouting in order to identify potential targets in lower leagues.
 

Trequarista10

Full Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2020
Messages
2,601
Its possible, players like Vardy or Lambert made late moves from lower leagues to PL. I'd imagine we are scouting lower leagues though it's just incredibly rare there'd be someone identifiable as suitable.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
18,511
I don't think it's worth the time, even if you went looking for young talents to develop I think it would be near fruitless.

Football is so professional now you aren't going to find an Ian Wright type player who gets discovered late, all the great strikers (or any position) of the future are going to be playing in the leading academies of the country they're born in, or if they're amazing, getting snapped up by a PL, La Liga, Serie A, BL etc. academy by about 6 or 7 years old. If you want a run of the mill/mid table striker at best, I'm sure some from the Championship or some of the 'lesser' leagues have good players but we want to be a CL club and elite strikers are like gold dust.
 

Chip

Full Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2010
Messages
2,723
I’d be shocked if we didn’t already scout the lower leagues for players including strikers.
 

Smores

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
25,721
I don't think it's worth the time, even if you went looking for young talents to develop I think it would be near fruitless.

Football is so professional now you aren't going to find an Ian Wright type player who gets discovered late, all the great strikers (or any position) of the future are going to be playing in the leading academies of the country they're born in, or if they're amazing, getting snapped up by a PL, La Liga, Serie A, BL etc. academy by about 6 or 7 years old. If you want a run of the mill/mid table striker at best, I'm sure some from the Championship or some of the 'lesser' leagues have good players but we want to be a CL club and elite strikers are like gold dust.
There's been plenty of strikers who have come up from the championship and looked decent enough to be a no 2 striker for us. If we'd have got either Mitrovic, Toney, Watkins, Wilson we'd have been better off and there's plenty more.

Our issue is we're so focused on the expensive elite players and they still don't always work out.
 

Red Comet

Full Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
1,459
I was hoping we could take a look at Ben Brereton since he was available on a free. Could play anywhere across the front and a pretty fast player as well. Not the best, but a decent backup nonetheless.
 

Gopher Brown

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
4,561
I’d be shocked if we didn’t already scout the lower leagues for players including strikers.
I’d be more shocked if we scouted anywhere for players. Our strategy is ‘who used to play for Ajax’ or ‘who has been signed recently for £4m that we can buy for 20x as much?’
 

Mr Waffles

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 6, 2023
Messages
9
Fleetwood Town are my home team and I watch a fair bit of them, including when Vardy was there. At that time it was plain to see that he was MILES above anyone else on the pitch every single week. Even I could have scouted him and tipped him for the Prem.

However, as regular League 1 watcher I can safely say that players at that level are extremely few and far between. It’s not like there is an untapped resource of promising youngsters or somehow overlooked players.

That said, I’d be surprised if our scouting dept weren’t fully aware of any potential recruits from the lower leagues. It’s good to keep your eyes open everywhere, but a lot of these lads have already been at Prem clubs at youth level and didn’t quite make it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jippy

Chip

Full Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2010
Messages
2,723
I’d be more shocked if we scouted anywhere for players. Our strategy is ‘who used to play for Ajax’ or ‘who has been signed recently for £4m that we can buy for 20x as much?’
There’s no denying that our scouting doesn’t seem to bear much fruit.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
18,511
There's been plenty of strikers who have come up from the championship and looked decent enough to be a no 2 striker for us. If we'd have got either Mitrovic, Toney, Watkins, Wilson we'd have been better off and there's plenty more.

