I think refereeing has become worse since the introduction of VAR. I think there is a lot of confusion around it. Referees seem to be relying on it, but it is not reliable.
They say that they want to keep the decisions in the hand of the ref, but they don't do that at all. If the VAR doesn't refer the ref, he doesn't ever get to see it again; this makes it the decision of the VAR instead.
It has also led to rules becoming over-complicated; there seem to be far more changes than there used to be. The rules don't even make sense anymore.
I just don't think it works. Bring in automated offsides, keep goal line technology and just scrap the rest of VAR.
Anyone with half a brain understand that there is only one way to use VAR -- and that is not Howard Webb's current path.
When VAR first came, the rules were applied, and people thought that there were too many penalties. To reduce this problem, they didn't change the rules, but instead came up with the brilliant idea to only use VAR if there is a "clear and obvious" error.
In practice, this means that if a ref incorrectly calls a penalty on one side of the pitch for an uber soft shirt pull, it can be reviewed by VAR and stand because it wasn't a clear and obvious mistake, and then 5 minutes later on the other side of the pitch, VAR can review a much worse shirt pull and not award a penalty if the ref missed it, because it wasn't a clear and obvious mistake. And the worst part is perhaps that there is no guidence whatsoever that makes sense on what is 'clear and obvious'. Why was the yellow card on Casemiro such a clear and obvious mistake that they ref had to overturn it and give it a red? Its ridiculous.
Right when Howard Webb took over PGMOL before this season started, he made clear that he was going to put the on-field referee at the center of the stage. Listening to him talk, its just downright absurd. A football game isn't about the referee. One rule book shouldn't apply one game and another rule book the next game -- just because one of these clowns get a feeling for it. But Webb sees the referee as a 'producer' of the game, he wants the guy in black to be like Tarentino or Spielberg or George Lucas or whatever.
If nobody wants the game riddled with soft penalties -- then make that the rules and apply it to everyone. How hard can it be?
And how f***ing absurd is it that the guy on the pitch goes out and watch a monitor.
Sure, there will -- always -- be controversies and no system will ever (even remotely) be perfect. But its just so obvious how these clowns don't understand how extremely frustrating it is for fans when the reffing is extremely inconsistent -- despite them getting to watch it in slow-motion from 100 different angles.