Let me explain, I've been a wrestling fan since I was 6, I'm now 35. I don't like matches because someone attractive is in them, plus Alexa is my girl haha. Imo though, regardless of I'd the majority perceived a match, if I have an emotional response to the work they're doing then to me it's a good match. Given the shitty response you put. Can I ask about you saying experience or are you a casual viewer?
I watched wrestling when I was a kid, didnt have sky for WWF so I had to watch WCW. My best friend got sky and we would watch WWF in the attitude era in 99/2000. Later I got sky myself and continued watching. I watched TNA for a couple of months before the Hogan thing, where he shat all over it and they killed themselves moving to Monday nights. That shit was terrible so I stopped watching it. I carried on watching WWE, albeit enjoying it less and less until the Daniel Bryan booking fiasco. At that point I had more interest in UFC and MMA and stopped watching wrestling.
I gave it another go about 3 years ago. Since then I've been watching WWE, New Japan Pro Wrestling, the occasional Ring of Honor PPV and a lot of indie wrestling promotions, including PROGRESS - wanting to watch certain wrestlers. 2 years or so ago I started watching Stardom, japanese Womens wrestling (the company Io Shirai and Kairi Sane came from). I also started watching some other Joshi promotions for a while, like Ice Ribbon. And EVE, a UK female promotion.
So I'm very well versed in current wrestling standards around the world. To me match quality is a big deal but its not the only thing, there are other ways to be invested too including storylines. Sometimes I know a match will be good but I've seen so many good matches that its not enough. I have to be a bit more invested in the characters and story beyond that - thats one reason I still havent watched last week's NXT show. I know Cole and Riddle will be a really good match as I've seen so many of their matches in the past. But I don't care about their characters and storylines.
As for Carmella I compare her to all the indie, joshi wrestlers, nxt wrestlers and main roster wrestlers and I'm sorry but she's not a good worker. She's a character, she has some attitude and her superkick is fine. She started doing a suicide dive a ways back too, although since everyone does those I consider it a basic move like a clothesline at this point. I refered to her botching, and in particular with her matches against Charlotte. She keeps leaving her feet too early and bumping when Charlotte's boot is nowhere near her, it looks awful like a ghost knocked her over.