What's really pathetic is the idea that you need to have won silverware at all in order to have history. As far as I'm concerned the likes of Carlisle or Oxford have just as much history as either Chelsea, United or Liverpool. In fact their fans probably deserve more respect, because they've stood by their teams for over a century despite never having a glamorous period.
As for what you consider worthy of pride, I really couldn't give a feck. Unless you're in your sixties, you almost certainly started supporting Liverpool while they were highly successful, which makes you a glory hunting plastic as far as I'm concerned.