This is a tough one. As someone who has had mental health issues myself, I certainly have sympathy. Yet, there will always be an element to life which is about survival of the fittest, and in competitive sports there is the safest possible version of that. To be the best you have to have not only the physical goods but the mental toughness too. If Osaka is finding that hard, she doesn’t have to do it anymore. She made 55mm last year. She’ll be fine if she packs it in.
I feel the way she has gone about this is all wrong. She should have gone to the tournament organisers privately and explained to them her mental health issues and seen if something could’ve been worked out. By all accounts all four grand slam organisers have attempted to talk to her in the wake of her initial proclamation, and not had any response. So to be honest I am not sure what she or anyone else is expecting.
She essentially posted on social media that she would be violating some very clearly mandatory requirements of her job, acknowledged she would be sanctioned for it, and so implicitly conveyed that she didn’t care. She then ignored attempts by organisers to contact her, played a match, and promptly broke afore mentioned rules. She’s now quitting the tournament because she was sanctioned….. She backed everyone else into a corner over this and is surprised they defended the integrity of their competition rules? She honestly shouldn’t have shown up if she was unable to handle the pressure.
Mental health issues are very real, and support is needed for everyone suffering from them. But the sufferers themselves have to also help themselves. If you can’t handle pressure, then it seems unrealistic to have a high pressure job. You can’t be a CEO, for instance, but then not comply with regulatory or compliance issues because you don’t like dealing with pressure situations. Just like you probably shouldn’t become a professional tennis player with tons of endorsements, if you don’t like being in the public eye. Incidentally, there is no mention in her complaint about not being able to handle the pressure of very well paid public appearances for sponsors. Just for unpaid press ones where people may ask tough questions.
All in all I think this has been handled very poorly all around. I hope Osaka finds her peace, and to do that it seems like she should take some time off tennis. Her first step should be to see a therapist.