It's going to happen so let's open the thread now.
My thoughts are maybe.
My thoughts are maybe.
So... Was it a red? (Casemiro / Hughes Royal Rumble)
- Thread starter Vidyoyo
- Start date
easy red
You can't have both hands around a player's neck like that. If it was one of theirs against one of ours we would rightly be calling for a red and I would have been livid if that had not been given had it happened to one of our players
Yes. You can't have your hands round someone's neck like that. Foolish and I think he knew that too
One of those, I can see why but it's also harsh as I've seen worst that hasn't been a red.
Obviously.
Yes, can't put your hands round the neck on another player
Possibly, but shouldn't VAR only intervene for a clear and obvious error. I don't think it was either. Happy that we've got a team that sticks up for each other.
His hands clearly fell on his neck. It's just a storm in a teacup
Not anywhere near violent conduct for me. Looked like he was just trying to stop Hughes from assaulting someone
Yes clear red, stupid from Casemiro
It’s a show of affection in Brazil
Yeah, that was a red. So unnecessary. But great fight all around. Gotta protect our fidget spinner.
you can't strangle the opposition.Slow motion replay made it look worse, but it’s a red all day. Didn’t need to get involved, as I said before, don’t give the ref a decision to make
You cant have your hands around the neck of a opposition player. Straight red and deservedly so.
It was bound to happen for someone on our team. Shame it's Casemiro though.
No. He was holding his collar of his shirt the whole time. The moment and angle the VAR showed the ref made it look like Casemiro was choking him. If you're making ref go and look at it, feckin show him the whole thing.
That is not even a yellow in Brazil, sign of affection.
You can't have your hands around another players neck.
Stupid from Case and he's one of the senior players and should have led by example to defuse the situation.
Stupid from Case and he's one of the senior players and should have led by example to defuse the situation.
Not even remotely, imo. If that was a red, then a few Palace players there should have definitely been sent off as well.
The funds were just resting on his neck
No chance 
Games gone soft FFS
Games gone soft FFS
I can't believe Casemiro is that brainless. Our best player probably but has to be smarter there.
If var says to the ref did you see case and he says no, they have to step in
It’s a red.
Of course. Easy decision
of course it was a red and it was a very good use of VAR unfortunately for us. None of the refs could have seen that and it was rightfully brought back
Casemiro was a red
But ref performance after that was a shambles
But ref performance after that was a shambles
Clear red. If he didn't have his hands on him as long as he did he may have gotten a yellow only.
Yeah, you don't do that unless someone asks you to.
Fred slapped him at some point so he'd have been off as well
That's a red
Both true
Bizarre that’s violent conduct but the tackle on Eriksen wasn’t, it’s a yellow at most, this happens all the time when there’s handbags.
It's a red, but If weasel cnut Robertson runs in and does the same in a Liverpool match, they don't even look at it.
Obvious red.
Antony being a dickhead caused this by the way.
Antony being a dickhead caused this by the way.
Sadly its a red. Strangulation still deemed violent in this pussy foot league.
Should just chokeslam Hughes to the ground. Marriner was nitpicked about those sequences though. Palace's players should get more than a yellow. Prick.