Cal?
CR7 fan
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2002
- Messages
- 35,024
Great, another article with no source, just what was needed on the thread.
Red17 said:Just 1 - against Bolton, after Saha started to feature regularly in his place, which was after the Liverpool FA Cup lost. During this period - he scored only 1 other time, against West Ham, where he featured for the full 90 mins.
Taking the Liverpool FA Cup game as the critical event, when he became "disillusioned/disinterested" when Saha featured more regularly in his spot, his stats are these:-
Up till the Liverpool FA Cup game: 138 minutes per goal
Subsequently: 218 minutes per goal (almost a full game extra).
So we now have both stats and naked eye observation to back up what some of us has claimed about his form.
By the way - when I write this - I do not mean to trivialise Ruud (I have the utmost respect for his striking abilities and what he's achieved for United) but just to set the facts/records straight.
WesBrownIsaGod said:he scored twice, you muppet.
Red17 said:He started on the bench in that game and came on to score 2. But that was before Saha began to replace him. He started in all the games before that game except for the 2 Burton Albion games and the Carling SF first leg. After that Blackburn lost, he still featured for the full 90 mins in the next 3 games. The issue here is Ruud's performance after he was "replaced" by Saha, not before that.
Stretch said:Also don't forget Saha only scored 4 goals in that run of 11 (2 of which came in one game!) starts he got, that is by no means so spectacular. I for one to this day do not understand why he got hyped up so much, he really was not that impressive in by no means could his best form ever match Ruud's best form.
Red17 said:For comparison on the same basis - for Saha, to put any of your doubts to rest:
Up till the Liverpool FA Cup game: 127 minutes per goal (Ruud 138 mins/goal)
Subsequently: 155 minutes per goal (Ruud 218 mins/goal).
Stretch said:Did you even read what I wrote? I pointed out that Saha was in top form during his run in the team yet his top form will never compare to what Ruud is like at top form, we just need to look at the first half of the season and then compare Ruud at top form to Saha in top form, there is NO comparison, end off.
irishmanc said:This a weird scenario. The coach (Aguirre) is claiming he's not confident Torres will be an Athletico player next season, whereas his agent claims the opposite. Isn't it meant to be the other way around??![]()
savais said:I really don't understand the Ruud fans that still insist that he IS the best finisher in the world. Last season he was a shadow of himself (most of the season before as well). Then, they blamed Fergie for dropping Ruud, well how do they explain that Van Basten did the very same thing? Yes, Ruud WAS a world class finisher, the best in the business, but nobody can claim that he still holds that title.
The question is will he be able to reproduce the form of his past? Probably not.Stretch said:Did you even read what I wrote? I pointed out that Saha was in top form during his run in the team yet his top form will never compare to what Ruud is like at top form, we just need to look at the first half of the season and then compare Ruud at top form to Saha in top form, there is NO comparison, end off.
Red Dreams said:Torres and Rooney...yeah it will work.
Are you talking to yourself now? I never said he was in the best form of his life throughout the season. You're stating the obvious, and trying to believe you have a point. He had a good season, especially the start, then in the second half he clearly lost form. Thats as obvious to a 3 year old child as it is to anyone. Whether he should have been sold, whether he is 'finished', whether he isnt the best finisher/goalscorer in the world, is debatable.Red17 said:Just 1 - against Bolton, after Saha started to feature regularly in his place, which was after the Liverpool FA Cup lost. During this period - he scored only 1 other time, against West Ham, where he featured for the full 90 mins.
Taking the Liverpool FA Cup game as the critical event, when he became "disillusioned/disinterested" when Saha featured more regularly in his spot, his stats are these:-
Up till the Liverpool FA Cup game: 138 minutes per goal
Subsequently: 218 minutes per goal (almost a full game extra).
So we now have both stats and naked eye observation to back up what some of us has claimed about his form.
By the way - when I write this - I do not mean to trivialise Ruud (I have the utmost respect for his striking abilities and what he's achieved for United) but just to set the facts/records straight.
TheRedFlag said:Forget it you bunch of worthless muppets, he's not coming to United.
Kaiketsu_Zorro said:Rooney + a proven finisher like Toni would work much better IMO.
Longsden_7 said:Tell you what, lets leave the Torres bullshit till :-
A - We see him in a United Shirt
B - We see him in another teams shirt
C - We see him signing a new contract with A.Madrid
SATA said:It's apparent on this forum that Fernando Torres is becoming bigger than Manchester United.
kanchelskis14 said:What crap!
amolbhatia100 said:Are you talking to yourself now? I never said he was in the best form of his life throughout the season. You're stating the obvious, and trying to believe you have a point. He had a good season, especially the start, then in the second half he clearly lost form. Thats as obvious to a 3 year old child as it is to anyone. Whether he should have been sold, whether he is 'finished', whether he isnt the best finisher/goalscorer in the world, is debatable.
amolbhatia100 said:Listen we have a rubbish midfield. Absolutely rubbish. .....
SATA said:Clueless
Typical response from someone who posted an utter load of nonsense without paying attention whats being said.Red17 said:Refresh your memory please by rereading the threads leading up to this .....
Wow. Now we dont need a midfielder either, but Torres is a must. You're on a roll.Red17 said:Well then, it appears that you don't really need to have a midfield to finish 2nd in the league. Actually, if you're referring to basically Giggs-O'Shea as CM then, top of the league, because our points tally in the 2nd half of the season puts us in the No. 1 spot!
amolbhatia100 said:Typical response from someone who posted an utter load of nonsense without paying attention whats being said.
amolbhatia100 said:Wow. Now we dont need a midfielder either, but Torres is a must. You're on a roll.
Red17 said:And you talk about success & loyalty - how about showing just some credit to the likes of O'Shea & Giggs who has held the CM together, against most peoples, including fans, derision.
Mainoldo said:Come on now , yes they did well at the end of the season but we finished 2nd not 1st so it obviously wasn't good enough and the Midfield is definatley a need for drastic improvement. We should only be complementing success like everything in life!
Mainoldo said:Come on now , yes they did well at the end of the season but we finished 2nd not 1st so it obviously wasn't good enough and the Midfield is definatley a need for drastic improvement. We should only be complementing success like everything in life!
Red17 said:Refresh your memory please by rereading the threads leading up to this .....
Well then, it appears that you don't really need to have a midfield to finish 2nd in the league. Actually, if you're referring to basically Giggs-O'Shea as CM then, top of the league, because our points tally in the 2nd half of the season puts us in the No. 1 spot!
londonredmaniac said:It makes no difference mate. Yes we finished second, but an early exit from both champions leage and FA cup exposed our midfield frailties.
Absolutely rubbish....well maybe not....average andputting more pressure on other positions in the side...definately.
If we continue with that midfield dont be expecting us to finish above chelsea, the scousers or the arse
I have. Loads of times. I enjoyed last season. I thought our attacking players in particular were fantastic. Rooney, Ruud in the first half, Saha, Giggs, Ronaldo etc. All of it done playing attractive attacking football. Finishing second behind this Championship manager created Chelsea team is nothing be ashamed of. I give a lot of credit to the Oshea Giggs combination. As you've pointed out, yes we got all those points then.Red17 said:And you talk about success & loyalty - how about showing just some credit to the likes of O'Shea & Giggs who has held the CM together, against most peoples, including fans, derision.
Red17 said:I can agree with that.