SER19
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 15, 2008
- Messages
- 12,847
I know this isnt exactly new information but having just looked at the squad again now it has hit me that as much as we need a midfielder we need a new player in probably every single position apart from goalkeeper. The degree to which this squad is about to be ripped apart is almost unprecedented and I cant see how this has happened given 2 years ago we were salivating at all of our talented youth. I suppose the easy answer is that, while good players, smalling,evans,jones,fabio, anderson have not progressed to the level many hoped....yet anyway.
This isnt a thread to argue and criticise all of the players you dont like but rather try optimistically see how we can challenge for a title again soon. I think the amount of changes mean we should be aiming for a challenge for the title in 2015/2016 at the earliest.
Im going to put in blue the players that i think will leave over the next 4 windows and mark in red where replacements will be needed, and when it gets to midfield and wings obviously we cant lose everyone so Ive just made a random selection.
Right Back: Rafael, Back up right back, (varela?)
Centre Back: Smalling, Jones, Evans, Vidic, Ferdinand, Centre Back, Back up Centre Back
Left Back: Evra, Buttner, Fabio, for one reason or another i can see all 3 leaving meaning we will need left back, back up left back
Central Midfield: Carrick, Fletcher, Cleverley, Fellaini, Giggs, Anderson, Central Midfield a, central midfield
Wingers/AM: Valencia, Young, Januzaj, Zaha, Kagawa, Nani,
Forwards: Rooney, Van Persie, Welbeck, Hernandez, Forward, Possible world class forward if rooney leaves
I dont think anything there is unreasonable and that forecast includes kagawa, rooney, young still being here. So we could see 10 players leave and a need for 8-9 new ones, while hopefully Powell and Lingard develop.
I think we wont see the big signing we all hope for in january but moyes would be sensible to do what fergie did with vidic and evra and draft in some of the players that may be easier to get just now (people mentioning the likes of astori and coentrao). we cant afford to blend too many at once and while people might scratch their head if we buy 2 defenders now for example, longer term it wouldnt be a bad idea. Off the top of my head without having a clue of what players we're looking at the world over, I see out next title challengeing squad being something like:
De Gea, Lindegaard
Rafael (probably smalling still being shifted right as needed)
Smalling, Jones, Evans, Astori, Mangala
Coentrao, Left back
Carrick, Fellaini, Fletcher, Cleverley, Herrera, Gundogan
Di Maria, Januzaj, Young, Zaha, Kagawa
Rooney, Van Persie, Welbeck, Striker
Its so hard to get your head around even just doing it casually at the computer, Moyes must be daunted by the challenge left. Even the likes of rooney and van persie are far from guaranteed to be here. Hopefully somebody can come up with a better solution to mine!
This isnt a thread to argue and criticise all of the players you dont like but rather try optimistically see how we can challenge for a title again soon. I think the amount of changes mean we should be aiming for a challenge for the title in 2015/2016 at the earliest.
Im going to put in blue the players that i think will leave over the next 4 windows and mark in red where replacements will be needed, and when it gets to midfield and wings obviously we cant lose everyone so Ive just made a random selection.
Right Back: Rafael, Back up right back, (varela?)
Centre Back: Smalling, Jones, Evans, Vidic, Ferdinand, Centre Back, Back up Centre Back
Left Back: Evra, Buttner, Fabio, for one reason or another i can see all 3 leaving meaning we will need left back, back up left back
Central Midfield: Carrick, Fletcher, Cleverley, Fellaini, Giggs, Anderson, Central Midfield a, central midfield
Wingers/AM: Valencia, Young, Januzaj, Zaha, Kagawa, Nani,
Forwards: Rooney, Van Persie, Welbeck, Hernandez, Forward, Possible world class forward if rooney leaves
I dont think anything there is unreasonable and that forecast includes kagawa, rooney, young still being here. So we could see 10 players leave and a need for 8-9 new ones, while hopefully Powell and Lingard develop.
I think we wont see the big signing we all hope for in january but moyes would be sensible to do what fergie did with vidic and evra and draft in some of the players that may be easier to get just now (people mentioning the likes of astori and coentrao). we cant afford to blend too many at once and while people might scratch their head if we buy 2 defenders now for example, longer term it wouldnt be a bad idea. Off the top of my head without having a clue of what players we're looking at the world over, I see out next title challengeing squad being something like:
De Gea, Lindegaard
Rafael (probably smalling still being shifted right as needed)
Smalling, Jones, Evans, Astori, Mangala
Coentrao, Left back
Carrick, Fellaini, Fletcher, Cleverley, Herrera, Gundogan
Di Maria, Januzaj, Young, Zaha, Kagawa
Rooney, Van Persie, Welbeck, Striker
Its so hard to get your head around even just doing it casually at the computer, Moyes must be daunted by the challenge left. Even the likes of rooney and van persie are far from guaranteed to be here. Hopefully somebody can come up with a better solution to mine!