- Jul 7, 2013
Yeah that's pretty much what I meant but without explicitly stating it.. it's recency bias. When I look at Tuchel's career, I see that he did pretty well at Dortmund, meh at PSG, and good at Chelsea. But he still needs to win the PL before seriously entering this discussion, that's the one thing he does not have in common with the other two. Longevity is another one, but that comes in time.All managers you mention reached the CL final years ago. And I remember a significant amount of people on the Caf treating Poch like the second coming, so yes at that time he was in the discussion, despite him winning nothing compared to Tuchel.
When discussing who I rate right now the most I will definitely look at recent performances, not so much at what happened years ago.