Our issue is we're so focused on the expensive elite players and they still don't always work out.
I'm not sure those players really work in this scenario - it's not like we're buying them based off their recent form, it would be like buying them when they were in the lower leagues before the transfer to their first PL club (otherwise the OP is just should we look at players who at one point were in the lower leagues). Then you have to remeber we're not just saying a mid table PL club might take a chance on them, United even in our worst form recently have been in the CL or fighting to get back into the CL.
  • Mitrovic at Anderlecht (I guess this counts as a lesser league even though it's their best league) was very good. He was well known and there were big clubs in for him like Chelsea. First jump to the PL was ok, he wouldn't have got game time though given we had a lot of strikers in 2015. (RVP, Rooney, Wellbeck, Chicha, Falcao)
  • Toney wasn't particularly amazing at Northampton, he did not do enough to break into the Newcastle squad in his first jump to the PL, also in 2015.
  • Watkins maybe is an outlier here, he was v good for Brentford in the Champ. He was behind Mitrovic in the golden boot race that year but being younger I could have seen a mid table PL club going for him. I am sure we scout the Championship and even though I like him he'd have cost a lot of money + not sure he was good enough at that time.
  • Wilson I am a big fan of, I used to say on here we should sign him back in the Bournemouth days but he has cruciate and hamstring issues and you only need to look at the difference between his Championship season (20 goals and 12 assists) and the seasons which followed for him to see the risk. Season ending cruciate injury 2015, season ending cruciate injury 2016, he only really had his first good PL season 3 years after coming up and then he had some ok seasons until last year.
 

SadlerMUFC

Thinks for himself
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
5,757
Location
Niagara Falls, Canada
Yes. We should be looking in South America in particular. I've already read that Fiorentina is looking at signing Lucas Beltran from River Plate. He's a 22 year old striker who would probably cost them around 12m. Problem is, our fans don't seem to do well with signings like this. If we sign a player from South American for such a low price, the Caf would go into meltdown. Our supporters would much rather have a club like Fiorentina sign him for 12m, and then have us sign him a year or 2 later for 70m. It's all about the status. Can't have guys nobody's heard of...
 

Longlivekeano

Full Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2003
Messages
2,832
Location
Singapore
I think there’s prob some talents in lower leagues. Been quite a few. sharpey from Torquay, Smalling from lower leagues, ben foster…
 

MegadrivePerson

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2022
Messages
1,639
I was hoping we could take a look at Ben Brereton since he was available on a free. Could play anywhere across the front and a pretty fast player as well. Not the best, but a decent backup nonetheless.
He's signed for Villarreal?
 

BAMSOLA

Has issues!
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
10,991
Location
"You know why I'm here" - Marshawn Lynch
Supports
A Crack Habit.
Yes and the following would be good places to start

Jonathan David - lille
Iheanacho - Leicester
Santiago Gimenez - Feyenoord
Gift Orban - Gent

I also agree South America would be a good place to look also.
 

Champ

Refuses to acknowledge existence of Ukraine
Joined
Jun 17, 2017
Messages
9,892
I see this thread has become another one to berate our vast scouting department with little to no evidence to do so.

United routinely purchase young players from other academies, routinely scout every continent looking for promising players.

Not many top European teams buy 'prospects' or players from lower leagues very often, not sure why United should be any different.
 

el3mel

New Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,736
Location
Egypt
Weghorst was a brilliant success so we should do it even more now.
 

Adebisi's Hat

Full Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2014
Messages
779
Location
Out Wesht
Supports
who do you feckin think ?
Yes and the following would be good places to start

Jonathan David - lille
Iheanacho - Leicester
Santiago Gimenez - Feyenoord
Gift Orban - Gent

I also agree South America would be a good place to look also.
Gift Orban - Gent - I love this dude, he will be the next big thing
 

Ali Dia

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
14,538
Location
Souness's Super Sub/George Weahs Talented Cousin
Yes this really bugs me and always has. Højlund is a Utd fan and we could have gotten him on the cheap from Austria or Denmark and loaned him out for a season or two. I’m sure he’d have been up for it seeing as he’s pushing so hard for this move now. Why do we wait until everyone and their granny is after the player and all value and transfer upside is lost?

We scout these players for ages we should be going in early and hard. Let Madrid or PSG or whoever faff about considering their options. We are playing catch up so we need to be decisive. Our approach in the market which has frankly been a total failure has us struggling with FFP? One of the richest clubs in the world. It’s really early days but we believe you are the type of player that will bring us back to the top table here’s a contract that will pay you world class money when you hit the heights.

Anyway in this window I would like us to get a physically strong striker such as Højlund and a speedy finisher. Like Moukoko or Adeymi or something like that. A highly rated punt so that if it doesn’t work out everyone moves on without much fuss. There is value out there we are just crap at finding it or acting on it fast enough.
 

