Your best United team (past 40 years)

[Livvie]

Schmeichel 247

Neville 203
Stam 139
Bruce
Irwin 218

Best 191
Charlton 129
Keane 180
Giggs 205

Cantona 173
Law 133


This would be the reserve team:

Van Der Sar 8

Parker 12
Pallister 72
Rio 56
Heinze 25

Beckham 52
Robson 128
Scholes 74
Ronaldo 46

Ruud 85
Ole 39


In my humble, Paul McGrath should have been there instead of Rio (McGrath was one vote behind), and I'd choose Kanchelskis on the right wing - he had 23.

I wouldn't like to say which team would win if they played each other tbh!

 

[ruudvanrooney]

Schmeichel 247

Neville 203
Stam 139
Bruce
Irwin 218

Best 191
Charlton 129
Keane 180
Giggs 205

Cantona 173
Law 133


This would be the reserve team:

Van Der Sar 8

Parker 12
Pallister 72
Rio 56
Heinze 25

Beckham 52
Robson 128
Scholes 74
Ronaldo 46

Ruud 85
Ole 39


In my humble, Paul McGrath should have been there instead of Rio (McGrath was one vote behind), and I'd choose Kanchelskis on the right wing - he had 23.

I wouldn't like to say which team would win if they played each other tbh!

thanks for all your efforts livvie,agree on the mcgrath thing he was one of the best defenders in the world and its a shame that injury and booze stopped him from becoming a legend

 

[a_devil_inside]

can we have the team play in this kit

 

[noodlehair]

We've had some amount of fecking amazing midfield players there

No wonder we act so spoilt

 

[Jacob]

Schmeichel 247

Neville 203
Stam 139
Bruce
Irwin 218

Best 191
Charlton 129
Keane 180
Giggs 205

Cantona 173
Law 133


This would be the reserve team:

Van Der Sar 8

Parker 12
Pallister 72
Rio 56
Heinze 25

Beckham 52
Robson 128
Scholes 74
Ronaldo 46

Ruud 85
Ole 39


In my humble, Paul McGrath should have been there instead of Rio (McGrath was one vote behind), and I'd choose Kanchelskis on the right wing - he had 23.

I wouldn't like to say which team would win if they played each other tbh!

Good to see Ronaldo among the best

 

[paul teague]

Peter the great
Parker Bruce Mcgrath Irwin

Best Keane Charlton Giggs

Law Ruud VN

subs
Cantona
Stam
VDS
Robson

 

[Livvie]

Peter the great
Parker Bruce Mcgrath Irwin

Best Keane Charlton Giggs

Law Ruud VN

subs
Cantona
Stam
VDS
Robson

Nice idea, but the votes have been cast and the polls closed. They are in the Polls forum if you want to have a look.

 

[Livvie]

thanks for all your efforts livvie,

Thank you.

 

[Broo]

Schmeichel 247

Neville 203
Stam 139
Bruce
Irwin 218

Best 191
Charlton 129
Keane 180
Giggs 205

Cantona 173
Law 133

The exact team I voted for. It seems that great minds think alike.

Cheers for the effort, by the way.

 

[Sultan]

Livvie, can I propose a recount by Weaste?

Mcgrath not being there is a travesty.

 

[ERICSAGOD]

Peter the great
Parker Bruce Mcgrath Irwin

Best Keane Charlton Giggs

Law Ruud VN

subs
Cantona
Stam
VDS
Robson

Muppet!

 

[Livvie]

Livvie, can I propose a recount by Weaste?

Mcgrath not being there is a travesty.

Absolutely.

Unfortunately, people vote for who they have seen, and not too many saw McGrath.

So basically, the poll is crap.

 

[CnutOfAllCnuts]

In my humble, Paul McGrath should have been there instead of Rio (McGrath was one vote behind)

McGrath should have been in there instead of Bruce

 

[Livvie]

McGrath should have been in there instead of Bruce

Shall we have a poll?

 

[CnutOfAllCnuts]

Shall we have a poll?

I bet you've had Poll already, you slag

 

[Tribec]

I stand before the judge here, and honestly swear that in the voting for the centre half's I made 1 choice instead of 2. I actually thought we only had 1 vote.

I would have put McGrath in the team with Stam, so that lost vote could have put him in the team...... I'll serve my punishment (as long as it's not supporting the dirties this weekend) quietly for this crime of general muppetry.

 

[Livvie]

I bet you've had Poll already, you slag

That's an unnecessary and insulting remark. Not a nice thing to say to a lady. Or to me. I mean - as if Poll would interest me......

