Mata has been excellent, and ahead of Smalling as our best player this first half. Especially lovely to watch the Spaniard when he's in the mood. Darmian's my pick to up his game, since he's the only defender on our side who can't say he's had a good half. He'll be weary with a yellow hanging over his head though so I wouldn't mind him shifting for Valencia at this point. Depay, bright though he looks, needs to start turning dangerous situations into clear chances- but with the way he's taking the game to Mbemba it's only a matter of time. Januzaj and Rooney look sharp but their not getting on the ball enough in areas that have decisive importance.
A decent half of football, but a higher tempo shouldn't mean sloppier play in the middle third. Should have capitalised on our domination when we were on top because Newcastle look content to nick something on the counter down Darmian's side.