devilish
Juventus fan who used to support United
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2002
- Messages
- 61,714
We conceded 36 goals last season as compared to the 54 goals conceded the year before. However 2018-2019 was a disastrous season for us with Mourinho losing the dressing room and his job and Ole coming in the mid terms to save the season. If you had to compare last season to the years before that then you'll notice that we had conceded more goals last season (36) with Maguire then we conceded in 2017-2018 (28), 2016-2017 (29) and 2015-2016 (35). Regarding your 'we weakened Leicester by taking Maguire off their hands' argument that doesn't really make sense. Leicester had conceded less goals last season (43) without Maguire then the season before (48) and the 2017-2018 season (60). In few words their defence seem to have improved. Leicester has conceded less goals this season (17 goals) then we did (21) but as said it's still early days.Funny that, isn't it. We finished 6th in 2019, Maguire came in and and was defensively the difference between us finishing 6th the season before, and 3rd in 2020, where we actually finished. This in turn clinched CL football which can be worth approx £60m-£80m to the club. If he stayed with Leicester, they'd have been defensively better than they were, and we'd have been defensively inferior than we were and as such, we'd have finished 5th at best, more than likely 6th again. This would have cost us the £60m-£80m (in reality we probably made just £30m by qualifying for the CL due to being knocked out at the group stages). So don't you see sometimes you've got to speculate to accumulate in football. Paying £80m instead of the £40m-£50m he's probably worth in reality, secured us CL football and going forward we're showing that consistency and are currently in 3rd place with a game in hand. This is progress and consistency we've never seen post-Fergie. You could argue the fee paid for itself in one season due to receiving £30m+ for qualifying and playing in the CL group stages.
On top of that, we had the best clean sheet record in world football last season, we made significant progress in every competition we played in, 3 semi finals. Its not the finished article in terms of where we are as a football club, but Maguire is an essential jigsaw piece. Having someone there for 55-60 games, never being injured, providing stability, scoring goals, playing his part in clean sheets and the teams defensive output is absolutely crucial. It's laughable people call him error prone. Everyone makes errors. VVD makes errors, Joe Gomez makes errors, Laporte makes errors, Upamecano makes errors. Do you home in on Maguire because of his fee? Because he's ours? Because he got into a fight on holiday? Because people call him slabhead? I'm curious, whats the agenda? Critics disappear when he marshalls us to a brilliant defensive performance thats required to get us over the line when we surrender possession for the last 15 mins of games.
Secondly, Ole isn't the only Manchester United manager that wanted Maguire. Jose Mourinho also wanted him, and was publicly critical of the board for not delivering Maguire! Mourinho would have Maguire now, so if we hadn't have gone for Maguire, not only would we have finished 5th at best last season, we'd now no doubt be behind Spurs in the league, instead of ahead of them. City also wanted him, but we got him. Yet some of our own moan about £80m like its their own friggin cash. We commercial out-perform every club in the league, and beyond so what difference does it make if we pay £60m or £80m? Next time out we have more money available, to buy players.
Thirdly, it was Woodward & Judge who decide the fees, not Ole. Ole gives his list of priorities, just like Jose used to, just like every manager in the PL does. To think Ole is sat with Leicester officials with a blank cheque saying he'll pay whatever they want is absurd.
CBs that are record transfer signings tend to create a paradigm shift in the team. Jaap Stam was the missing piece United needed to win the treble. Rio Ferdinand came into a defence that leaked 45 goals and reduced that to 34 goals. Both had the class, the pace, the leadership and the overall talent to elevate the defence. Maguire is a strong unit and nothing more. He lacks leadership, he lacks football intelligence and he lack pace. It took us just few months for us to start talking about the dire need of us bringing in a top quality CB to do the thinking and the running for him. If thing doesn't work out with a 30m signing then he can easily be sent on the bench or sold. There's no chance either Ole or a new manager would be able to do that to an 80m CB. It makes the club and the manager look silly.
Finally we knew exactly that Maguire would cost big money to come to the club. There's no way Leicester would have sold him to us for anything less. So let's not blame Woodward on this one. The only thing I do blame Woody is for not hiring a top DOF. Someone with some brains would not have allowed this signing to happen, not on those fees.