 

[CnutOfAllCnuts]

That's an unnecessary and insulting remark. Not a nice thing to say to a lady. Or to me. I mean - as if Poll would interest me......

No one could resist your beauty, intelligence and charm.

Or your fantastic boobs.

 

[Livvie]

No one could resist your beauty, intelligence and charm.

Or your fantastic boobs.

Right on all counts.

 

[Giggsy PO]

I would expect higher numbers for Best and Keano.

 

[Livvie]

Only two of the current team make it, but six of the current team make the reserves.

 

[topper]

McGrath should have been in there instead of Bruce

and Foulkes should be there sfore McGrath

 

[topper]

Absolutely.

Unfortunately, people vote for who they have seen, and not too many saw McGrath.

So basically, the poll is crap.

agree Livvie - Cantona having more votes than the GENUINE King is a joke as the piss poor reaction of voters to George

 

[Simieski]

McGrath >>>>>>>>>> Bruce

 

[Livvie]

Why did no-one notice or comment that Rooney got left out!

Bollox.

We might have to do the strikers again.

 

[Man Utd Mrs]

The exact team I voted for. It seems that great minds think alike.

Cheers for the effort, by the way.

That is a great team...and then some.

 

[Giggsy PO]

Why did no-one notice or comment that Rooney got left out!

Bollox.

We might have to do the strikers again.

and include Forlan too

 

[eric le roi]

Why did no-one notice or comment that Rooney got left out!

Bollox.

We might have to do the strikers again.

I don't even think Rooney is a striker as such. His game is about so much more than scoring goals.
I think there should be a special category for him.

 

[original muppet]

Schmeichel 247

Neville 203
Stam 139
Bruce
Irwin 218

Best 191
Charlton 129
Keane 180
Giggs 205

Cantona 173
Law 133


!

You can tell the majority of users in this place are kids.

 

[bcubed]

What you have to remember is that most people who are old enough to have seen McGrath, couldn't even switch a computer on let alone deal with the general lack of intelligence, and abundance of muppetry, on this site. Me personally, I think much the same travesty has been committed by a lack of Martin Buchan in the showings. Then i'm an old fart -now, how the feck do I switch this thing off?

 

[bcubed]

I don't even think Rooney is a striker as such. His game is about so much more than scoring goals.
I think there should be a special category for him.

There is - if he carries on at the rate he is going - he will be promoted to a God. Sadly not won too much or been at the club long enough to force his way past the other choices.

 

[thoward]

Absolutely.

Unfortunately, people vote for who they have seen, and not too many saw McGrath.

So basically, the poll is crap.

Well at least some would have seen McGrath but there are players from the 50s and 60s who would have probably got in there if only people over 60 or 70 had voted. Hughes could be considered unlucky not to be ahead of Ole for instance as well.

 

[topper]

Well at least some would have seen McGrath but there are players from the 50s and 60s who would have probably got in there if only people over 60 or 70 had voted. Hughes could be considered unlucky not to be ahead of Ole for instance as well.

probably probably

Duncan Edwards would have strolled in and Roger Byrne too - maybe even Tommy Taylor

 

[original muppet]

Johnny Carey, Stopper!! Don't forget him.

 

[kf]

What you have to remember is that most people who are old enough to have seen McGrath, couldn't even switch a computer on let alone deal with the general lack of intelligence, and abundance of muppetry, on this site. Me personally, I think much the same travesty has been committed by a lack of Martin Buchan in the showings. Then i'm an old fart -now, how the feck do I switch this thing off?

My team had Buchan and Foulkes as the centre backs and an honourable mention for Mr McGrath.

 

[Livvie]

and include Forlan too

You think he would get ahead of Cantona, Law, Ruud, Ole.....or even Teddy?

 

[topper]

My team had Buchan and Foulkes as the centre backs and an honourable mention for Mr McGrath.

ditto the first two

 

[mista john]

I wouldn't like to say which team would win if they played each other tbh!

Good stuff Livvie. My team was the same as that chosen (which makes me a bit of a sheep) except I had Pally next to Bruce as they had a great understanding, or something like that. Cheers.

 

[Giggsy PO]

You think he would get ahead of Cantona, Law, Ruud, Ole.....or even Teddy?

No but there should be equality of chanches.

GB would vote for him for sure.

 

[SmashedHombre]

Quality team that. What a wealth of talent we have had.

I wish i had been arsed to vote