The 4-4-2 Draft

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,331
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
Don't mind the concept in theory, but in practice it looks a little cluttered.

I think mandating everyone to have the same basic formation template (i.e. a 4-4-2 shape using sharemytactics) so they can be presented side-by-side and look similar would achieve the same objective.
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
Gio said:
but in practice it looks a little cluttered.
Click to expand...
I will checkout if there is a better website than SMT where it might look cleaner
Gio said:
so they can be presented side-by-side and look similar would achieve the same objective.
Click to expand...
I do like the idea of seeing the wing battles and midfield battles in close quarters
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. Benarrivo
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. Hansen
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. Armfield
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. Mazzola
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. Vieiri
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. Terry
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. Camacho
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. Varane
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. Haaland

@Earvin Johnson
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
P.S: The idea wont be adopted unless there is a 75% consensus, dont want to try it if almost half the guys dont like it even if less than 50%
 
Last edited:

Šjor Bepo

Wout is love, Wout is life; all hail Wout!
Joined
Mar 29, 2011
Messages
15,653
Gio said:
Don't mind the concept in theory, but in practice it looks a little cluttered.

I think mandating everyone to have the same basic formation template (i.e. a 4-4-2 shape using sharemytactics) so they can be presented side-by-side and look similar would achieve the same objective.
Click to expand...
This
 

Lord SInister

Full Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2015
Messages
2,967
Location
where grasses are green and girls are pretty
123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. Benarrivo
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. Hansen
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. Armfield
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. Mazzola
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. Vieiri
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. Terry
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. Camacho
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. Varane
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. HaalandPuyolChiellini
 

Lord SInister

Full Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2015
Messages
2,967
Location
where grasses are green and girls are pretty
GodShaveTheQueen said:
Its not a GSTQ draft without a bit of experimentation, so I would like to propose an idea for the match threads

1. The OP will have a single formation graphic with both teams
2. Colour will always be red and blue, names will always be small letters so its not an eye sore. The match poll will indicate colour of manager's team
3. Since all teams will only play the 4-4-2 formation, the graphic should look symmetric and clean, so its kind of an ideal draft to try this.
4. The idea is that it would lead to a more direct visualization of the various battles on the pitch and hence enhanced discussions (maybe)
5. The graphic will have a single template and will be created by the draft mod, you just need to submit your starting lineup with positions
6. No arrows, no asymmetry, no one fullback forward - one fullback backward, you explain all that in your OP.
7. Your tactics can have a separate formation graphic if you want to add arrows or want to explain certain thing or interactions between players, but it should be in a spoiler.
8. I have created a poll to get a general consensus on whether you guys want to go ahead with this experiment, please vote.

Below is an example graphic

Click to expand...
I am fine with this one.
 

Pat_Mustard

I'm so gorgeous they want to put me under arrest!
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
13,806
Location
A never-nude? I thought he just liked cut-offs.
I'll take John Charles @P-Nut


123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. Benarrivo
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. Hansen
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. Armfield
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. Mazzola
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. Vieiri
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. Terry
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. CamachoJ. Charles
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. VaraneR. Rensenbrink
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. HaalandPuyolChiellini
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
We don't know who will start as our second striker, but we know it will be a damn good one either way we go. We'll take Mr. Florian Albert

@Physiocrat , kindly update the table after you pick.
 

Physiocrat

Has No Mates
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,970
I'll take Tommy Gemmell

123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. Benarrivo
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. Hansen
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. ArmfieldT. Gemmell
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. MazzolaF. Albert
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. VieriAlisson
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. TerryA. Vidal
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. CamachoJ. Charles
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. VaraneR. Rensenbrink
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. HaalandPuyolChiellini

@Edgar Allan Pillow
 

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,417
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬


123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. Benarrivo
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. HansenRaul
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. ArmfieldT. Gemmell
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. MazzolaF. Albert
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. VieriAlisson
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. TerryA. Vidal
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. CamachoJ. Charles
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. VaraneR. Rensenbrink
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. HaalandPuyolChiellini

@Isotope @Himannv
 

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,622

@Zlatan 7

123456789101112
MichaelF. RedondoP. VierchowodP. McGrathA. SpencerM. ColunaE. FrancescoliD. IrwinJ. JoyaLeandroJ. AbbadieJ. L. Chilavert
GioL. FigoR. KrolRivaldoD. SantosG. BergomiR. DonadoniD. GodinCarecaD. MackayS. MaierN. Gonçalves
General/JimP. BreitnerV. VoroninZ. CziborK-H. ForsterV. Van DijkJ. GreavesJ.JohnstoneJuniorD. McGrainA. ShearerR. Dasayev
StobzillaM. DesaillyB. RobsonD. EdwardsR. RivelinoH-P BriegelA. ShesternyovK. HamrinW. RooneyC. FerraraK. BenzemaP. Shilton
ZlatanT. HenryP. VieiraN. VidicD. BergkampG. ZambrottaF. HierroC. SeedorfC. WaddleT. HasslerS. PierceI. Casillas
Iso/HimannvP. NedvedD. PassarellaJ. TiganaP. LittbarskiM. BossisO. RuggeriK. KeeganL. YashinM. KempesB. BremnerA. BenarrivoO. Sivori
EAPD. BeckhamJ. StamL. SuarezM. AmorosH. StoichkovP. ElkjaerM. OvermarsP. EvraDungaD. ZoffA. HansenRaul
PhysiocratT. FinneyG. BatistutaW. van HanegemL. BlancM. TresorM. ZagalloTostaoZitoMarceloG. BanksJ. ArmfieldT. Gemmell
Sjor/GSTQR. FerdinandF. CannavaroB. VogtsA. CabriniB. ContiL. RivaZ. BoniekI. NettoB. SchusterE. van der SarS. MazzolaF. Albert
BorisDeLeForaR. KeaneR. CarlosA. ShevchenkoM. TardelliR. CarvalhoR. PiresS. CampbellE. GeretsG. MendietaD. ForlanC. VieriAlisson
PnutS. Eto'oR. GiggsS. KocsisS. MatthewsA. ColeJ. BozsikM. NeuerLucioD. DeschampsG. NevilleJ. TerryA. Vidal
MustardD. LawB. SchweinsteigerD. AlvesT. SilvaJ. BarnesS. GerrardC. MozerP. SchmeichelK. DalglishJ. PirriJ. CamachoJ. Charles
Earvin JohnsonR. LewandowskiA. IniestaF. TottiC. MakeleleF. RiberyA. PirloR. KoemanG. BuffonJ. AlbaT.A.ArnoldR. VaraneR. Rensenbrink
paulscholes18P. ScholesM. SammerS. RamosC. GentileO. BlokhinL. SuarezG. LatoG.BaleT. BurgnichKH. SchnellingerP. CechE. Cantona
TheReligion/SkizzoE. DavidsU. SeelerL. ModricB. LizarazuF. GentoA. CostacurtaH.ChumpitazA. RobbenA. Del PieroO. KahnM. KaltzL. Enrique
Lord SinisterJairzinhoP. LahmG. SounessN. KanteE. HazardA. DemyanenkoJ. PopluharJ. RepD. DrogbaE. HaalandPuyolChiellini
 
You must log in or register to reply here.