Adebisi's Hat

Full Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2014
Messages
779
Location
Out Wesht
Supports
who do you feckin think ?
Yep and given his rumoured release clause is under 20mil I'm surprised we don't take a chance, has great off the ball movement and finishing and could be the next big name in terms of goal scorers in European football.
He would take time to adapt but surely he would not be that far off Hojlund in that respect, if his form continues into next season there will be a big battle for him in summer 24. This is the type of lad that Ajax or Dortmund will hoover up and sell on for mad money in a few seasons.

That all said i do like what the club are doing in going for potential with Hojlund.
 
Last edited:

Gandalf

Full Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2018
Messages
4,900
Location
Alabama but always Wales in my heart
Yes and the following would be good places to start

Jonathan David - lille
Iheanacho - Leicester
Santiago Gimenez - Feyenoord
Gift Orban - Gent

I also agree South America would be a good place to look also.
The latter two I would agree with. David is priced higher than Hojlund though and is very meh and Iheanacho is at his right level in the Championship.
 

Offside

Euro 2016 sweepstake winner
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
26,902
Location
London
Absolutely. Nicholas Jackson has been impressive for Chelsea so far, and he was bought on the cheap. But some people will say there's no good striker on the market for cheap. I think our scouting team and manager needs to up their game.
A few good pre season performances from the biggest flopped striker graveyard in the world and we should shift our transfer strategy.
 

Red Devil 26

Premature Examination
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
3,348
Location
Sydenham
I’d be more shocked if we scouted anywhere for players. Our strategy is ‘who used to play for Ajax’ or ‘who has been signed recently for £4m that we can buy for 20x as much?’
This. Scouting players for United must be the easiest gig in the world.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
58,219
Location
Krakow
Yes this really bugs me and always has. Højlund is a Utd fan and we could have gotten him on the cheap from Austria or Denmark and loaned him out for a season or two. I’m sure he’d have been up for it seeing as he’s pushing so hard for this move now. Why do we wait until everyone and their granny is after the player and all value and transfer upside is lost?

We scout these players for ages we should be going in early and hard. Let Madrid or PSG or whoever faff about considering their options. We are playing catch up so we need to be decisive. Our approach in the market which has frankly been a total failure has us struggling with FFP? One of the richest clubs in the world. It’s really early days but we believe you are the type of player that will bring us back to the top table here’s a contract that will pay you world class money when you hit the heights.

Anyway in this window I would like us to get a physically strong striker such as Højlund and a speedy finisher. Like Moukoko or Adeymi or something like that. A highly rated punt so that if it doesn’t work out everyone moves on without much fuss. There is value out there we are just crap at finding it or acting on it fast enough.
Hojlund was pretty much unknown before Atalanta. He was struggling for game time at Copenhagen where he scored 0 goals, and had a decent but not phenomenal run with Sturm Graz where he only played 18 times and scored 9 goals. You would not have expected top teams to really have much interest in him.
 

Ali Dia

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
14,538
Location
Souness's Super Sub/George Weahs Talented Cousin
Hojlund was pretty much unknown before Atalanta. He was struggling for game time at Copenhagen where he scored 0 goals, and had a decent but not phenomenal run with Sturm Graz where he only played 18 times and scored 9 goals. You would not have expected top teams to really have much interest in him.
Then we need to improve our scouting? Look at Brentford finding PL level strikers on the cheap. Watkins and Toney would walk into our team to this day. Even fecking Maupay would have played a lot for us last season. There’s no point in us shopping at the top table once the player is a fully known quantity because if they are truly top class they are most likely going to choose Madrid Barca or Bayern over us. We aren’t the draw we once were. We can’t get any edge like that apart from the fact that we are prepared to give big wages but at that point big wages are a given and other factors come into play.
 

thegregster

Harbinger of new information
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
13,640
Tom Cannon. Everton player on loan at Preston. Only 2 years left on his contact.


 

flappyjay

Full Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2016
Messages
5,973
I agree with this. A deal not too different to that of Dan James. You bring someone to come be 2nd choice for cheap they can turn out like a chicharito or a mame biram diouf. Either way they will be on low money and easy to move on. We did make a profit on dan james when he turned out not to be United quality. Similar to Pellestri if we want to let him go he won't be a financial headache to the club.